水浒 - 林冲 vs 杨志

这片子的武打效果做得比央视三国好

這是當然的,三國是94年的作品....

单刀对双手带，漂亮。可惜与史实不符，宋代刀形还要细长，并非牛 尾。

另外，0:22杨志那一扎刀，力量很大，林冲这个门户是闭不住的 ，除非侧身。

杨志那是朴刀

双手带和朴刀有啥区别？

那是军队的装备的手刀吧，直刀身更利于破甲，民间的朴刀究竟是何 样式似乎还没有定论。

well, for starters, what they drank probably wasn't wine, more like some sort of vodka I guess. Secondly, to sustain their life style, they need money, money and money, that's why the scale of combat they fought grew bigger and bigger, if you looked at the story line carefully, you would notice that the magnitude of battle roughly corresponded to the size of their rebel. Song Dynasty, among all Chinese dynasties, is noticed for its exceptionally prosperous economy based on trade as opposed to

agriculture which was, for the most part, the mainstay of Chinese economies during imperial China. For Song Jiang and his followers, their vociferous appetite for good drink and fine food could only be satisfied by robbing, or certain brand of wealth redistribution, whatever you may call it. As a result, it's inevitable they are gonna outrun their logistic by pushing further and further away from their bases and antagonizing more and more local militias, which, unlike government forces,

were well-trained, well-motivated fierce fighters. At that time, there was no deep social-economic problems for them to exploit, so there was little chance they were gonna actually overthrow the government. On the other hand, they were gonna to face more and more, wave after waves of attack from the government forces and their attacks on towns and counties would face even fiercer resistance. It's a dead end for them. Song, as the most politically savvy member of the outlaws,

realized their fatal deficiency in their particular model of rebellion, that's why he decided to sue for peace and negotiate with the government, he got no choice. If you look past his outwardly coward behaviors, you would realize he was actually trying to look out for his brothers and sisters. It didn't turn out that well, but at least he tried.