Carly Smithson - Jesus Christ Superstar American Idol Top 6

i could not beleive she went home after this week she was a brilliant perfomer should of went to the top 2 or even won but the main thing is that shes in a band and that their making an album wats coming out soon but carly omg u always blow me away ur my idol same wif u kristy

this was an amazing performance, i think a lot of stupid people thought it was about religion and therefore didn't vote for her

I couldn't believe she wen't home after this.

me either :( i was shocked i wanted her to win so badly :(

She messed up the lyrics in the chorus, but the performace is so electrifying I don't care. Shame she was eliminated because of song choice. A lot of people think the song is sacrilige. Bogus, really. It' from the point o Judas and he is simply wondermog at amazement at Jesus and his brave choices.

OfficialTheresaCrall -

I'm not stupid, little girl. Frank Zappa? Weird Al? I read your screen page. You're in your 40's, honey and maybe in your 50's and gayer than Bruno. Not that I care. Get out of the closet and be loud and proud. Believe it or not, I don't have a spell check button on my computer and I am not about to look up words in the dictionary to impress you. Can I spell? No. Am I stupid? I would be if I really thought you were a 14 year old girl.

Sorry I listen to music. Apparently you didn't look at my videos - there's a video of me on there. I mean, first you call me a little girl, then say I'm 40-50? I don't really want to prove that I'm 14, because...I am, and I'd have a hard time doing so. Like I said, I really don't care about you, or what you think, so please leave me alone and don't try to write back trying to look smart and/or cool. KNTHX. ;)

Oh yeah, and, how am I "gayer than Bruno?" That also makes no sense, considering the fact that he's a fictional character, and in real life, he's married. To a woman. Yeah, and I don't see how you would come to that conclusion from my Youtube page. And I'm pretty sure it has my age on there, as well, so, you're not ""funny" nor "cool" for making up my age and sexual orientation. That's just your "toatalee awusum" comeback because you have nothing to say to me. HA!

Perhaps you should waste less of your childhood slagging off someone who will never read your comments, and instead spend your time doing something valuable with your time.

I'm sure you have something better to do - read a book, or go out with friends. Or did all of your friends leave when you started on a Carly Smithson rant?

Ok, whoever you are...how about you leave me alone? I really don't want to have to keep giving this video views. And besides, you can waste your time writing a comment back if you really want to, but I'm not coming back to reply.