Duke Special vs Neil Hannon pt. 2/4
Uploader Comments (Nuckpang)
Top Comments
-
Love both of them, but Neil's rendition of Duke's song is definitely the best of the two covers. He just knows how to convey the emotion in his voice better- something that comes from 20 years' experience, Duke's just not quite there yet. I also love the one note he changes in the bridge to make the second piano phrase into a diminished chord as opposed to Duke's original normal chord. Simple, but ingenious. Much more effective.
-
Neil definitely wins. No doubt.
All Comments (22)
-
I love Duke Special - a lot, but I have to say I think I like Neil's version of No Cover Up better that the original. Both fantastic covers, both fantastic musicians. Thank you so much for uploading.
-
Both are stunning. Neil doing No Cover Up is amazing, but the Duke's rendition of Mastermind is equally haunting.
-
The very beginning seems a bit high for Neil but he pulls it off <3 That version of "No Cover Up" is so haunting and deep- not to say Duke Special's isn't, but this just has such a different quality.
-
I wasent familar with Duke Special before this vid, but that song is wonderful, and it sounds beautiful coming out of Neil hannons mouth. I could listen to it forever. Same goes for the version of Tonight We Fly he did on this show
-
Simply divine !! Duke's rendition of Neil's song is amazing, he has such a beautiful voice. Both of them are so talented !
-
I Think that Neil Hannon is a better lyricist but I think that the Duke has a greater range as a singer (but this is all I have heard Neil sing in)...
-
Duke has way more emotion in his voice, Just my opinion.
-
Both are fantastic in different ways.
Duke is my personal preference though. I met him before.
-
To my mind, Peter sounds more emotional but Neil still sounds awesome and very refined.
I can't believe I missed this! Amazing! Thanks for uploading! ^_^
chibinessroxsheep 2 years ago 4
You're so very welcome :)
Nuckpang 2 years ago