Alert icon
We're changing our privacy policy. This stuff matters.  Learn more  Dismiss

The doctor who hears voices part 2

Loading...

Sign in or sign up now!
9,936
Loading...
Alert icon
Sign in or sign up now!
Alert icon

Uploaded by on Oct 30, 2008

No description available.

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

License:

Standard YouTube License

  • likes, 1 dislikes

Link to this comment:

Share to:

Uploader Comments (jenni560)

  • This comment does not even warrant intelligent debate! I wouldn't even know how to engage with you at such a low level.

  • This critic of psychiatry is, it appears, employed by the health service. Any real enemy would not be allowed into a debate with a leading psychiatrist. Rufus May just remodels schizophrenia instead of debunking it. There is no "schizophrenia" of any sort in the fist place but that fact would put May out of business.

  • Again a massive assumption here that being employed by the health service means you cannot be opposed to the practices of another member or 'enemy' as you put it. Of course a real 'enemy' would be allowed into the debate, this is part of the reason Rufus wanted to go into the health service in the first place!

  • The second point you made makes a little more sense but there are problems again! Rufus is trying to argue that there is no catch all category called 'schizophrenia' but he does not deny the individual experiences of people hearing voices or experiencing 'delusions'. Clumping them all together is clearly unhelpful but it is not wrong to say that a person might want some support to understand a very real experience of hearing voices.

  • "If I told this to a normal person,,," chortles one of Mr May's "patients". Thus the untruth of hearing voices gives this person a certain status as being different. Wise up to it people.

  • Are you saying that these voices are all lies, people don't really hear them?

Top Comments

  • I think that one problem is that society places too much demand on each individual to "Succeed " in life. People try there best to succeed in life that they forget about innerselves and live a life that is comparitable to some other persons life. This could seem like too much on the mind and we suffer mentally from our failures of approaching this ideal picture in society. Everybody around us just pushes us. Find yourself within, you can can find some solutions to your mental anguish.

see all

All Comments (34)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This "doctor" is a true dumbass!

  • i agree with this doctor meds suppress the thoughts and sht..the thoughts wud eventually come back...

  • I absolutely LOVE the silence that follows after Rufus puts that 'leading psychiatrist' in his place when he reveals that HE HIMSELF was one of his patients!

    EPIC FAIL.

  • @jenni560

    Its people like this "RickMoonbeam" that somehow establish themselves as doctors and propagate ludicrous treatments such as EST and frontal lobotomy's - which clinically acceptable procedures not long ago - wherein if you (regardless of your professional credentials) were to critique mainstream "medicine", you'd be a laughing stock. Hows that for a combination of Normalcy Bias and Milgrams Obedience to authority experiment 1962?!!! (you can watch it on YT)

  • Whether we agree with what Rufus is saying to the "leading psychiatrist", it is safe to say that the psychiatrist is responding in a very immature way. Judging from seeing that psychiatrist here, I don't think he has the empathy to be able to help anyone. But he probably believes his personality is irrelevant anyway. His observation and analysis are sufficient to prescribe the correct medicines.

  • Go Rufus! Antipsychotics simply diminish total mental functioning in the frontal lobe, shutting you down, turning off all thoughts both hallucinatory and sane, making you a drooling non human. The frontal lobe is a part of the brain that makes us differ from animals. Antipsychotics make you stupid. If you hear voices, talk back to them. If you see a unicorn, pet him.

  • this doctor is so disguisting in my opinion. he says ruth's voices tell her to kill other ppl and says thats progress then laughs. i feel like im gonna vomit. that dr needs to go back to the mental facility he was in. OMG RUTH NEEDS MEDICATION. SHE JUST JUMPED IN FRONT OF A DUMP TRUCK. the woman staring at them was cracking me up.

  • haha Rufus is great!

  • That is wired.. That she should hit him s: I don't see how he is helping her!

Loading...

0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more