Prokofiev - Symphony no. 1 'Classical' (1)
Uploader Comments (Mimameior)
Top Comments
-
its actually not that fast guys....sorry to burst your bubble. Click thumbs up if you agree :)
-
Koussevitsky liked to push his orchestras to the edge, correct? The full score puts the tempo at "quarter note = 100," which I believe is slower than the normal Allegro. He put the tempo at at least "quarter note = 155" or higher.
Video Responses
All Comments (52)
-
I see what you did there, keyboard cat.
-
Sounds kinda Haydn or Mozart , guess that's why its called classical , I'm such a dumbass lol but this is a very memorable piece , listening to it a couple of times now , trying to get into Prokofiev
-
@Mattlikestheyankees LOOOOOOOL.
-
SWAG
-
@Mimameior habe you played it ???? :-) i did and this is way to fast to play it with fire and spirit and brilliance. You can also play with fire and spirit a loooottt slower !!!! And in the End the sound is what counts!!!
-
@Mimameior habe you played it ???? :-) i did and this is way to fast to play it with fire and spirit and brilliance. You can also play with fire and spirit a loooottt slower !!!!
-
this is played too fast for my taste, Prokofiev's is fast music, but let's not cross over the point, where caricature begins...
-
@ThaSchwab is "quarter note = 100" an addition of the editor or was it in the manuscript ?
-
Am I the only one here who thanks that Prokofiev bears an uncanny resemblance to the "turtle, turtle." fellow that Dana Carvey played in master of disguise?
Yah I think as Leiter...better Celibidache version..this is too fast and without "breathe"...ReSPIRO!
elycopter71 3 years ago
As I keep saying, this is an arbitrary matter, and the only authority we have is Prokofiev himself. Look at the first page of the score - 'Allegro Con Brio', meaning 'fast, with brilliance/spirit/fire'. Can you honestly say that Celibidache plays it like this? Brilliance? Fire? This is a piece designed to be fast, flashy, and showy, not laden with deep meaning. Celibidache's version positively plods. I like plenty of his work, but you do him no favours by making him the expert on Prokofiev.
Mimameior 3 years ago
Great, thanks! Does it come from a cd transfer, or did you do the 78's yourself?
-----------------------------
Rolf, Netherlands.
I am a collector of classical 78's and lp's
Click "otterhouse" above to see (and hear!)
some of my collection.
otterhouse 3 years ago
This comes from an old LP, but I got the mp3 file from someone else - I don't have the tools for proper transfer and restoration, unfortunately! You have a nice collection of old recordings, as I've said before. Keep up the good work!
Mimameior 3 years ago