appassionata
Top Comments
All Comments (575)
-
I'm glad to learn, as a Japanese jazz fan, this video captures audience outside Japan, even though some of the comments critisize her performance. IMO, technique is of secondary to the musical mind, while I highly evaluate her skills as well though.
-
you wouldnt know what would work in this context....forgive me, but jazz musicians are inferior in every way to classical musicians....no organization, no technique, no formal training......
-
@Aerich711 Don't bother with him. He made a mistake and was unwilling to admit it, even after outstanding evidence against his unwarranted claim was presented (by you). You pinned him down, and he refused to accept that.
-
Whatever
-
@Dolorousness Ever heard of Stephane Grapelli?
-
forgive me but violin is incongruous in the jazz idiom, in spie of her technical proficiency and allure; Jean=Luc Ponty is boring and outside of the intro this piece is rather pedestrian. Violin didn't work for John Handy and it doesn't work here.
-
@Browniesisgood There's only one Chaconne in D minor from Bach's 2nd Partita, BWV 1004. What I meant when I said C minor is that this piece is in C minor, Chaconne is in D minor.
-
@Aerich711 Then we are not talking about the same piece.
-
@Browniesisgood Umm... yeah, no. This is definitely nothing like the Chaconne. Stylistically it's similar, but it's in C minor, not D minor. Also, aside from the brief bariolage section she does (which Bach certainly doesn't have a patent on), I hear no quoting of the Chaconne or any other Bach piece for that matter. The intro is a unique composition and isn't "from" anything.
Qualifications: I'm a violin performance major and have played the Chaconne.
Asians+Jazz= Orgasm
Martel211996 1 year ago 18
SHE'S SO FRIGGIN GOOD!
Eagleflight2442 1 year ago 8