Personally I think anyone who can sing such a demanding and dramatic role not just to the opera house they are performing live in, but for tv or to the world in the met broadcasts, is allowed a leeway. To have the personality to enjoy it and carry this off in a very demanding and critical world ...
Sutherland is singing Morgana's aria here. That is the part that Dessay plays in the DVD from Paris, while in the 1959 recording Sutherland is Alcina not Morgana. I think Sutherland and Dessay are both brilliant in their own ways. I don't know why we love to criticise these artists and put on...
Personally I think anyone who can sing such a demanding and dramatic role not just to the opera house they are performing live in, but for tv or to the world in the met broadcasts, is allowed a leeway. To have the personality to enjoy it and carry this off in a very demanding and critical world ...