Commentary: Books vs. Movies Review, A Christmas Carol

In which Matt fails to do a Christmas review, and instead just does a commentary of last year's.

All clips property of their respective owners.

Merry Christmas!

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• commentary
• books
• movies
• review
• christmas
• carol
• charles
• dickons

[UglyBetty70]

The Hobbit&christmas carol are my all time favorite books,Alistair Sims and Muppets is my favorite film adaptations of A Christmas Carol. Alistar Sim is the only Scrooge he convinces me anyways every time. Sherelock Holmes is also inspired so many movie adaptions and surprised that you haven't done a book vs. movies review on that or if you watch the Sherelock tv series by BBC and did a comparative review on that it would be interesting. But FIRST you need to do Miyazaki's Ponyo!! Please..

[bandgeek8408]

@UglyBetty70 Alastair Sim is also one of my favorite Scrooges. And I imagine I'll be looking into Sherlock Holmes at some point. And Ponyo is on my Netflix queue.

[MrMovieBrat]

Out of curosity, what's your opinion on the Doctor Who version of the story?

[bandgeek8408]

@MrMovieBrat I've not seen it, but I imagine I will someday.

[Myytmovies]

@bandgeek8408 Love to see you do a BvsM of "A Clockwork Orange" but I don't think the YT censors would allow it

[UglyBetty70]

PS watching again I agree with the chasing scene it was more to get a video game from this scene. I love the old Joe scene and was irked that they felt the need to add the chase.

[UglyBetty70]

@bandgeek8408 great! Ponyo worth seeing just for the animation alone, it's weird but good.. and you can discuss so much with Sherlock Holmes.

[VampireGuardian14]

Pete is actually a cat but I do agree with you Matt that was rather ridiculous but in all fairness alot of the fun of the Disney version is the various Disney Character Cameos however they could have made Things to Come Mickey's Arch Nemisis the Phantom Blot who rarely shows his face anyways