Jay Chou 23/02/08 Malaysia Concert - Secret Piano

Secret Piano

Category:

Travel & Events

Tags:

• Jay
• Chou
• 23/02/08
• Malaysia
• Concert

[wisnu1231]

the beginning part must be repeated 2 times

[666Deathscythe]

@abchangk he still a human dude.. :)

[Yasminmonlol]

I think he would've gone 100 years into the past if he played that fast in the movie. LOL

[1Sedicar]

@Einfrein Well Terdsak Janpan's name was written beside all of Jay Chou's songs it said composed by Jay chou+ Terdsak Janpan. then I looked him up. he's an actual composer, composing music way before Jay Chou even started out. I think that's why Jay Chou chose him. so it's quite obvious that he needed help with the composing. otherwise why else would he need him?

[Einfrein]

@1Sedicar

But I'm not saying 100% that he did write it. I just think so.

Yeah well, he is still the songwriter of the song, whether he used help or not, right? As well as the other ones also may be classified as the songwriter of the song, but he probably came up with the main music of each song, or else he wouldn't be credited as the composer/songwriter, right?

And yes, Terdsak Japan DEFINITELY wrote some of the songs in the movie, and he MAY have helped Jay Chou with some of Jay's songs.

[Einfrein]

@1Sedicar

Yeah, I know, I watched that video too. That's why I was so confused, but if that's all the argument you have for Terdsak Japan writing it, I really don't believe he wrote it. I rather believe the uploader of that video, and thereby the writer of that description, is wrong. It says Jay Chou wrote that song on my original sheet music, plus he used one of Lu Xiao Yu's theme in his song "Pu Gong Ying De Yue Ding" (Dandelion's Promise), and he has all the credits for writing the music.

[Einfrein]

@1Sedicar

Secret 2 hasn't been produced yet, so it's no wonder why you haven't seen it yet ;)

Yes it was a great movie, both the story and music, but it had some loopholes in it. But still among my favourite films.

Well, it says "Music by: Terdsak Japan, Jay Chou", even if you missed it. It is understandable that you didn't pay any attention to who wrote the music if you didn't even know Jay Chou wrote music, although if you really enjoyed the music you might've read that.

[1Sedicar]

@Einfrein I'm not assuming that.... I know that he didn't. because it was composed by someone else. says somewhere on someone's video of them performing it. " Original song composed by Terdsak Janpan and performed by Jay Chou."

watch?v=zhc8WjOlax0

I also looked at some of the credits and it shows that Jay chou didn't compose all of the songs on his own he had help from others to compose the pieces... even on the song "secret".

[1Sedicar]

@Einfrein I know he directed it... actually thinking about it. I did read that in the Wikipedia after I watched secret 1. I even read all about secret in the Wikipedia to see when secret 2 was coming out, but I didn't see where they say he composed the music they only say it's directed by him. Well anyways secret 1 was a good movie especially for those who enjoy classical music, I haven't watched secret 2 yet I'd like to see what other nice pieces of music it has.

[Einfrein]

@1Sedicar

True, that's why I said you should get your facts right before commenting (okay maybe I didn't say it like that, but still?).

And for the record, he also directed it ;)