EVERYTHING SOAPY ...

The great thing about Tamara Braun's Carly is that she hardly EVER yelled but she was a TOTAL bitch.. This scene was the perfect example of her who her Carly was.. Cold, Calculating.. and a Character you just didnt mess with..

@ilikevampboys1 TOtally opposite of Laura Wright... Tamara had chemistry with everyone.. Laura only has chemistry with Ingo...

This is a Leading Lady performance.. There hasnt been a Leading Lady on General Hospital since Tamara Braun left in 2005...

Its really sad.. Soul Train was trying to Promote her talent from 2005-2008. This image is what really did her in. That ensemble is HORRID.. I am not sure if she had an official stylist or she styled herself but.. The Choice here was definitely NOT on the mark.. which is usually uncharacteristic ...

A great Defying Gravity that doesnt MURDER the voice... FABULOUS

I think she, more than anyone on Idol represents what is wrong with Idol.. That people with Real Talent, and REAL sellability LOSE the competition and people with no talent and no likeability WIN because of shamelss LAST minute Promotion...

The funny thing ..is .. about Lil Kim vs Nicki... is The Argument is really RAP vs. Pop MUSIC... Music Exec.. just wanna have a fake rap version in a POP sound.. They dont want a woman getting up on stage and doing what MEN do.. Like Lil Kim Said, Check the posters and videos, Youll always be Num...

Shoshana's is CLEARLY far superior to any of the other girls shown here.. None of them can compete with singing 7 Different Notes.. Christina could only hit 3.. as well as Whitney as well as some others.. Patty and Shoshana were the only 4+ in this video...

It really goes to say something.. Learn from Andrea Bocelli for 2 + years adn You really will start to make it...Kat McPHee is truly a STAR...

For me.. Its a Tie... Fantasia brings out the character within the Song the best.. however, Jennifer Hudson.. Portrays the MESSAGE of the Music.. more beautifually.. We, as fans, have traveled Jennifers Journey from Heavyset Nobody to Oscar Winner to Personal Tragedy.. to a BRAND NEW IMAGE...

I ...

I loved TB and SB as Jason and Carly.. They have always had that Ex-Boyfriend/Best Friend VIbe.. LW and SB just have a Bestie Vibe... They never seem to have chemistry as former sexual pertners.

Jennifer Hudson is hands down.. a far superior Actress and Singer than Fantasia.. Since her Families Death's, This song is 100% more poignant under the helms of Jennifer Hudson.. Sadly, I would hate to think that Jennifer Hudson would be known for being the artist that lost 1/2 of her family in t...

The truth is.. she is right.. If she were a normal teenager who had grown up and made mistakes .. and became famous.. Everything would be fine.. BUT shes not.. The world is obsessed with Lindsay Lohan.. They have been since she was in Mean Girls...

I absolutely love Lindsay Lohan .. .because she is the last Paparazzi crazed 20 something left with REAL talent... She is our Judy..

OK.. yea. what rapper doesnt rap live... oh wait that would be nikki garbage...

His age fits... For once.. it fits with the storyline..

The biggest disappointment in this performance is Samantha Barks.. I dont understand her portrayal of this song... Its very disconnected... Nick is actually doing a fine job.. His Marius is Caring but yet uncomfortable because his best friend is hitting on him while she is dying...his role fits...

This is why THE WORLD has fallen in love with KIM K.. because she is girl from the block who would give you the shirt off her back...if she could..

Diana Degarmo is,was, and always will be an amazing talent.. Young and The Restless realized they needed to bottom line their song purchases by having an in-house singer/writer rather than purchasing songs to air all the time..

The blocking is very bad.. however it tells a differents story.. A max and elsa story...

im a true Kim fan... but Kim's downfall was when she left her hood image behind.. its why shes a legend... This opened up Nikki GARBAGE to steal her style and make it current ...

A legend .. who actually raps live... NOW THIS IS FEMALE RAP...

Megan Hilty is great .. but this was definitely a MISCAST...Diana Degarmos version was The only capable Doralee other than Dolly...

Lets keep in mind that Eden is 9 yrs older than Diana Degarmo.. So when Diana was doing this at 19, only a little over 2 yrs out of her AI run..Eden was a sharp 28...Prime in her career as a Singer and Broadway Actress...

Its kind of like Kristin Chenoweth stepping in for Bernadette Peters.. Sur...

This was sad because her earpeice was too loud and she couldnt hear .. I will always remember this performance.. Diana would have won had it not been for the sucky technical elements of this show.. Lets remember this was the first year they went to the BIG stage...for the finale...

Tamara and Maurice had INSTANT chemistry. Laura and Maurice have NO CHEMISTRY. Sarah and Maurice have Amazing Chemistry. Jennifer and Maurice had Chemistry

Case and point.. LAURA IS NOT CARLY.. SHe is a bitchy CASSIE..

Tamara's Carly was DANGEROUS.. Didnt noone mess with Tamaras Carly ...

Again, Kerry and Diana are the Top 2 .. Kerry begun this Penny hairspray journey, So everything was written with her in mind so her vocals fit perfectly with the lyrics.. Diana, however, reimagined the role of Penny and both girls conceptions of the role.. are PERFECTION...

Lisa and Diana .. is that even a competition...

Shoshana's Elphaba had the most depth.. She went from Naive to Vulnerable to Confident to Vulnerable to Truth seeking... And her rendition was so honest to the characters core..

Shes a soprano and when she got the Elphaba role. Her career changed drastically with this role.. The effects of treating her voice as an High Ranging Alto .. is doing disasters to her vocal cords..

Shoshana's comedic timing is amazing..