Top Comments
All Comments (703)
-
no many of them dieing now for any british or american soldier is sad but most of all is the scottish as im scottish i care most of all for us scots
-
@3tangle3 Where do you get your ideas that scottishness is a culture but the UK is a corporation? I am Scottish, I was a soldier, I swore an oath whilst serving as do all of the armed forces. I joined the army because I wanted to see the world & came from a poor backround & I got to see some beautiful places. I also had to do my job as a soldier. This song is about a dying soldier, not an independance campaign or a humanist ideaology. Can't you just appreciate the song as it is?
-
@3tangle3 Will do mate!! Song does'nt mention fuel poverty or the crown (& the 2 have no connection btw) so, yeah,, whatever!!
-
arent we all just humans...at least scottishness is a culture...not a corporation called UK
-
@andy81andy007 why do you swear an oath to a queen who takes your taxes while old people die of fuel poverty.....are you sick........the army is a great place to be brainwashed.....please wake up :)
-
A fine rendition this tune is..
-
Must huv been old days if youse acually caught on Loch Leven.
-
@wallsy2111 Hazaaa
-
@Witheraf Thumbs up from me too;I am English and have visited Scotland it is a beautiful country. Rest in peace those Scottish soldiers who died defending this beautiful country.
-
I salute you Andy, both of you. I remember me and oor Wullie playing this on a juke box, back in the sixties, We were just bairns, back fae a days fishing wi the auld man on Loch Leven.



i am english, but most of all i am british,and if the scottish were in trouble i would fight for them
wallsy2111 1 year ago 46
Thumbs up for all the Scottish soldiers who have lost their lives fighting for our country.
Witheraf 8 months ago 37