Star Wars IV 1977 vs 1997 vs 2004 comparacion
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (403)
-
That's exactly how I've felt since day 1.
-
@Dracofyre Greedo did not shoot at all
-
Good video. SHITE music.
-
Star Wars sí, George Lucas no.
-
@Ryeguy123a I was about to post exactly this until I saw your post.
Gimme Blu-Ray cuts with all the new fancy processing to pretty em up and none of the extra added crap and I will give gladly give Lucas piles of my money but not until then.
HAN SHOT FIRST
-
@Imaculata By the way, I LOVED the puppet effects in Farscape. I thought it was the best stuff Henson's Creature Workshop has ever done.
But I found it hilariously ironic and telling that in those early days of the internets you could find chats and message boards where people were bitching about Star Wars CGI while simultaneously bitching about muppets in Farscape.
Some fanbois will complain about anything.
-
@Imaculata Nope, I fully understand. I never said the performance was bad.. I said the CGI effects were better than the puppet effects. And guess what? CGI characters are ALSO performance based...what YOU fail to understand is that it's not even new technology to dress Andy Serkis up in a ping pong ball suit and motion captuire.
I'm sorry you prefer old style effects, but the majority of the people on the planet want special effects technology to progress.
-
@Imaculata I truly respect your opinion. It gives me lots of insight.
-
@THX11003 Yes, it is not so much that I mind a bit of humor. Because RotJ always had that little cut to a frog creature outside Jabba's palace. I didn't mind that gag. But the Mos Eisley approach was never intended as a funny scene. It was meant as a serious scene, where the characters have to be careful. By inserting gags all over the place, it ruins the mood that was intended here. Obi Wan describes it as a hive of scum and villainy. Now it is a circus of side gags and shenanigans.
-
@Imaculata I would have to see it for myself. I see what you mean now, you are talking about the humor. All these gags add humor to the film. Which is distracting. I understand.
I really wish Lucas would stop trying to fix what isn't broken. If we wants to mess with history, there's plenty for him to focus on in the prequel trilogy...maybe he can start by removing 90% of the dialogue.
mco119 1 week ago 22
I don't mind the re-mastering and making the film we see a higher quality. Where he really pisses fans off, including me, is in *changing* what actually happens, dramatically changing scenes and even the actors who are in those scenes, in some cases. If he just wanted to make a clearer picture, with higher definition and better colors for the things that are actually there... that's fine. But leave it at that.
Ryeguy123a 1 week ago 20