stevegreenfield's channel
Loading...
-
stevegreenfield
favorited
10 months ago
Yoshitake Hashimoto Shihan - Shikko Part 2: backward - Junshinkai Aikido
Friendship Seminar - Newport Dojo - Melbourne 2011
-
Spaceflight (Flashlight) George Clinton P-Funk Pepe The Prawn
Pepe The Prawn from the Muppets sings with George Clinton and P-Funk. It's basically Flashlight with Pepe singing along.
-
Joe Esposito - You're The Best Around (Karate Kid soundtrack)
Joe Esposito - You're the Best Around.
From The Karate Kid soundtrack.
Annotations relating to some of the London Tekken players/personalities, an...
-
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
@TSOAS2008 YOu have said on facebook that people run away from debating with you because you have the 'truth' . perhaps you should consider that the reason people 'give up' is because you dont debate , you cling to your theories and despite any evidence to the contrary you 'rationalise' things in...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
Nagayamas drawing -at that scale any degree or sori is going to be impercetible , 1800s picture - you know there were other editions of the same work that didnt have the blades as straight , 1600s quote as a number of people have pointed out that phrase can mean other things. The debate on point ...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
@MrMmafan - ok , there are sepparate issues here
so If i have this correct
1) The iconic STRAIGHT ninja sword as alleged to have been 'attached' to Mr Hayes did or did not exist in the historical record . So, antony do you as Mr Mmafan says you do in the video, admit that in fact this particular...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
'Did there exist a sword which was conected to the ninja with a square tsuba before Hayes appears. ' will you agree that this is actually a completely different question that you posed in your first video, then the debate can actually move forward. And further admit that what you argued for in th...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
i really should spellcheck before i post
the sorry in question 2 is sori - indicating curve
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
@stevegreenfield my mistake, 1) Was the premise of your first video to demonstarte the existance of the straight blade square tsuba 'ninja sword' in history yes or no
My fault , i wish to make this exact as it is on your first video
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
@TSOAS2008 if Mr Hayes changed it from 3mm to 6mm sori it would still be a curved blade not straight.
Basic questions then antony
1) Was the premise of your first video to demonstrate the existance of the STRAIGHT blade square tsuba sword in history - yes or no
2) If yes, do you think that by ...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
so when had you changed this from whether or not the straight sword with the square tsuba existed in history , to the ninja suit
-
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
the point of this series of videos on the ninja sword, was as i quote to show whether ' the straight bladed square guarded' ninja sword existed in history - that was the opening of video number one. you then went on and sword two ninjato in chokuto form - that is the opening remarks on what you ...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
@MrMmafan111 but is history, its the little details that are important, and when the suppositionis that a straight bladed square tsuba sword existed, and you provide curved ones, its wrong. The blade geometry and general shape that is presented as the 80s ninjato differs from what antony has pres...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
ok, where does Hatsumi sensei say 'no square tsuba existed' - reference that quote
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
@MrMmafan111 sorry that question should read - If something has a curve, do you agree , by definition it isnt straight ?
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
He includes the definition in the videos - a straight sword. And in the fist video he states as attributed to Mr Hayes. That sword was of a reasonably specific design , and if you look at the ninjato sold at that time they were of chukoto form with chisel tip.
I am not saying a sword didnt exist ...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
logically broken down
-The straight bladed ninja sword attributed to mr hayes has been bound in history
- Evidence presented illusitrates swords that are acknowledged to have a curve or sori of even 1mm
-Definition of straight from oxford dictionaries online
Straight -noun
1 a part of something t...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
@MrMmafan111 also no one contested the existence of nagamaki naoshi , or even the appearance of curved swords , some with square tuba , some with round some with mokko in japanese books prior to Mr Hayes, most of us arguing here have all those books by fujita or nawa or Hatsumi sensei or access t...
-
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
@MrMmafan111 not at all thats not the argument. Antony said he had found the iconic ninja sword attributed to Mr Hayes in history. Now the argument being put forth by antony is that those not agreeing with him are arguing on semantics, that straighter isnt straight etc, but when you are talkign a...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
@MrMmafan111 a nagamaki or naganata is not a spear , a yari is a spear , the terms attributed to them are different, their form is different , their use is different. they are different. what antony presented was a nagamaki naoshi, the book did not state a spear/yari was 'cut down' it stated a na...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
so when you talk of str4aight what you mean is curved , is that what you are saying, straight means staright, a few mm of sori on the muni side equates to a curve, both on the mune/shinogi and at the ha , cutting edge. that means its not straight, does it not. The argument was that the 'straight'...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
a straight sword with a few mm curve is not a straight sword, and yes in japanese blades it matters a lot. The'iconic' ninja sword that is attributed in this argument to Mr Hayes , and if you dont believe me on its form have a check in the magazines, was a chukuto form , i.e. a staright blade for...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
again, your central argument is you have discovered the straight ninja sword , however when it has been point ed out that what you are presenting are blades with a curve, sori, which in fact you openly recognise by saying that a 1-5mm curve doesnt matter. so essentially what you are saying is tha...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
if you are arguing for the existence of a straight sword, anything other than straight is not that , it has a curve. you were arguing that you have found a striaght bladed ninja sword in history , you have not. because all you have shown a swords with curves. the curves may be shallow but they ar...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
sorry i meant 'few mm sori'
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
your whole argument seems to revolve on the fact that you will continue to argue on the fact that you still assert 'straighter' or straightened or only a fell mm curve is the same as straight. so at what point of mm sori does straight become curved
-
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
the orriginal drawing of the nagamaki naoshi in the book conoisseurs book of the sword is approx 4cm , are you really telling me you can , with a degree of accuracy say whether that has a sori of 1-5mm reliably
11:48 the first blade you show is a tanto, is it not, the second has a noticible curve...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
7:18 your line clearly shows a portion of the scabbard outside of the line does it not, would that not indicate a shallow curve... 8:12yes you have misquoted as has been demonstrated in comments on you previous videos. What appear merw semantics to you have a large bearing to the point you are m...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
3:46 but the sword having ' the slightest bend' means it is not a 'straight sword' yes or no? 4:08 please do not speak in that way about my teacher it is quite uncalled for, and in my time with manaka sensei training in ninja bike, a straight sword has never been used or mentioned, and i can happ...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
2:03 yes the fittings are blade , lots of saya and blade fittings were, it was quite commom , 2:59 hatsumi sensei is saying it is a ninjatou because in the togakure ryu it says as such. I.e. It was a sword used in his school of ninjutsu in certain circumstances, there are other varriants . The ar...
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 3
Part 3 of the debate
0.47 you miss out the blade shape conventiently, i.e. Chokuto , and dont say ita not important or you are really showing up your lack of knowledge of nihontou 1.01 no one is saying mr hayes made a square tsuba 1:03 almost straight doesnt mean straight and before you go any further try reading the...
-
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 2
Did you know that the straight bladed sword existed in quotes, images and in the archaeological record? Well, it did. The ninja sword was not a nin...
The 'ninja sword' as would be recognised today , is a short bladed , chokuto style blade with a square tsuba, with a ko kimassu tip. No such swords exist in Japanese history. Curved , even small is not straight. You stated a 'ninja sword' existed in history , you have not demonstrated that, but y...
-
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 2
Did you know that the straight bladed sword existed in quotes, images and in the archaeological record? Well, it did. The ninja sword was not a nin...
And what it does not say , which is what you say in the video 'shave off the back of the blade to make it straight ' that is not what is said at all. So do you know what period that nagamakinaoshi were made , do you have contemporary evidence to state ashigaru were using nagamakinaoshi , or is it...
-
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 2
Did you know that the straight bladed sword existed in quotes, images and in the archaeological record? Well, it did. The ninja sword was not a nin...
No, it's shows a nagamaki being 'properly reshaped ' into a more usual sword shape. The term spear , as applied in Japanese blades is diifferent from a nagamaki both in nomenclature , construction, form and use .
-
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 2
Did you know that the straight bladed sword existed in quotes, images and in the archaeological record? Well, it did. The ninja sword was not a nin...
And the drawing on page 49 shows the coversion of the shobu zukuri blade shape of a naginata into a shinogi zuki shape , the more sommon blade shape for a katana. , theyare forming a kissaki and properly reshaping the naginata/nagamaki into a katana
-
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 2
Did you know that the straight bladed sword existed in quotes, images and in the archaeological record? Well, it did. The ninja sword was not a nin...
You cannot make it more curved without removing metal from shinogi, the ha would not be reshaped unless necesary and ammount depending on hamon width, the process on page 49 illustrates the kissaki reshaping because nagaki kissaki shape differs to katana and wakazashi
-
The "Ninja Sword" Found In History - Part 2
Did you know that the straight bladed sword existed in quotes, images and in the archaeological record? Well, it did. The ninja sword was not a nin...
On page 26 of the connoisseurs book of the japanese sword it states the following (emphasis my own) "in addition to shortening the tang ,the upper portion of the back of the blade was also removed AND THE BLADE PROPERLY RESHAPED FOR USE AS A KATANA OR WAKAZASHI" this was following an explanation ...
-
Antony seems to think your video supports his theory and a 3-5mm sori doesn't matter , that in itself show up him lack of knowledge of Japanese blades and his willingness to twist any evidence to fit his agenda
-
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
NINJA SWORD not FOUND IN HISTORY
antony's video was a little misleading, there are various versions of the zohyo monogatari, straight swords appear in only one.
I believe te comment he made at me 'antony says it is not Ninja 100% ' etc was mistakingly sent from his own account , I beleve that it was meant to be sent from another account , otherwise why would it be phrased as if someone else was writing it
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
NINJA SWORD not FOUND IN HISTORY
antony's video was a little misleading, there are various versions of the zohyo monogatari, straight swords appear in only one.
No he doesnt say it , and on page 26 states the bladenwould be properly reshaped to be used as a katana or wazishashi. No mention of straight. Looks straighter possibly depentding on the orriginal nagamaki, straight, no
-
stevegreenfield
commented
11 months ago
NINJA SWORD not FOUND IN HISTORY
antony's video was a little misleading, there are various versions of the zohyo monogatari, straight swords appear in only one.
@TSOAS2008i am asking you to explain why a comment attributed to your account as a reply to me says"antony is saying 100% is is not ninja" - so is it 1) talking in third person2) someone else using your account
-
-
stevegreenfield
favorited
11 months ago
GLC - Dog Porn
Another requested tune from Goldie Lookin' Chain
-
Scottbaioisdead lies and is exposed Part 2 & doesnt really know the Ninpo Bugei of genbukan
I further own scottbaioisdead and expose his lies and his lack of knowledge . You all witnessed how he got my other video taken down. He went cryin...
-
About stevegreenfield's channel
The Ninpiden in English
The ninpiden in English and two other secret manuals!!!
1,120 views
stevegreenfield said:
@TSOAS2008 there is a modern version on amazon japan , at least there was a few weeks ago for about $60.
The Ninpiden in English
The ninpiden in English and two other secret manuals!!!
1,120 views
stevegreenfield said:
Very interesting, As far as im aware the Gunpo Jiyo shu consists of 12 volumes , which volumes have you translated? Was it taken from the orriginal or from the modern translation. I know the Iga museum has 5 volumes but my impression was they were missing the 'ninjutsu' volumes just interested wh...
Antony admitted it wasn't straight
ふぐり！
1,216 views
stevegreenfield said:
from Connoisseurs book of japanese sword - anthony cited as reference
Page 55 the curvature or sori of the japanese sword distinguishes it from the pre heian chokuto or straight sword
Kanbun shinto sword (which seems to be the one the pictures indicate - - representative of early edo period 1644...
+ One more videoshow less