(1/12) World War II Mind of a Code Breaker
Uploader Comments (2bn442RCT)
Top Comments
-
What about the Polish scientists who lost their lives delivering half of the job already Done to he guys Bletchley??
Anyway, Thank EDUCATION for all of them (Poznan's and Bletchley Park Scientists)
Video Responses
All Comments (33)
-
THIS JUST FANTASTIC STUFF
-
For more information I would refer you to Rejewski papers published and translated into English many many years after war. If you take into account the state of the pre-war cryptography you will understand why the British and the French were clueless before the meeting in Pyry.
-
This is why Bletchley Park succeeded so fast. Even though the Poles were the first to break Enigma during wartime, the method (Zygalski's sheets) they had to use because of technical limitations (they were operating in the occupied France, for some mysterious reason they were not in Blechley!!) soon proofed to be obsolete (after consecutive modifications).
-
But they were able to read it before the war as well (the machine was less complicated then). What is even more impressing they reverse-engineered the wirings in the military version's rotors without having access to the machine. They were technically unable to read it after the modifications introduced in 1938 – they only managed to design appropriate devices. These plans along with theoretical background were then transferred to the French and the British (secret meeting in Pyry).
-
Not entirely true. Poles were the first to read Enigma ciphertext during wartime (precisely on Jan 17, 1940).
-
Ok, let's get the facts right. Where did you get this video description from? It contains a number of historical inaccuracies (like the myth about Polish spies).
-
the Polish people were in bondage for almost 60 yrs, first the Nazis then the communists. I went to school with them all my life and there were very few dumb polocks, bless those poor people I am so glad they are finally free, we need their brain power.
-
Thnx for post-one of the most interesting on YT. I believe National Cash Register was involved in manufacture of deciphering equipment here in U.S. during WWII but have not seen any clip or books to confirm.
Rejewski broke the military Enigma (plugboard version) in 1932. He used a theorem on permutations to solve it. Along with his friends between 1932-1939 they designed mashines to facilitate and speed up the process of decrypting. Among others they designed a device called Rejewski Bomb. To brake the 1938 version of Enigma you had to take several RB and make them work in parallel. This is what Turing did creating Turing Bomb.
uka79 1 year ago 4
@uka79 Thanks for your imput!
2bn442RCT 1 year ago
It is good to recognize the contributions of the Poles in attacking the Enigma machine with replicates and deciphering messages using replicas and weak keys. Also good to remember that some of the Polish codebreakers fled to France and then to England to join the British codebreakers there and add their (promptly classified) experience and knowledge.
landen99 1 year ago 5
@landen99 They deserve credit
2bn442RCT 1 year ago
This Programme is just a re-edited and re-narrated version of the british channel 4 programme called 'Station X', Made by Darlow-Smithson productions in 1999.
Plattythegreat 2 years ago
@Plattythegreat Where can I find that.
2bn442RCT 2 years ago