Main problem with asking for a recommendation is if the linesman said it was red welsh fans would have accused the officials of bias. Even though im welsh i think 2 things of the wales-ireland game
1)-Bradley Davies should have been red
2)-Stephen Ferris' 'spear' was only a penalty and not a yellow. RANT OVER :)
@Tlevids You're right. But it's vitally important that we don't only scrutinise decisions when they really matter. If it had been the last minute it should still be scrutinised. TMO should be used in these situations. The ref shouldn't have asked for a recommendation. Turned horizontal = Red. That's all he needs to know. Rules are rules.
I agree that BD's tackle should have been a red, but whether it was red or yellow really wouldn't have influenced the game much. If he had scored the final try then I would agree with you, but this didn't happen, and neither was he instrumental in setting it up.
If this is red card how is Davies tackle against ireland a yellow???!!!! Davies dropped the irish player from shoulder hight!! CHEATS!! Two years in a row the welsh cheated against ireland in the six nations!!!
omfg im welsh my self, ye it was a bad tackle but not worth red crickeyyy bradley davies tackle against irland on 9 feb 012 tha was red shouldav
mongoTV777 22 hours ago
yellow card is what it should've been
RED WTF too harsh !!!!!! BAD decicion ALAN ROLAN :|
MsEddie98 1 week ago
Yellow cox he did drop him but a sweet hit none the less
englandrugbyrules 1 week ago
@channelnw
Main problem with asking for a recommendation is if the linesman said it was red welsh fans would have accused the officials of bias. Even though im welsh i think 2 things of the wales-ireland game
1)-Bradley Davies should have been red
2)-Stephen Ferris' 'spear' was only a penalty and not a yellow. RANT OVER :)
H4RR15K1D 2 weeks ago
Yellow. Simples
MadocNco 3 weeks ago
@Tlevids You're right. But it's vitally important that we don't only scrutinise decisions when they really matter. If it had been the last minute it should still be scrutinised. TMO should be used in these situations. The ref shouldn't have asked for a recommendation. Turned horizontal = Red. That's all he needs to know. Rules are rules.
channelnw 3 weeks ago
@flimslaaxfalera
I agree that BD's tackle should have been a red, but whether it was red or yellow really wouldn't have influenced the game much. If he had scored the final try then I would agree with you, but this didn't happen, and neither was he instrumental in setting it up.
Tlevids 3 weeks ago
If this is red card how is Davies tackle against ireland a yellow???!!!! Davies dropped the irish player from shoulder hight!! CHEATS!! Two years in a row the welsh cheated against ireland in the six nations!!!
flimslaaxfalera 3 weeks ago
Yellow card sin bin 10 minutes
taylor1654 3 weeks ago
seen worse tackles in under 10s never a sending off, an nothing to do with french/irish ref
boogieboy1974 3 weeks ago