Star Trek XI with a better soundtrack (I)
Uploader Comments (tvTrequer)
Top Comments
-
Not only does it not fit but you're silly to think that Michael Giacchino's score is anything short of awesome.
Jesus, why do trekkies have such an issue with Star Trek being exciting and watchable?
-
If only Jerry Goldsmith's theme was in this movie.
All Comments (93)
-
@Nikatsu I can't tell you how grateful people like you exist! After reading the insane comments comparing favorably Michael Giachinno's pabulum to Jerry Goldsmith's genius it is reassuring to see good taste and discernment still exist.
-
@AndycorpPro You're talking about Michael Giachinno's score,right?
-
@Coltfighter except that Giacchino used the theme from the old TV series....
-
I thought that Jerry Goldsmith's theme felt like returning to a long lost love while Micheal Giacchino's theme felt like love at first sight with a sense of some whoop ass tonight.
-
@Raymint It's because we're used to decades of utter shit; we don't know how to appreciate good Star Trek anymore.
-
This is excellent! I liked much of the XI score, but this scene in particular was really lacking the emotional impact it should have had...it *should* nearly bring you to tears!
-
@plastique45 I have one thank you very much.
-
@Raymint I don't know if they have any, but you have an issue realizing Giacchino is a video game composer of no talent whatsoever and his score was horrible. Of course this doesn't fit, it's not scored for it and it's not professionally mixed. It's still better than the actual score.
-
@SChaos1701 I order you to get a soul.
-
This just ruins the scene. The XI score > this.



I still think Giacchino soundtrack was too generic...
tvTrequer 2 years ago 2
The soundtrack from XI was great....this music in this video...not so great. Hate to say it. Not being disrespectful...just not my cup of tea.
SChaos1701 2 years ago
Ok.
Thanks for commenting.
tvTrequer 2 years ago