What If - Theatrical Trailer
Uploader Comments (AListProductions)
Top Comments
-
Only a fool would be offended by this. I take this as a tribute to the victims of 9/11 and the real heroes who saved as many lives as they could. I commend you for making this. We all wanted Superman on 9/11.
-
Takes balls to make a concept vid like this. Combining pure fiction with real world events. But you've done it with enough class and skill that a reasonable person should understand your intentions, particularly in its absolute 3.36 context.
Excellent editing. Nothing offensive or controversial; it is what it is - a 'What If?' video.
Fantastic work, A-List. One to be proud of.
Video Responses
All Comments (54)
-
@AListProductions naw man, i'm not saying i that don't like your vid. it was really cool i'm just saying i don't like bush. any was great job as usual
-
@AListProductions It's okay, I understand. You're very welcome, for I am an editor too and I know what it's like to need feedback as well. When will this be uploaded as full length film (if it hasn't already?) Can't wait for more edits =]
-
Been awhile since a "What If" scenario with superheroes vid has really caught my attention and made me think. This was obviously very well thought out and clearly no disrespect for the heroes who gave their lives on that day. I don't often comment on YouTube vids, it's just not my style. However, with this one, I felt like I had to.
-
ALSO - Why was Ghost Rider dressed up like a fire fighter! LOL His head is a fire hazard!
-
Superheroes and 9/11? Edgy. But I'm glad people aren't posting "this . . . is an outrage!" type comments.
-
Great job on the video. I especially appreciate how you made the original superman movie blend well with newer movies. I think combining fantasy with facts is very appropriate and has always been seen in heroic comics dating back to WW2. Forcing people to reconsider their situation.
But I'm not sure I follow your point. Were you just presenting super heros in the 9/11 crisis, while at the same time posing several what if questions?
this was absolutely AMAZING... until bush
hbkdabaybeast 1 month ago in playlist More videos from AListProductions
@hbkdabaybeast If you're going to base your like or dislike of something based solely on a person's voice you hear, that's pretty bad. Bush was president when this happened and he made a historic and emotional speech. I would have done the same thing if Obama was in office during this, Clinton, etc.
AListProductions 1 month ago
Nothing describes the word inspirational better than this video.
Astounding. A concept that I've never been able to put together, or even fathom about, was made by you and such a wonderful job was done on it. You deserve praise for that, and that alone, despite the wondrous editing of yours about a rough concept, you managed to respect it and make it seem so real at the same time. If my cousin who died on 9/11 was still here, I'm sure he would have been in awe from your video alone.Amazing work
boredsox78 1 month ago
@boredsox78 First off sorry for taking so long to reply back, I wasn't ignoring you... I was just in the process of moving and only had mobile internet at the time! Thank you so much for watching and for leaving one of the most meaningful comments I've ever received on a video. I love hearing feedback, especially when it's as genuine and real as yours was. Thank you!!
AListProductions 1 month ago
@mailx197333 thanks for watching, I agree with you until you said "parody" I am not mocking the events of 9/11 or parodying it in any humorous way, so I take offence to that claim.
AListProductions 2 months ago
simply from an editing stand point great job, though you need to touch up the scene with Lex Luthor (the audio kinda disconnects it from the rest of the trailer), or removing it wouldn't take away anything from the piece I think. two thumbs up!
Scribeholic 2 months ago
@Scribeholic Yeah, haha that's what I get for editing with head phones on! o_O
AListProductions 2 months ago