Much too fast. He has missed the point. There is no feeling of rhythm, therefore it does not sound at all like Haydn. What is more there is more than a dash of Chinese style stuck on top. No thank you.
I like your interpretation of the 3rd movement a lot better than the one of the second. still it's kind of painful to watch your bodymovement while you are playing... way too much shoulderwork and tension....
at a few moments the rit.s are a bit exagerated for my taste, but not so bad that it would really hurt the performance
also I think that you've done the ending very well... a real haydn sense of humor... you just gotta love it how papa haydn plays with expectations in his music
I have been playing the piece too, and I know of the ending. Yet there is a difference between a proper ending despite its humour and an ending that fails to impress.
Much too fast. He has missed the point. There is no feeling of rhythm, therefore it does not sound at all like Haydn. What is more there is more than a dash of Chinese style stuck on top. No thank you.
cynic150 1 year ago
I like your interpretation of the 3rd movement a lot better than the one of the second. still it's kind of painful to watch your bodymovement while you are playing... way too much shoulderwork and tension....
at a few moments the rit.s are a bit exagerated for my taste, but not so bad that it would really hurt the performance
also I think that you've done the ending very well... a real haydn sense of humor... you just gotta love it how papa haydn plays with expectations in his music
pkoen79 2 years ago
Of course. But not on Youtube. =)
smartjingle 2 years ago
Do you know of any recording, where this ending works better?
kpunkt 2 years ago
I have been playing the piece too, and I know of the ending. Yet there is a difference between a proper ending despite its humour and an ending that fails to impress.
smartjingle 2 years ago
it's a typical Haydn joke ending :-)
kpunkt 2 years ago
I think sometimes he rushes towards or a little bit aggresive partly .
tempo is no problem though .
DennisChoy1 2 years ago
wow! the 3erd. movement!!! i like your technic!
AminaBellini 2 years ago
Very well-played.
rata254 3 years ago
do you know what a "metronome" is? google it if you dont,..... i think he gets the tempo right, it is presto (around 165bpm)
revolvair 3 years ago