12 Without You - Mariah Carey (live at Manila)

Charmbracelet World Tour
Manila, Philippines
November 16, 2003

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• mariah
• carey
• live
• without
• you
• charmbracelet
• tour
• manila
• philippines
• 2003

[pontolononoy]

lipped or not, i dont care.. i so love Mariah <3 ^_^

[Raoulirshan]

Lipped? This is not lipped! This is my favorite song ever and trust me.. it's live ;)

[P29able]

nossa eu estava eesperando a mariah carey ,não a joelma ! kkkkkkkkkkkkkkk

[rksu747]

People saying that this is lipped are stupid! Plain and simple!

[pedy19]

@pedy19 Oh and she is a terrible lip syncher she definitely is one of the worst ever!

[pedy19]

@fuckingbrill Because often ppl forget We belong together has E5 that require to be sung and not belt, and she sings them and nobody cares, then say she lips the C5 quite strange isn´t it? she either lipped the whole thing or sung we belong together live. Also check It´s like that live ellen. those F5 GOD

[pedy19]

@fuckingbrill Listen she has still the voice, is just fragile now and more vunerable, yes she does lip sync more because her vocal stamina won´t let her do as many live performances as in 96 she however sings live in important events (especially in USA) , for instance in 2008 she managed to sustain two F#5 and hit a G5 in I stay in love. Plus most of her C5 sound the same in We belong together because it is meant to be that way, it´s a belt , the hardest notes are the E5 not the C5

[fuckingbrill]

@pedy19 And I mean't this. When I was watching performances of 'I wanna know what love is' and she was straining on simple C5 or lipping C5 from 'We belong together' and whistles, I was confused. And I often don't trust her when she is singing so good and I guess it's lipped. And I can hear the difference between voice from studio and live. The problem is it's often sound the same.

[pedy19]

@fuckingbrill I think she was at her best until 2003 honestly, I even prefer 2001 - 2003 than 97 and 98. And after 2005 her voice clearly started losing power, her worst years were 2007 and 2008 and now her voice seems to be a bit better and she has delievered some cool live performances, such as "Emotions live 2010", and yes her voice changed and it´s not the same.

[fuckingbrill]

@pedy19 I'm not saying she is always lipping. I can hear it's live. There's no doubt she is one of best singers of all time, but let's face the truth- she was great on 90s. Now she's only straining and lipping the highest parts of songs.

[pedy19]

@fuckingbrill I know she does lip sych I´m no delusional, that doesn´t mean all the performances are lip. This is a clear example of a live performance

[fuckingbrill]

@pedy19 I'm not a youtube singer, but singer which have some performances on stage. Some? You wanted to say nearly a half. At least high notes if she didn't it for whole song. Anyway, I don't wanna to keep this conversation, cos i can see you are like a psycho fan and you can't handle the truth.