Dawkins vs. Tyson
Loading...
Uploaded by agillesp123 on Nov 22, 2006
At the 'Beyond Belief' discussion, Tyson rebukes Dawkins for his rhetorical style, and Dawkins responds brilliantly.
- 10,867 likes, 416 dislikes
-
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
All Comments (26,603)
-
@povsepian the point is. just because you can't prove they do or do not exist. don't discredit the idea that they can.
-
@povsepian remarkable work with logical proofs about a being that he refers to as the un-caused cause, or in our words, God.
-
@povsepian and with premises means that each one holds a truth value, one of either true or false. While you might not be able to establish the fact that it doesn't hold a truth value of true. that doesn't automatically make it a truth value of false. just like proving the validity of an argument, just because it doesn't fit one of the five famous forms, that doesn't make it an invalid argument. Now, do some research on St. Augustine and his proofs for the uncaused cause and he's got some
-
@povsepian Yes, I see now, in the terms of logic that I did ask him to prove a negative. You need to realize, that I also formed the argument in the negative form. lets take the positive. Prove that God does exist. While you may not be able to prove that he does exist that doesn't diminish the fact that he doesn't exist. If you're bringing logic into this, then you need to realize that this argument, just like all of them, is basses on the foundation of premises.
-
LOL This is hilarious.
-
Insulting people, who already have their defense up, is not the most efficient way to educate them.
2 days ago 3
-
Gotta love em both^^
-
get his ear Tyson!
- 3:02Neil deGrasse Tyson on Science and Faithby bigthink114,514 views
-
richarddawkinsdotnetChannel141 videos
- 0:44The Best Richard Dawkins Moment Ever!!!by ZachValkyrie792,524 views
- 4:40Bill O'Reilly SCARED by Richard Dawkinsby ComedyJesus4,208,234 views
- 2:15Dawkins Dumbfounded by Ignorant Creationist Int...by no2religions339,763 views
- 0:33Oh Lydia... - Skyrimby MalakaiTheNinja2,053,944 views
- 7:14How to argue with a Muslimby ZaneArf239,758 views
- 5:21Neil Tyson destroys Muslims' false argumentby TheCrocoduck62,060 views
- 1:22Disproving Atheists in 82 secondsby pamuk7405,866 views
- 0:53Smart Kids Spy on Neighborby coolcommercials02194,818 views
- 5:34Why Tolerance Is Condescendingby bigthink120,326 views
- 0:48Family Guy makes fun of Creationistsby robertedge903,572 views
- 3:53New reasons to hate peopleby moppix5,124,659 views
- 1:16Atheist Bitchslapby bdwilson1000712,372 views
- 1:43:28Richard Dawkins Vs. William Lane Craig Debateby ChristopherHitchslap13,184 views
- 11:16Sam Harris simply destroys catholicismby 71Plastico139,311 views
- 6:07Ben Stein vs. Richard Dawkins Interviewby grn8r367,892 views
- 2:11The Strongest Material Known to Manby bigthink489,131 views
- 1:57Dawkins Breaks a Man's Heart | Dawkinsby Sqirril191,377 views
- 4:31Stupid people doing stupid thingsby GaloreVideos5,738,077 views
I just want to say that Tyson is a fucking cool dude. And it's not that he's disagreeing with any of Dawkins points, it's just that he in an over exaggerated way was saying that if dawkins had a bit more salesmanship attitude towards his learnings, more people would be inclined to listen. You can take that anyway you like. I agree with both of these men though. Science is indeed interesting, and fuck you.
bigbakaboon 3 weeks ago 34
And then Tyson said: "Watch out we got a badass over here"
Eniacbc 2 weeks ago 31