Uploaded by RealIdolFans on Apr 15, 2008
http://www.IdolRings.com
Carley Smithson performs "Without You" by Mariah Carey during the Final Seven American Idol Episode on April 15th 2008.
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
All Comments (166)
-
@onysak88 Mariah is.........AWESOME!!!!!
-
I REALLY REALLY HATE IT WHEN THEY COMPARE PPL TO MARIAH, OK YES SHES' GREAT NO ONE CAN BEAT HER..BUT ITS NOT FUCKIN MARIAH SINGING ITS CARLY...SHUT THE HELL UP AND STOP MENTIONING HOW GREAT MARIAH IS, IT'S ANNOYING!
-
YOu sound GRRRReat...Great Tone!!
i just recorded this..."Live"..would LUV & appreciate any comments@@ my channel
Blessings :)
-
nice voice. love it.
-
@felo4444 mariah is an incredible songwriter too :)
-
all the famous divas sing songs that are not theirs and they get credit for it.there are singers and songwriters. and even if this song was not written by Mariah carey,she really kills it and in my opinion is the best that i've heard so far.
-
@musikclassher0 IDK But I Perfer Mariah's Performance I Mean Come On Her Version Has More Melisma And Is Soulful. But Then Again That's Just My Opinion.
-
@1marisolmc I wouldn't say she was better, just much different... Also she shouldn't get as much credit for something that isn't hers.
-
@musikclassher0 I Think We All Know That But They Give Mariah More Credit Because She SANG It better Than Them.
-
FYI, this song is not BY Mariah Carey. She re-did it. The original was by a british rock band called Badfinger....
1:53Carley Smithson Ken Leeby gamutman13,074 views
Featured Video- 2:38Me singing Without you (Original)by Giftofmelody71,737 views
-
mariahcareyChannel21 videos
- 1:07David Archuleta- Heavenby robie93202,675 views
- 2:30Romana - Mariah Carey "Without you"by Vtbrinca40,834 views
- 4:43Carly Smithson - Jesus Christ Superstar (4-22-08)by idolmusic0869,525 views
- 1:47Without you - Mariah Careyby Laeti2659,294 views
- 4:57MARIAH CAREY - WITHOUT YOU - TOKYO 1996by VAUGHNYX944,770 views
- 3:35Mariah Carey - Without Youby djtony258,657 views
- 5:51Carly Smithson - Without You (4-15-08)by idolmusic0810,697 views
- 5:57Leona Lewis - Without Youby kingy1712,668,199 views
- 3:10Carly Smithson - Alone (Hollywood Week)by CarlySmithsonMusic174,674 views
- 3:53Mariah Carey - Without You With Lyricsby loayalqushy150,924 views
- 3:34me singing without you [mariah carey]by sekushi0yahh8889,452 views
- 3:24One Republic & David Archuleta - American Idol ...by RealIdolFans162,522 views
- 3:07Mariah Carey - Without you (MTV Studio Live)by Vinc13129142,812 views
- 3:36Without You - Mariah Carey (live at Cologne)by MariahLiveConcerts28,838 views
- 3:10Carly Smithson Auditionby wookiielover100,225 views
- 1:59Syesha Mercado - I Will Always Love You Americ...by bonk65124,762 views
- 3:16Without you-Mariah Carey-live in Spainby angbar27283,689 views
- 3:39MARIAH CAREY WITHOUT YOUby fairyally191,716 views
Pretty good. But all the singers just reminds you of how good mariah is.
Sall80 2 years ago 68
everyone who sings this song on Idol sound like they're struggle. Kelly, Leona, the girl who sings Ken Lee:p even if they can hit the high notes in the song, they struggle alot with the verse.. Kelly is stressed, Leona whispers... this girl sounds like a guy.. Mariah does it like nothing, and she can give anyone chills without turning up the pitch at the end
promisuous88 2 years ago 29