Mozart Concerto No. 19 in F (K459) Mv. 1, by Charlie (8)
Loading...
2,875
Uploader Comments (coffeetea)
Top Comments
-
Charlie is good however his play is not musical and powerful. I like the same play by Tiffany Koo, a 7 years old gril with amazing talent and musical sense. Good luck....
see all
All Comments (34)
-
Nice playing for an 8 year old. But I wouldn't say it's enjoyable to listen to, I've heard so much better version.
-
Very Nice !! sprightly, clean and clear!!!
-
Bravo!!!
-
I really enjoy listening to Charlie perform this concerto! I think I've listened to this video about 30 times already... Also, I like the fact that you annotated the video to describe what Charlie's doing, since with 2 pianos it can be a little confusing unless you're super-familiar with the concerto.
-
Wonderful!
Loading...
I have to say I prefer Charlie's version. He simply has amazing control of the keyboard, wonderful sound, excellent direction of the music line and exquisite phrasing - everything that is so difficult to achieve came together so beautifully. Very secure playing and mature interpretation for any age!!
2008hymusic 2 years ago
Thanks! I certainly agree with you. I think those who thumbed up the previous post probably mixed up 7 yo Tiffany Koo with 10 yo Tiffany Poon, who's a great talent and who played K459 very very nicely. Tiffany Koo is a great talent too, but there's no way her current version betters Charlie's. But, one day she just might ...
coffeetea 2 years ago
Sorry about the multiple comments, but the semifinal round was on Saturday, wasn't it? How did it go?
lilly763 2 years ago
hehe, you're certainly on top of NJ competitions. Nobody other than pianists & judges are allowed inside. Charlie's accompanist said he was awesome and had a fantastic cadenza (he definitely improved over the last month too). The judges said "thank you very very much" then asked him some questions, I don't know if it's routine. We're waiting on results too. But again, it's under-18 category, so we're prepared for getting nothing.
BTW, thanks much for your comments!
coffeetea 2 years ago