Clay Aiken - American Idol Season 2 - Top 7 Billy Joel Night - Tell Her About It

Simon says,"I like you better with my eyes closed." It is actually a compliment because he thinks Clay has a terrific singing voice, which is what really counts in this competition, he just doesn't like that thing Clay does with his mouth.

Although, I think Simon would have gotten in BIG trouble if he had given that same compliment to Susan Boyle! lol

Eh... Hate the slow beginning and he doesn't have the right sound for this song. He's a good singer.. but he made the wrong choice.