The Ring of the Nibelungs (Quick Compilation Trailer)
Top Comments
All Comments (35)
-
"Dark Kingdom, The Dragon King"... is indeed a really stupid name for the film, and it's said they've dumbed it down for American consumption. No matter the title, this film relies more on Wagner than on the original story. Wagner, not Tolkien, might be said to have "bastardized" this one.
-
Well said! Also, scholars have 35 or more versions of the Nibelung stories. Tolkien didn't exploit the Brunhild vs Kriemhold saga and his work is as original as any great story can ever be said to be.
-
yes, he was siegfried von niederlanden but "niederlanden" ist not the modern netherlands (look at wikipedia). he wasn't dutch. however, dutch and germans have the same ancestors, so it's stupid to argue about this.
-
@TelumehtarOriOn NO !
,,Siegfried, Sohn des Konigs von der Niederlanden namends Siegmund , geht als Lehrling weg mit Meister Mimer ''.
You see. 'NIEDERLANDEN'
And i have multiple books wherein it says the samething from the NIEDERLANDEN. and Holland was way bigger in the early days, part of germany and whole of belgium.
-
no, siegfried wasn't dutch. he was from xanten which is in germany.
-
"Wagner flatters his audience with the conceit that their libidinous impulses resonate with the Will of the World, and that their petty passions have the same cosmic significance as Iseult's or Kundy's [Arthurian lore].
Wagner portrayed as inevitable and even desirable the fall of the old order. his music turned the plunge into the abyss into an intimate, existential experience — redemptive bliss, a sacrifice restoring meaning to the orphans of traditional society. A new religion of impulse"
-
Oh goody, Europeans embracing Wagner's Ring Cycle, what could possibly go wrong.
"For in the Twilight of the Gods their impulses would be freed from the fetters of the law. How can one be rid of ancient society? Only by declaring war against traditions and morality."
-
teutonic legend yes, but Siegfried was dutch ;-) Never forget that :P
-
@ElliePearl What J.R.R.Tolkin did was pretty common at the time, he spended just more time and work in it. C.S.Lewis did the same thing with his Narnia, a lot of unmarried scholars spended their free time at colleges like Oxford, writing this kind of things, in Europe they still do this, but in the time when people did not had TV, Internet, DVD, etc , they read more books and wrote more stuff, so they practiced their imagination way more than these days
-
HA, I worked on this. Great to see it torn into a large montage on YouTube. It was produced by Germans. The same guys that worked on 2012. It was fun to work on it.
Nice move, love Wagner's Ring and the legend, but you shouldn't call J.R.R. Tolkien such names. He took the ideas of a legend and used them in his story, which is also amazing.
There isn't an author living who didn't borrow from another source of some kind, and most religions are bastardizations of others and no one complains about that, so leave J.R.R Tolkien and his books alone.
ElliePearl 2 years ago 9
foarte tare filmu,nam c reprosa:-??
medjay07 2 years ago 3