POGUES & KATIE MELUA , FAIRY TALE OF NEW YORK
Top Comments
All Comments (157)
-
@utubalicious2 Should see him now. Looks alot worse than here.
-
Nothing is ever going to be as good as the original recording. Times have changed-Shane McGowan is more drunk than ever & Kirsty Maccoll is no longer with us. Its still my favourite Christmas song though,& I dont think anything else can top it. When you're out in a pub & it comes on its probably the only Christmas song that most people not only know the words to but dont feel a fool singing either. I mean,who really is going to sing along to Slade in a packed pub?.I cant see any hands up.......!
-
Where is banjo player (Jem Finer)?
-
this aint as bad as poeple are making out to be.
-
Fantastic tin whistle play. Spider is very good like always.
-
There is no spit or fire in Katie's voice. Not good.
-
@nappadang1 you can't listen the music! you are deaf!......
-
shane is just a twat, needs to sort himself out and stop thinking he's a god.
-
All I can say is...I saw the pogues for the 3rd time a few nights ago, Shane has got his emoiton back, sounds great and the band are as great as ever.
-
Katie is terrible! Not even in the same league as Kirsty!!!!



That was really bad. It's as though Shane has lost the emotion in the song and is just goin through the motions. Katie's voice and pronunciations just don't fit the song. Also the pianist is rubbish and the tin whistle sounds crap. I met shane in a pub back in August and he looks far better than he does here. He got new teeth!
utubalicious2 2 years ago 7
that whistle player is shockingly bad....
PaddyIrishGirl 1 year ago 5