Uploader Comments (IndieKey)
Top Comments
-
Bless, I'm so proud of Birdy and I don't even know her!
All Comments (40)
-
2 people can not hear the sounds.
-
this is the first cover from Birdy that I didn't like. I couldn't listen to it till the end, and I'll now get over this trauma by listening to the original. No offense, I just don't believe anyone but Jonas can pull this off.
-
she really puts feeling in her songs, ♥
-
this song is amazing!
i can't wait for her album to be realeased in canada!
-
Please credit Mew for their music when you use it, Birdy.
Overall, it was an "ok" effort. Singing was the best part of this cover, while the end stretch was a disappointment.
-
This song reminds me of Murray Gold's music for Doctor Who 5:30 onwards-on the Doomsday episode with Rose in the parallel world where the Doctor is left the tardis alone and she is left on the beach crying all alone...I'm crying.
The original is a masterpiece, but this is simply stunning. A completely different take on the song, but I love this.
-
The original piece of art does not deserve to be copied by some girl with a mac. End of story.
-
@Colanissen666 at least try to give constructive criticism if you think it's wrong, i don't know, explain yourself a little bit instead of just hating.
-
Of course, I prefer the original. It's a masterpiece. But, this really is one of the best covers ever. The whole point of a cover is to take a great song you love and do it differently, and that's what she did. It's really beautiful, the way she's done it, and and I agree with another commenter, this is really uplifting, while the original is much more dark and somber.
-
Hmmm.. I like Birdy and her most of her covers but I've got to agree with some ya'll that this song should never be touched. It is in a league of it's own. Good try though.
@IndieKey I couldn't agree more ;) by the way, birdy is well known in holland :) she sang in a radio studio of 3FM. Type birdy giel in YouTube and you get to hear her live in that studio , she sang for 6 min sooo good:)
There was also a birdy contest for the dutch birdy, for the winner type this in on YouTube Anna verhoeven de tv draait door.
Siks7Ate9 1 month ago
@Siks7Ate9 OMG! I have no words to say about all those girls singing Skinny Love. Wow! And the cover of Laura Jansen's Signal was incredible. Seriously, I loved it so MUCH!
IndieKey 1 month ago
@ IndieKey, thank you so much for posting those tracks only available on the deluxe edition and within the UK for MP3 dowloads : )
mezzocase 3 months ago
@mezzocase you're welcome! Music is something universal, can't be limited to one country or nation, everyone needs to hear it :)
IndieKey 3 months ago 12
@IndieKey the rest of the world can have Bieber...we only want Birdy in the UK. She's a great talent
BlaiseKingII 1 month ago
@BlaiseKingII the rest of the world deserves good music, it's not about Justin Bieber or Birdy, either someone, it's all about music, made to be listened. Birdy is so talented to be recognized only in one country, as for sure in a place exist an amazing singer that I don't know and probably I would love to hear her/his songs. This is the purpose of my channel, share music that I consider good for the world.
UK have so many wonderful artists, don't be selfish with the rest of the world!
greetings
IndieKey 1 month ago