An Chailín Álainn : The Lovely Girl
Uploader Comments (UISTMAN59)
Top Comments
-
Yes, it is Tomás 'Jimmy' Mac Eoin, one of the best but least appreciated voices of Ireland for at least 30 years. He has great voice for a song but is also a masterful reciter. What a pity no one locked him into a studio somewhere to record him reading the top hundred Irish poems in both English and Irish.
What a treasure for all of us that would have been. I have lost my copy of his only cassette 'Tomás Jimmy'. It has a recording of 'An Bonnan Bui' / 'The Yellow Bittern' - the best ever made
-
bye the bye, Uisteach - you have a fine eye for a bonny lass.
All Comments (46)
-
@Yelpy1 Could you send me a copy of the mp3of Tomas Jimmy. tdmcg26@gmail.com
-
@UISTMAN59 Yes, I knew the second song was Tom Sloss. Just nice to hear an Irishman singing fluently in his native tongue - the way it should be. Not made-up words like BBC Esperanta!
-
Hey I have 'Tomás Jimmy' on MP3, I restored it a few years ago for a friend, if anyone needs a copy of this just throw me an email alan@yelpy.net :)
The 1st song is probably scottish! I know for a fact that the 2nd one is from Conemara because ive been there manys a time being from the west meself!
croinaheireann1 1 month ago
@croinaheireann1 What's all this "probably" nonsense? "Two songs, one in Irish Gaelic the other in Scottish Gaelic (translated from Irish). " Is that somehow not clear enough for you? !!!!!!!!!!!!
UISTMAN59 4 weeks ago
@UISTMAN59 im just saying that it sound alot like the Conemara dialect of Irish in the second song and that I learned this song siar i Ros a Mhil blianta ó shin!No need to fly off the handle at me in just saying what i think!
croinaheireann1 4 weeks ago
@croinaheireann1 I'm not flying off the handle. The first song is not "probably Scottish!" , it is in "Irish". The second is in "Scottish Gaelic" and has been translated from "Irish" into "Scottish Gaelic." Something far wrong when you don't recognise your own language. Maybe you need to go back to Ros a Mhil for refresher. :(
UISTMAN59 4 weeks ago
I see a lot of discussion re Gaelic here. Some attempts at scientific crap. This sounds to me like it is sung by an Irishman who actually speaks Gaelic as opposed to school-taught nonsense. I like this and a good pairing of songs by the man from Uist. (I'm half Uist myself!)
DasHearach 3 months ago
@DasHearach The first is sung by Tomas Jimmy , an Irishman singing in Gaelige. The second is sung by a man from Uist singing in Gaidhlig. I'm pretty sure neither learned the language in the classroom. Thanks for the final comment. :)
UISTMAN59 3 months ago