Communism vs Anarchism

Some comments

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• anarchism
• communism

[6ch6ris6]

wow really great video!

except a few thingsbut i guess that is normal and good because discussions are always good :)

greetings from germany ;)

no gods. no states. no servants.

(A)

[wnxsilence]

There is no difference between genuine Communism, the libertarian socialist interpretation of Anarchism, and functioning Democracy...

[SlyFox70100]

Anarchism is the only way the world will ever get along. LET ANARCHY REIGN!! --A--

[Fergusforslipknot]

since conservatism/rightism believes that the government should be limited, isn't anarchism just the most extreme form of right wing politics and not socialism? anarchism is the doctrine that the government should have a place in society whereas socialism believes it should have the biggest role in a society. Maybe I'm wrong though...

[almanacofsleep]

In the materialist conception of history formulated by Marx and Engles, stateless communism is the final stage of history, this is "pure" communism, a classless, stateless system based on common ownership and free-access, superabundance and maximum freedom for individuals to develop their own capacities and talents.

[punkunite123]

@wowalinbie How can anarchy be individualism? the idea is based by people for people. The lack of trust and so individualism in most of societies today = the reason why anarchistideas exist. a good idea would be to destroy this monetary system for once. to use media in a good way, to educate children in a good way. to think ecological, to grow on with nature again instead of slowing the process down. to use technology in a good way finally. break the essence instead of every person on the top

[kwaal]

@ToaJoe Thats not what socialism stands for, socialism stands for the workers owning the means of production. and we want that, but without the authoritarian "dictatorship of the prolitariat", "Communist" countries never seem to get past.

[meow333333333]

Marx said that the state would disolve once it reached communism. Communism is definately not a right wing theory, getting to communism may go through a right wing period but true communism is left

[wowalinbie]

@mmantech True enough but there are multiple forms of anarchy and realisticly thinking anarchy is a utopia or that people can reach a utopia is not a valid possibility. where as u said social responsibility (socialist) is true but i still feel that no government and depending on individual responsibility is better. with no intrusion of societies black death of ideas. I still consider myself haveing anarchist ideas just a little bit different.

[mmantech]

@wowalinbie wrong! this thinking of yours is individualist/right wing libertarian thought. if you understand this subject properly you will now that anarchism starting with proudhon is bourgeoisie/utopian socialist thought.

[mmantech]

@4500jas this then will lead to the end of class antagonism, following that is the natural dissolving of the state.

[mmantech]

@4500jasWrong! if you understand this subject properly you will now that anarchism(proudhon) is bourgeoisie/utopian socialist thought. anarchist dont like the fundemental acpect to human history and human nature and that is class struggle. some streams of thought like syndacalism may seem to adress this but they(anarchist) seem not to understand that in order to get to the point of no state u need; first the fall of bourgeoisie capitalist dictatorship. second the dictatorship of the proletariot