FRIENDS in Autism Treatment- #5 ABA vs. Son-Rise Program
Top Comments
All Comments (14)
-
@Reichieru1 It seems that ABA judges the agenda of the adult as being more worthwhile than the child's agenda. One of my child's behaviours that you would have sought to reduce is him walking around the room 'writing' in the air. He did this for many hours and didn't sit at a table at all. However instead of attempting to stop this I joined it. After many days I realised that he was working out the 1812 overture by Tchaikowsky. Now he can play it on the piano. I'm so glad I went with him on this
-
@meadowlotus ABA is just a set of principals that govern all actions of all people, and there is far more to it than setting up the environment. Setting up the environment is about providing opportunities to communicate, making the child comfortable, and reducing the behaviours that interfere with their ability to learn, not motivation. That being said, if a child likes playdough, we may put it on a high shelf to provide them with the chance to mand for it.
-
@Reichieru1 Ah an ABA program. I understand where your comments are coming from. As I understand it ABA is based on a set of beliefs that by setting up an environment with predictable desired/undesired consequences the child will learn the things that we the adults want them to learn. So essentially you are hoping that the child will look outside of themselves for the cues to motivate themselves. That is, one of the fundamental differences between Son Rise and ABA
-
@meadowlotus Provincial just means that is where the funding comes from, the province. It's not a particular technique. They adapt based on needs of the children, which is very easy with ABA because ABA isn't a technique, just a set a principals that apply to how all behaviours work. The children learn how to talk about how they feel. They talk about what friends are, any social skills they need to learn, and then practice them, taking into account all the individual needs of the children.
-
@Reichieru1 It looks like the Social Circle technique is a differnet one to the one that I was refering too - as you could only carry that out somewhere that had groups of children to enlist as 'friends'.
What sort of program is your 'provincial' program?
-
@meadowlotus Not once did I say school. The programs I am refering to are designed for people with autism that take into account all of those needs.
-
@meadowlotus Not once did I say school. The programs I am refering to are designed for people with autism that take into account all os those needs.
-
@Reichieru1 I used to work in a school and taught using social circles and I agree they do have some success. However I used to find that the children were very overstimulated at school by the environment which meant that they learned more slowly, plus the other children kept dropping out as they found it challenging. With the Son Rise Program you create a very low stimulus room in which to teach, with adults one at a time, my son has learned so much faster like this.
-
@meadowlotus The provincial programs in Ontario have social circles in which they do all that stuff, and not all children can just absorb the information other information, anyway. Some still need to be explicitly taught. And you're right, what is the big deal about not being able to tie your shoes? Any ethical therapist will focus on the skills that matter the most to the parents.
-
brainwashing, instead of encouragements
Have you noticed that the best things in life are not things? Relationships with the people whom I love are the highlight of my life. I chose the Son Rise program because of it's focuses on relationships. I found that by making relationships the primary focus of my Son Rise program that my son actually learnt all the other stuff anyway without my need to create lessons to teach it. You can go through life without being able to tie shoelaces - buy slipons, but who wants to go through life alone?
meadowlotus 2 years ago 5
Love The Son-Rise Program !! xxx
abancroft1 2 years ago 3