TAG: Matt Slick VS Matt Dillahunty PART 5/5 - A.E. #593

Matt Slicks Website - http://www.mattslick.com/

The Atheist Experience is a weekly cable access television show in Austin, Texas geared at a non-atheist audience. Every week we field live calls from atheists and believers alike, and you never know what you're going to get! Sometimes it can get quite feisty indeed! You don't want to miss it.

Episode: #593
22 February, 2009
Topic: Live Calls. Matt & Tracie take on live calls.

Atheistic Experience: http://www.atheist-experience.com/
Atheist Community of Austin: http://www.atheist-community.org/
AE Blog: http://atheistexperience.blogspot.com/
Non-Prophets Radio: http://www.nonprophetsradio.com/

Category:

Nonprofits & Activism

Tags:

• atheist
• community
• faith
• non
• prophets
• atheism
• religion
• Christianity
• Christian
• Russell
• glasser
• god
• science
• creationism
• religious
• Tracie
• Dillahunty
• Loubet
• Dee
• nonprofit
• Atheistic
• Austin
• Texas
• catholic
• Jesus
• Christ
• evolution
• delusion
• dawkins
• violence
• indoctrination
• apocalypse
• protestant
• prophecy
• caller
• history
• church
• 593
• carm
• slick
• prayer
• matt
• TAG
• transcendental

[Rawlsrocks]

@joclovesprince92

How is pointing out that Slick's assumption that everything is either physical or conceptual is an unproven assumption (since Slick didn't present any evidence for this) the same as "running away from the truth"?

Matt D. doesn't have to present evidence that a third option exists, because Matt S. is the one making the claim that only 2 options exist, that everything is either physical or conceptual and therefore he has the burden of proof! It's logic 101!

[orcslayer006]

Ok, I'm not as educated as these guys and I'll admit there were times that I just stared at the screen and went "huh?" That said, I don't have to know what something is to tell you what it's not. If I see a purple blob of gooey substance, I know it's not a car. I don't know what it is, but it's not a car. Am I wrong? Should I consider it may be car since I don't know what it is?

[joclovesprince92]

Matt Dillahunty running away from the truth

[D3maine]

Slick does exactly what CARM does. They've corrupted the third "Law of Logic" by saying, "that a statement is either true or false." This, of course contradicts the first "Law of Logic." It should read, "that a statement is either true or NOT TRUE." Or, as per the first law, it is either A or not A. You can't just introduce the need to define what "A" isn't or assign "A" the properties of another entity of your choice, if it is not A.

[D3maine]

@metro2034artyom Well, like Matt D. said " I just spent forty-five minutes" telling him why and he still couldn't get it and neither do you. Some things are just beyond the grasp of some peoples mind's.

[espnfan54]

Matt Dillahunty is beast!

[espnfan54]

@metro2034artyom lol Matt killed him. Slicks entire argument was a logical fallacy.

[metro2034artyom]

Matt Dillahunty had no counter point to make against Matt Slick, he got cornered and could only say, nope its not conceptual, however he failed to say what it is or give another option. Gotta love it when he could not give an answer and just put Slick on hold and then still proceded to attack him without giving the opportunity of Slick to defend himself, Matt Dillahunty failed miserably in this debate.

[AchronTimeless]

@Kaddywompous yes, we call it sound, so it's still sound. If you honestly think that the moment you turn your back on your computer that there's a very real possibility that it transmutes into a bunch of faries having an orgy until the moment you turn around.. this conversation is over. Saying the same things over and over doesn't make them right, and I'm not going to bother letting you say them to me. Afterall, I turn into a carrot while you're waiting for me to read them. *sigh*