Uploaded by 613ENFORCER on Jun 2, 2011
NEW SQUARE — The man severely burned during an arson attack alleged to have been committed by a follower of the Hasidic village's grand rabbi angrily denounced the religious leader in a recent video from his hospital bed.
In the video, Aron Rottenberg, 43, who says he was attacked for refusing to pray at Rabbi David Twersky's synagogue, calls Twersky's comments condemning violence hollow and disingenuous. He said the grand rabbi's comments disrespected Jewish law and that Twersky is concerned only about himself.
"This person doesn't have the guts to base his speech on the Torah or humanity," Rottenberg says in Yiddish in the video.
Rottenberg, a father of four, said a religious leader of Twersky's stature "should fire himselfupwith all his might and courage togo out to the community and denounce this as an indecency and immoral actand against the Torah, not to say, 'It's just not our way.' "
In his first comments about the May 22 attack outside Rottenberg's home, Twersky told students last Thursday that violence violated the principles of the Hasidic Jewish sect.
Twersky, the spiritual leader of the worldwide Skver Hasidic community, also said he prayed for the healthy recovery of Rottenberg and of his accused attacker, Shaul Spitzer, 18. The rabbi didn't mention either man by name.
"Violence has never been our way," the revered religious leader said.
Rottenberg's comments on the video were translated by several Yiddish speakers for The Journal News, including Paul Glasser, senior research associate on Yiddish language at the YIVO Institute for Jewish Research in New York City.
The video shows Rottenberg holding a letter in his left hand as he sits up in bed at the Westchester Medical Center's burn unit. He suffered third-degree burns across 50 percent of his body on May 22. He underwent a second surgery on Tuesday, cannot use his right arm due to the burns and is battling an infection.
Spitzer, who slept in Twersky's house and did butler-type duties, is accused of trying to burn down Rottenberg's Truman Avenue house after 4 a.m. May 22.
The family was asleep except for one son who was monitoring a security camera because of threatening telephone calls to the family.
Spitzer suffered third-degree burns to his hands and is being treated at a New York City hospital. A nurse said Wednesday that Spitzer was not allowed to speak with reporters.
Ramapo police charged Spitzer with second-degree attempted murder, first-degree attempted arson and first-degree assault. His brother Jacob and community members posted $300,000 cash bail.
In a previous video, Rottenberg said he started praying at Friedwald Center because a friend there was being treated for cancer.
Rottenberg had walked the mile to the New Hempstead nursing home so his friend would be able to pray with 10 Jewish men as required under Jewish religious practice. He said the New Square community sabotaged a shortcut by taking down lights and digging a 3-foot-deep trench.
-
8 likes, 5 dislikes
1:59
Suspect in New Square Arson Attack Now Facing Murder Chargeby TheVinVid17,322 views
2:09
New Square arson victim Aron Rottenberg to sue David Twerskyby SkverahShtatel5,974 views
0:46
NEW SQUARE: A NEW VICTIM COMES FORWARDby 613ENFORCER2,238 views
8:48
NEW SQUARE ARSON VICTIM QUESTIONS AND CONDEMNS THE ATTACK ON HIMby 613ENFORCER1,804 views
1:43
NEW SQUARE: FORMER HASSIDS ORGANIZE BIKE RIDE FOR NEW SQUARE ARSON VICTIMby 613ENFORCER5,678 views
3:27
Motorcycle In New Square Paradeby bigshotphoto9,742 views
2:12
New Square arson attack suspect back in Yeshiva But not the Rottnberg kidsby emmesdig2,243 views
0:34
Mandy Berger unveils David Twersky complicity of the New Square terror attacksby SkverahShtatel13,593 views
2:27
Mr. rottenberg's Son Speaks Out After Saving His Fathers Liveby SkverahShtatel4,417 views
2:06
FBI to join Ramapo PD in New Square Investigationby SkverahShtatel2,100 views
1:38
Skver Rabbi follower Clashes with New Square Burn victim Family - Journal News LoHudby shmekil9,432 views
1:33
R' Chiam Aron Rottenberg Reads The Megilah At The Friedwald Centerby SkverahShtatel6,061 views
8:11
New Square Fire Victim Rottenberg speaks out from Hospital bedby emmesdig8,311 views
3:49
Burn victim's family shouted down at press conferenceby TheJewishSongs28,891 views
8:11
NEW SQUARE: ARSON VICTIM RECOVERING ASKS FOR CONTINUED PRAYERSby 613ENFORCER1,376 views
2:31
NEW SQUARE ARSON VICTIM SPEAKSby 613ENFORCER938 views
3:33
Violence in New Square Escalates To Possibly Attempted Murderby SkverahShtatel8,622 views
2:16
NEW SQUARE LOCAL HASSID COMPARES ATTACKS TO STALINISM AND COMMUNISMby 613ENFORCER2,431 views
3:00
Terror in New Square Continuesby SkverahShtatel12,494 views
2:35
Police Say They Will Investigate New Square Rabbi David twersky (news 12)by SkverahShtatel9,146 views
- Loading more suggestions...
amazing! couldn't have said better myself
KAHANAwasRIGHT 8 months ago
wow ..im amazed after listening to him it just mind boggling how skvere rabbi got away with this i used to have a lot of respect for the skvera rabbi all i can think of saying now is hashem should repay him eye for an eye we should all see his demise that will be a gr8 kidush hashem
avrumduvid 8 months ago
Good points !!!!!
zaliwins 8 months ago