Poison the Well - Today (Smashing Pumpkins Cover)
Top Comments
All Comments (83)
-
@Nfox0900 I happen to like ever genre out there, except country, and justin bieber. I have a 50k+ library with everything from Ravel to Kitaro and Napalm Death to Redman, and some Gloria Jones on Vinyl. I was merely stating, while its OK to have your own opinion, that you can say was you said about screaming can apply to any other musical instrument in existence, even the kazoo.
-
@phil600616 Finally, maybe before you claim that someone has musical idiocy, next time you should try taking to heart that not everyone likes YOUR style of music. Thats why theres so many different genres of music, musical opinion. Unless someone likes Bieber. then theyre an idiot.
-
@phil600616 basically what I'm trying to get at here is that it's not really my style. I have a friend who sings for a screamo band, ive seen his band a couple times, and enjoyed it despite my dislike for the style. Everyone has their own taste in music, so I dont bash peoples interests usually. Its an interesting cover of the song, in all honesty though while its an okay cover to me, I cant say its really good based mainly off my musical tastes.I have an open mind, I also have a musical opinion
-
@phil600616 What? No of course not! I have nothing against screamo or screaming in general, its just not my personal taste, as I said to me it seems like it takes away from the actual voice of the singer. That said its sometimes used to perfection, but on a song like this that was written specifically to sound happy and cheery despite its dark lyrics, it doesnt quite reach the same effect. Its not like Im a close minded music fan, I listen to everything from A7X to the Doors to Nirvana gladly
-
@Nfox0900 you sir, are a musical idiot. The voice is just like any other instrument. I suppose you'll say that distorted guitars are an abuse of the blues distortion classic in jazz.
-
@shymenH shut the fuck up dude, PTW kicks ass no one cares about Ben Kwellers version. PTW straight up did an amazing cover. The screaming is better than your mom in bed. fag
-
The guitars were lacking something,otherwise good! PTW!!!!
-
PTW are one of the best hardcore bands going around. And i agree with negativedrew its a hardcore band expect screaming or else dont listen to it.
-
na dude, I think PTW's earliest work was the best concerning vocals, that scream was raw, angry, and unique. Shit is awesome
-
lol at all these dorks complaining about screaming from a hardcore band.
AS a huge Pumpkins fan, I liked this.
MykeMetyll 1 year ago 17
@shrew616 lol its bad quality because the file has probably been compressed so many times from p2p.. I have an .m4a of this that sounds just fine :)
illfists 2 years ago 9