Luciano Pavarotti "Cielo e mar" La Gioconda - In Memoriam
Top Comments
All Comments (90)
-
@Doooku If you can sing this better than my man Pav, you'd better let us hear it. That's an extrememly arragant statement to make.
-
@Doooku Oh please do put your better than the greats version up... oh my your arrogance is out of control.
-
@Doooku Not sue what the purpose of microscopic analyzation is. Would love to hear your voice. If you can effortlessly sing d, e, and f, this would be an operatic voice?
-
I sing this aria probably better than most of the tenors. I can effortless hit High D, E, F with good control and timbre. If you pay attention VERY Carefully for the last note, you would hear what I talked about. There was certain degree of stretch. Please compare the version of Mario del Monaco. You would know the difference. OK?
-
@Doooku Pav had one of the most flawless techniques in singing, beyond criticism. When you said he strained, do you understand how the voice in opera is produced? By grunting/supporting with very firm abs; that is what you saw. A long way to go? You must be joking.
-
@Doooku No I don't agree with you. Pav was one of the most consistent singers that continuously performed at the highest caliber. His technique was beyond criticism. The other great tenors you mention did not go out of their way to act on stage and neither did Pav. It was the era of standing there and singing basically. A long way to go? you must be joking. When you said originally that he strained it said you don't understand how the voice is produced/supported with grunt/effort.
-
I listened to huddreds, if not thousands of, Pavarotti's records too. If you respect the fact, you would say that this man was good, but not the No. 1 in terms of true vocal ability, artistic expression, and understanding to music. Compared with the greats like Caruso, Bjorkling, Monaco, Pav has long way to go. Do you agree with me?
-
@Doooku I'm not going to waste my time. I've heard hundreds of Pav's arias and don't need to go listen to one mistake. If that is your response to what I said, you're a true moron.
-
Please go check "Luciano Pavarotti - Ah mes amis! - Live 1995 at the Met" and learn something from that clip. Thanks
-
@Doooku The world is full of knowledge (about singing) .... You would be well to seek some out, because your statement could not be more incorrect. You obviously have a lot of work to do. You might also want to quit commenting on things you know nothing about. Please. You embarrass yourself.



Absolutely perfect. Bravo Luciano!!!!!
alvarito45 3 years ago 14
I agree with your musical opinion, but it is sad your vocabulary and lack of class dirty up this honoring of The Maestro. You owe the online world and Luciano an apology.
dancerinblack 3 years ago 8