Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here (Live In Montreal 1977)

Pink Floyd playing Wish You Were Here live in Montreal, 1977. This is from the Who Was Trained Not To Spit On The Fan bootleg, the infamous show where Roger Waters spit on a fan.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• Pink
• Floyd
• Wish
• You
• Were
• Here
• Animals
• In
• The
• Flesh
• Tour
• 1977
• Who
• Was
• Trained
• Not
• to
• Spit
• on
• the
• Fan

[doruner]

IT WAS THE SAME GIG, as Roger Waters had a "spit conflict" with one fan? (Sorry my english, i´m not englishman)

[brdempsey69]

Beautiful, as always.

[thewriter1008]

Who's playing the bass here? I thought Waters always played the twelve-string part, and I can here Wright's piano and Mason's drums, but is it Waters or someone else - maybe a touring musician - playing the bass part?

[snloftus]

@FenderMeddle94 keep in mind two things, 1. practically no one from that time were singers when going into music....pink floyd had zero singing training and 2. thats what makes live music so good, the imperfection

[einysjame]

I love this, but definitely not my favorite version of this great song.. I mean they sound really tired and out of it, after all this was the last concert of a very long tour of stadiums so

[stillclimbin]

The recording is shite,it may have been one of many off days, the auditorium may not have been acoustically receptive to the great Pink Floyd, I have about 100 bootlegs from this period and they all sound crap and out of tune, lets disect all those as well, listen with your heart, not your ears.Armchair critics are the scum of the earth

[charadeyouareha]

@FenderMeddle94 I agree this particular performance of Wish - the Floyd seem rushed and indifferent and like they can't hear themselves. Something also seems to go wrong with David's singing on all live versions I've ever heard of Money too for some reason. Otherwise Pink Floyd are perfect - everything they do every note jams together golden and I would flip to be at this show. ♥

[TEMPmichaelhansen]

3:23 a mistake in there somewhere?

[FenderMeddle94]

@stillclimbin Maby in your pathetic world the friends an idiot like you don't deserve are afraid to disagree with you, but open your eyes retard

Did i write Dark Side or Wish you were here? talentless life? so you mean that if i haven't written the best album ever i'm worthless? Would loove to see what you have acomplished in your life...

You're one of the most pathetic and biggest fuckin idiots i ever have been forced to meet. Get a life and get help.

[stillclimbin]

@FenderMeddle94 perfect pitch, so fucking what, did you write Dark Side of The Moon, or Wish You were Here or The wall, or was I havibg a nap and missed your talentless life flash by

so some fucking performance recorded by a two bit wanker doesnt meet your standards

when you have done one thing in your life worth even pissing on for its modicum of talent, then pass judgement, and still you are so far down the ladder of life that it will still be worthless, now fuck off and look in the mirror

[FenderMeddle94]

@stillclimbin please explain why my opinion is no good in your world, talking about beyond my intelligence, i've got perfect pitch and am kinda musically talented, so...