Peer Review of the Bedini / Hamel Spinner Part IIIB

This is section B of my peer review of the Bedini / Hamel spinner.

As you can see, I now have the original ring magnet constructed with 14 magnets; all with north poles facing in. And it is now mounted in a centered and stationary position below the glass.

(The video looks like things are off center but I assure you this is simply the camera angle required in order to look into and down through the frame that supports the lifting device.)

And I have the disk magnet, with sphere, and south pole up, attached underneath the glass as well.
This is being held perfectly centered inside the ring magnet by another magnet above the glass.

The objective here is to remotely release the spinner allowing it to drop a small distance THROUGH the strongest influence of the ring magnet and remain upright and under the influence of the ring magnet.

IF there is a vortex present, this should result in at LEAST one revolution of the disk.

So, lets find out shall we?

So, as you can see, after repeated attempts and after spending my money and lots of time on this, my conclusion is: NO VORTEX PRESENT!!!

So, time to place this TOY back on the shelf and build something that actually works such as an SSG energizer.

And, if you want to demonstrate a magnetic vortex, you will place your individual magnets in a spiral or cone pattern. And not line them all up along the single axis of a ring.

Thank you for watching, have a good day.

Category:

Science & Technology

Tags:

• Bedini
• Hamel
• Spinner
• Free
• Energy
• Magnetic
• Motor
• Demonstration
• Vortex
• Gate
• SSG
• Currents
• Replicate
• Rig

[Segnet37451172]

your device looks diffrent. you have one two many magnets in your ring. remove one magnet from the ring so a vortex will be created

[ScorchGD]

@Segnet37451172 That was done in one of the other videos. It made no difference in the peculiar effect of a supported sphere being teased across a smooth surface. And I can produce the same spinning effect with just ONE magnet or even NO magnet.

[GaOlSt]

I salute you! so much work just to prove Hamel Spinner DONT WORK and never worked.

[ScorchGD]

Thank you.

I produced these videos after a yahoo groupie proposed spinners be distributed as demonstration PROOF of a magnetic vortex.

There I suggested without a THOROUGH explanation of the OTHER forces causing spin; this would be a BAD idea.

Without warning I was booted from the Bedini Monopole3 yahoo group for making the 'ridiculous' suggestion to shelve this toy and study the practical application of Bedini technology instead.

New information censored?

Will they ever figure it out?

[Subspace4d]

your rotator magnet must have only one pole on the top. But your version has just south on one side.

[ScorchGD]

This has already been tried. The fact remains that spin is induced simply by the peculiar behavior of a supported sphere being teased across a flat surface. Until such time you can demonstrate a disk magnet spin WITHOUT this STRONG influence coming from OUTSIDE any existing magnetism then the experiment is flawed. Please provide a method of demonstration WITHOUT the SPHERE OF INFLUENCE. Which is a SIGNIFICANT CAUSE of spin. Thank you.

[Segnet37451172]

@ScorchGD the central magnet is "hanging" in the field which puts gravity and magnetic attraction in oposition to it's boyancy point.and preventing it from "tilting". where as in the hand held attemps, the magnet was ballanced ona ball. the grav. force would tend to cause it to tilt out of phase with the surrounding field. with the majority of the weight being suported on the ball rather than hanging in the field would tend to cause circular motion. as it tried to right itself. like a gyro

[K0W0O0N0]

Good experiment...

but i don´t know why anyone would expect a Vortex in it...

Cheers...

[Subspace4d]

Yes I agree your experiment is based on real facts.