paulkate72's channel

@HeWhoIsIAm420 - Sorry to hear that you're an amalgamation of all three of the above. Not sure about intellectuals - anyone blessed with common sense would come out on top, hands down, against such ones.

Also don't know what lolwut means, and I don't thank I want to. Cheers!

@Sshelly34213 - Haven't heard Al's version is it available on YT pls?

Great song - thanks for uploading, rachaelseitz.

Surely one of the best true country music voices of all time. This song and I'm Moving On are the real-deal songs of the way country music was, and still should be, in my view. What a loss when he left us!

Terrible - Hank Snow's version is like a Bugatti Veyron compared to the Stones T-Model Ford!

This seems to be the best version on YT of San Antonio Rose by Bob Wills and anyone else for that matter. Good song!

@decoycarver17- Remember from those nasty animals we get wool, lamb and various other products - not really so nasty, are they?

@jellyrollbaker - Thanks for your comments. It's all in the taste and playing style, isn't it? No doubt the other two are greats - I've heard them and everyone else says they are, yet they don't grab me. Cheers!

Were a very good band a long time ago. Better managed they could have been a real force in British music, but they weren't and didn't - shame

Good song then and a good song now. Notice how the good songs last and become evergreens? Will many of the present songs achieve that? Unlikely I think.

This is not Lulu's best song.

The girls are pretty good, I think. Even so, I don't like the song and I've heard the late Johnny O'Keefe (from Australia) and Lulu sing it and I didn't like their versions of the song either. Taste, I suppose.

All these band were absolutely 1st class: Carroll Gibbons, Ambrose AHO, Lew Stone, Roy Fox, Ray Noble. The singers with them made a big difference too, for example Sam Browne, Ann Lenner and the incomparable Al Bowlly. What a golden age of unforgettable music!

@shnaz2 - It's to your credit that you've said what you have here. It takes humility to do that, so thanks for taking the time to do so. Cheers!

@richmond196- Agree absolutely - they were superb and will we see their like again - I don't think so...

@SenLinFu - Does seem a bit that way. Thanks for your comments - good singers from the 60s are a bit thin on the ground nowadays.

@donquixote2u - Thanks for the info about this song not being a hit in the US, esp Wheeling. Surprised to hear that - too good not to have been a hit. Cheers!

No doubt about it PJ was unique. I remember all the beat groups around in England at the time with pop, rock and r&b, yet PJ managed to get massive hits with songs like this. Yes, he was one of a kind. What a music scene we had back then - nothing like it since.

Pretty good song. This is one of the songs Jack Higgins, the novelist, mentions in the 40-odd books he's written. He must like it - I do too.

@vandywilliam - We share a taste in this music, I see. Surely Ray Eberle and Glenn Miller were among the best combos in history. Personally, I think the best ever was Ray Noble and Al Bowlly a few years earlier, but I'll take Ray and Glenn any time after that!

@lewstone1934 - You must really be into the music of that era. Lew Stone was a bit earlier, but how good - esp with Al Bowlly. Nice comment here.

openflix - Thanks for uploading these classics. They don't make films like this anymore. Some might say just as well, but let them at least they have a plot, have no nudity, no filthy language, no ultra violence and over-the top sex.

@carlanthony62 - It seems to be 1936. Tim Mccoy was at the height of his powers then.

tvdays - Thanks for uploading - you've gone to a lot of trouble. Likely not many will look at these old films, but you've made one older person happy with a movie you can watch that has no objectionable content. Thanks again and best wishes...

Why didn't these two record more songs together? They were so good way back when and their version of this song is the definitiive one in my view.

Georgie was good, wasn't he? He probably is still good is he's playing now - what talent!

@kasbersky - Your life, it seems sir, has been sadly lacking in the finer things! Now that you've discovered Van the Man it will never be the same again!!

Nice song, thanks for uploading. Sorry to hear Oliver passed away too early.

@its4it Music certainly stirs the emotions if the remarks on this page are anything to go by. Can't we all just enjoy this beautiful folk music without the politics?

@DrLegume - All that out of a simple South American folk song. I must truly be a shallow thinker.

@calalilygirl - Thanks for your comments. Top songs are too few these days. In the 60s new super songs were an everyday event, that's why it was so special. Cheers!

Some pointless comments on this page over what? Can't we just enjoy the music without nationalistic remarks which enflame. The events which spawned this beautiful music are long past history now. It does no good to keep it going surely.

Sad tune this, but beautifully sung by the choir. How sad that we can make such glorious music, but are so incapable of making lasting peace.

Very moving - no doubt about Welsh singers they are special. This is a truly beautiful song and done justice by this choir.

I realise that my comments on this film won't be to everyone's taste, but I thought it was a load of rubbish!

Music's good though as all of Hans Zimmer's work appears to be, but the movie and Keira Knightly's performance was very forgettable - in my view.

@purga60 Yes, we can claim him now, but we all know he was born in England and strictly speaking is English. What a star Hank is!

@Nojnotpu - Well said. Not all beer and skittles back then, was it? Sad that, but in the main it seems people were more law-abiding and generally more interested in others than they are now. Racial bigotry is vile, so unjust and so baseless - all men are created equal as the American constitution...

I think Peter's version of Roses of Picardy is the best of them all on YT. Beautiful version of a sad WWI song. Picardy is the area basically covered by the Western Front. Unspeakable place 1914-1918.

Beautifully played by Artie and his band, but with respect to them, no one renders it like Nat King Cole.

Beautiful song, no doubt about it. What a wonderful voice this man had! Don't think anyone else can quite sing it like Nat King Cole. A classic.

Thank you, edmundsrex, for such a wealth of information about Bert Ambrose. What a bandleader! What great music came out of Britain in those days. We may never see their like again - we certainly haven't in the nearly 80 years since.

240252 - Great job of uploading this classic - thank you. What a team was Ambrose and Sam Browne. In my humble opinion only surpassed by Al Bowlly and Ray Noble - perhaps the best ever.

This is very clear much clearer than Al Bowlly's with the Harry Hudson Orchestra - far better quality. Even so, Al's vocals are still too good for anyone else to cut the mustard with this song. Bing Crosby's is good too.