Keisha Buchanan vs Jade Ewen Thank You For The Heartbreak Sweet 7

Keisha vs Jade In Thank You For The Heartbreak From Sweet 7

Category:

Music

Tags:

• keisha jade sweet 7
• keisha vs jade
• sweet 7
• sugababes
• keisha sweet 7
• thank you for the heartbreak
• www.keisha-buchanan.com
• keisha-buchanan.com
• sugababes keisha
• sugababes jade
• sweet 7 jade

[priscillaaries]

I think,that this song was not meant for Jade's vocal range BUT...GIVEN the fact that K got the boot,they prob made Jade sing her heart out to say," heyyy look what you have been replaced with"....I think J is over doing it.

[kb20101]

@priscillaaries I really couldn't agree more, it just ain't for her at all!

[silentknight826]

Some songs on Sweet 7 suit Keisha better and other songs suit Jade better but this is the one song where Jade undeniably owns Keisha.... and no amount of volume fiddling is gonna change that.

[kb20101]

@silentknight826 dream on, jade sucks big time, and i never fiddled and volume, any messing with that was the studio because Jade wasn't powerful enough!

[kb20101]

I have to say, I can not really hear Jade until the end. Keisha totally drowns her out.

[94asm]

@kb20101 thats because you've made keisha louder? you can tell because at the end they obviously take the bridge differently, so there isn't perfect overlap and you can barely hear Jade's version, yet when its solely Keisha singing its so loud. Anyone can bias it...

[Lisledl]

Jade all the way, she has a bigger range and more powerful vocals. She could sing that live - Keisha probs couldn't! Also the Sweet 7 cover looks better with Jade!

[Spursette1986]

Jade sounds so much better, Keisha is too auto tuned.. saw them live and keisha was rubbish whereas all othr members past and  present have been great live..

[poptacular6625]

Ya'll are cynical. The leaked versions of Keisha are "louder" in general. I did feel the studio/recording/mixes of Jade's versions are softer and lost some oomph (lack of better word). I was devastated when I heard Jade's About a Girl - it seemed slower and had less bass. On the bright side, I grew into Jade and don't mind it at all. But still, Keisha's vocals have a little more character and is more distinctive when pitted against the other two. Jade's voice even gets lost behind Heidi's.

[nico92stronger]

sorry... but; where is jade?

[govievil]

keisha's better

[Nathwano]

@BAREBACKER yeah cause the sugababes recording their 8th studio album currently screams, the sugababes are over

[BAREBACKER]

@Nathwano sure she can sing, just nowhere near as good as keisha. however it doesnt matter now, the sugababes are over.

[silentknight826]

@Nathwano Lol that's so true about the cardboard cutout thing. Some people called it their 'moody persona/attitude' but I just think it lacked any stage presence. But yeah it is a shame Keisha's not in the group anymore but nothing can be done about that now. At least she's got a solo career to look forward. People need to accept that things have changed and like you said, move on.