Machaut: Messe de Nostre Dame [w/ score - part 1 of 4]
Top Comments
All Comments (39)
-
Déroutant non? Nous sommes tellement habitués à des voix plus "lisses", sans doute de mise pour les polyphonies de la renaissance, mais qu'en était il au XIVe siecle? Sans doute ne le sauront nous jamais, mais il est fort possible que M.Peres soit plus proche de la réalité que nous le pensons.
-
Sine no-one knows absolutely for certain how this would have been performed, this rendition is every bit as valid as any other. Always loved the music of Machaut, however it is performed.
-
@NoahSV You don't think our idea of beauty has changed that much over the years?
-
Machaut, un des grands maîtres de Nôtre Dame. Magnifique!
-
Well, "our" idea of beauty has changed drastically over centuries (suffice to see the beauties on paintings...). Whether or not people sang some similar way like Peres in the times of Machaut is a question. (I personally think they did not, but they did so some centuries earlier). But be sure people do sing - somewhat - similar like this even nowadays. It is no big secret that Peres took most of his inspiration from Greek Orthodox singing (as it is today).
-
@NoahSV Get over your self, it is apparant that some people just cant stand the idea of difference, anyway who died and made you a western music historian??, do you know it is also sacrilege to judge others unfairly, you seem to be doing that pretty well. Jerk.
-
I honestly doubt people would sing like this in any age. I don't think our idea of beauty has changed that much over the years. Moreover, I think it is sacrilege to moan the name of Christ.
-
So this is not matter of protestant/catholic but a peculiar flaw of our times, recognisable also in religious architecture, moral and metaphysical conceptions, language, and every aspect of civilisation, of which religion is the most significant.
-
What you very rightly describe as insincere sounding music (pardon my "English") doesn't only apply to protestantism since the cantica in catholic churches have now the same platitude and emptiness, absence of spirit, grace and beauty. And certainly protestantism allowed and even fostered Bach et alios.
-
Sardinian ethnic style? Where's the bagpipes?
Now this is just fantastic! I'm so thrilled first of all to hear this magnificent and powerful performance of such a great piece of music, but more importantly, to hear the result of such courageous and excellent scholarship, in a genre of music where most performances so completely miss the point of "historical performance", especially in the case of vocal styling. i want very much to hear this group live, and wish them the greatest of success.
ivoryconsort 1 year ago 19
This is my favorite performance/recording, the voices are so deep and crisp.
stormrender0 1 year ago 11