Phil Ochs - The Ringing of Revolution
Uploader Comments (AnarchistOpposition)
Top Comments
-
"Religion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich." - Napoleon Bonaparte
All Comments (129)
-
@HavidDagstrom absolutely right, well said. Phil was no "champagne liberal", he was a revolutionary every bit as much as Sartre or Guevara, he bitterly opposed our petty bourgeois apathy and illusions.
-
He was a hippie, live with it
-
Phil Ochs was a socialist, deal with it. He supported Allende, defied the vietnam war which liberals supported, was against attacking cuba,and hated liberals. Deal with it. He was one of the most radical singers of the era, and that's why nobody knows about him and why Bob Dylan is so popular, since he was liked by liberals and never had any phone taps at his house.
-
@TheMariner48 Phil Ochs was no Libertarian nor Anarchist, he often was an individualist corrupted by the people around him, read first
zito(dot)biz/memorial/philochs
.html Sorry I have not gotten around to updating it more. But just a point in mention anarchy applied to the lyrical format would not produce this type of song. As for themariner associating comments on Phil Ochs with libertarianism anarchy is easy when they pretending they are one yapping in the wrong place at the wrong time.
-
@AnarchistOpposition So you knew Phil Ochs did you? Naw. Now fuck off Opposition your dumb shit check yourself.
-
Occupy needs to be singing this one. I miss Phil big time.
-
@ThereAreNoUnionThugs So, so well said. Thanks.
-
Ochs said "Topical music just means the lyrics are so clear they cannot be confused with nonsense".
Its great how "topical" music is timeless; Ochs or Guthrie are more relevant today than almost all current music.
I like the part where Ochs said the rich "Gave in half way". After OWS we will see a lot of greenwash and whitewash and a fake shift toward real reporting.
This video is for North America as well as Egypt, the whole world, but don't worry, search "After the Revolution"
-
@psakref Right, thanks or I meant left thanks



Yo can we not ruin every song with immature arguments in the comments. Beautiful song, great lyrics, enough said.
Blasphemy510 2 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Phil Ochs 5
@Blasphemy510 No. Fuck you. :)
But seriously, I don't think that people arguing ruins the song. They have their grievances and I address them if possible. I see no fault in that. Your post itself, after all, is a grievance and I am now addressing it. You created an argument or at very least a discussion. XD
AnarchistOpposition 2 months ago
Libertarian my ass. Traitors who refuse to contribute. Just live unbothered and reap the benefits OTHERS provide. The song is allegorical for chrissake. Read labor history in America. Every once in awhile need to trim the excesses of the idle rich. Ochs was no anarchist, saying often "there's something inherently good about America WORTH SAVING" Democratic socialist if you have to pin a lable on him.
TheMariner48 3 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Phil Ochs 4
@TheMariner48 Who the fuck says that he was a libertarian? x_x It seems to me that you are responding to an imaginary dumbass youtuber who doesn't actually exist.
AnarchistOpposition 3 months ago 2