One last adventure The last voyage of Robert Falcon Scott
Top Comments
All Comments (50)
-
Those who have gotten all pissed off at Roland Huntford's expose of Scott can't take the truth. He busted a myth, a big myth. Good for him.
-
@mjwquinn Funny how the dogs were no problem for Amundsen. In fact, they were decisive.
-
@mjwquinn Where I live, the temperature over the course of a year can vary between 100F and -20F or lower. I've supported Amundsen since childhood. I've done a good deal of research as to Amundsen and Scott. Facts are, Amundsen knew what he was doing, Scott with equivalent experience didn't. To my knowledge, the Scott apologists are exclusively British. I may have found an exception.
-
@mjwquinn I am using my brain. If Amundsen had encountered that blizzard that kept Scott in his tent for 2-4 days (as per Solomon), the dogs would have enabled him to keep going. Amundsen was managing 13+ miles per days even in blizzards.
-
@TheMythOfRescue PS scott did identify a problem "the dogs" which is why he didn't take them! and if i was leaving tomorrow id take my new bombardier not my old polaris and if i died id still be happier i left it at home because it really pisses me off! so there human nature
-
@TheMythOfRescue further more once again, I judge explorers by my own experience of living and working in northern canada with almost a 100 degree temperature change, i know what its like to have frostbite and be stuck in the middle of nowhere! And I say to you that if big oil cant get supply and transportation right today how do you by watching youtube videos and reading wikipedia earn any credibility to criticise early 20th century explorers.
-
@TheMythOfRescue Like I said Use your own Brain, the dogs comment was quite clearly a reference to scott being stuck during his last days where Amudson would, if he hit that weather, been in the same position. You do not need to quote facts like knowledge because ive seen all the videos and information you have so plagierism is not needed here. My point to you is explorers use there own personal experiences and technology advancement to decide how they conduct their expeditions - not hindsight!
-
@TheMythOfRescue The British love debacles. They're still talking about Dunkirk. It's my opinion that they should concern themselves with the enemy they've imported. The next Dunkirk might be in Dover.
I was raised to hate the Russkies. That has faded to extreme dislike. They're asian in thought and deed.
Scott was an egotist convinced of his own infallability [much life Obama].
I prefer guys like Richard Francis Burton. His journal of his trip to Mecca is fascinating.
True Character.... sadly it seems in short supply these days
swmsalem 2 years ago 5
Ermm .. Sorry but the pics were of Earnest Shackleton and the 28 men trapped on Elephant Island which did not leave the u.k. until 3 years after R.F.Scotts ill fated expedition to the South Pole in 1911 . ( 22 men actually, 6 inluding Shackleton navigated 800 miles to South Georgia to seek help)
Tyne56 7 months ago 3