Aur Ek Prem Kahani - Ilayaraja - Asha Bhonsle - Naina
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (40)
-
Nice singing. At least one to 1.5 notes lower than Janaki's original tamil version
-
Dear listeners, you'd understand this is a Ghazal and not a Karnataki Raaga based song. And that's why the difference came here from the original one sung by S. Janaki.
-
Ashaji is undoubtedly a good singer.... but in this song it is Janaki amma who stuns everyone.... she simply rox.... her expressions were beyond explanations... its sad dat she is yet to receive Padma awards....
-
@nuetro78 it was in the year 1988
-
@macanusa Heera
-
this is a karnatic raga.. S janaki is a mastreo.. no wonder Ilya Raja prefers her most of the time.. Asha jee is good but handsdown , janaki jee is the winner.. i would listen to her songs any time of the day... i am Proud that she is TELUGU and from my home town :)...
-
I always liked Asha more than Janaki. But in this Song, I dont know Why she sounds comparatively less interesting than Janaki's version.
-
Excellent.
-
@nuetro78 : I agree that the intro by Janaki is like 10 times better than this one.... But the lyrics I like in this song (because I cant understand Tamil...else I am sure it is much more beauiful in Tamil version).. But we cant compare poetry in 2 languages... Each has its own merit..
-
awsome song, listening to it after 10+ years........ thanks for uploading.........
-Asha has given her best but not even close to Janaki.....especially the intro. The tamil version is awesome.When did this movie release?.
nuetro78 2 years ago 12
Thanks for uploading this song. I had heard the Tamil version growing up. I love Illayiraja's music and of Asha Bhonsle singing.
deepaliagashe 2 years ago 6