She sounds alike Amy Lee. But this is different, musically talking, to the path that both bands have embraced. And if the singer was trying to imitate Amy, it's a total failure because she isn"t singing as well as Amy. And We are the fallen is more rock, less dark. And they don't have this dark energy that evanescence has. But they're very good!!!
Ben Moody, said that We Are the Fallen differs from Evanescence in that "everyone is equal" and that it has "more energy than Evanescence could ever muster."He also stated, "We cannot try to be who we are. If there is some similarity in sound, it's because that genre was created by us. !!! ;-)
I don't get this. When I turn off the sound, they all are appearing to be playing something real nasty...yet the sound itself is good enough only to put me to the sleep...weak and without juice (it's just MHO freaks)
never like "we are the fallen" when they was just doing "evanescence" covers but gotta admit not their doing their own thing im really starting to love the music
Youtube sucks ass, I can't even watch videos on here anymore. The layout is all jumbled up and it's much more complex then the previous design. (Btw I love this song)
omg u guys this girl cannot help how she looks or her voice so unless you are amy lee or can sing better than this chic then shut it because i love both evanesance and we are the fallen
Imagine being in a state like Juliet's (Romeo and Juliet), temporary death, but while you're in that state, people wish to bury you. And during the funeral you come back to life. But no one can hear you screaming, it's a closed coffin. It's a scary thought.
@TheElisaloo Why? Amy Lee would not only welcome this new artist, but probably wish to record a song with her! Amy Lee knows and recognizes and honors great singers and bands. Why are you so narrow-minded? I truly adore Amy Lee, yet have learned from her to give credit, where credit is due.
I hope Ben Moody realized what he'd left when he left Evanescence to create this clone. I mean look at Evanescence now, still having number one records across the world.
How did the original members of Evanescence become an Evanescence clone?? They would be SO GOOD if they didn't look and sound exactly like, well, Evanescence.
Obviously those who compare "We Are The Fallen" with "Evanescence" don't know a thing about pitches. There's a definite difference. Plus, you have such a problem with people sounding similar to Amy Lee? Then please, do us all a favor that appreciate music being music, go away and don't come back. Go listen to Evanescence and don't listen to We Are The Fallen: It's that simple.... Really.... =) Anyways.... "You bury me alive.... And everybody's gotta breathe...." <3
@LitianMarie Even when our singers will die...their music, their teachings, their concerts, their ways to see the world will live in our eyes and when i get old and i listen to My Immortal of Evanesncence and when i cried i'll say: thanks Amy lee to made me understand this life...thanks amy to show me how beautiful could be this life with the right person beside you...amy you will live forever in yours fan's eyes...i hope to meet you some day in other side...just...thanks....
@LitianMarie did you say all that for what i said ? if you didn't realize they are a copy of Evanescence (they are good, very good) look at the singer..she dresses like Amy Lee...they want to be like Evanescence..i like this song..it has got a good sound..i apreciate the good music and it's good music..maybe i'm wrong or maybe i'm right...but i'm sure about one thing: we listen the best music on earth..we listen ROCK i'm fan of Evanesncece but i'm more fan of the rock and the ROCK'LL LIVE 4 EVER
@LitianMarie I have to say this. Amy Lee has the most amazing voice that I have heard in years!!!! But, this artist has an amazing voice as well and this song really rocks and speaks to me, just like Amy Lees songs can speak to me. How can people compare them negatively? After all, both are the future of great female artists!!!! I don't know who had the stupidity to pit them against each other, when both are great and both lead us forward in musical creativity and emotion
Noo deben comparar este grupo con Evanescence,cada cual tiene su talento y son excelentes grupos los dos!! Yo disfruto de la musica de ambos! Exitooo We Are The Fallen!!!! =D y si no tienen nada bueno que desearle al grupo mejor no escriban nadaa y ahorrense los comentarios envidiosos
@TheJenn4Blue No comparemos algo que es igual? escuchaste alguna vez comparar a Slipknot con Korn, o a Kiss con Led Zeppelin?... o a los Beatles con Rolling Stones?... no? PORQUE NO SUENAN IGUALES (ESTOS SON EXTREMOS). Es mas... el guitarrista es el ex de Evanescence. No jodamos... autocrítica la puta madre. O por lo menos crítica. Carajo.
@Sele2punto0 Y si... aparentemente tenía (y tiene) una visión muy exacta de lo que debería ser SU banda. Bueno, bien por Moody que lo logró... pero, lamentablemente, las comparaciones van a ser inevitables. Saludos.
Carly Smithson é boa no vocal, mas não chega nem aos pés da Amy Lee.
Além disso Ben Moody, John Lecompt e Rocky Gray não valem NADA fora do Evanescence. Cometeram um grande erro saindo do Evanescence para entrar numa banda tão vulgar como essa.
Evanescence is sooooooooooo much better.... Ben Moody and the other guys are NOTHING without Amy Lee. And Carly has a low style, nothing too special. This is nothing compared to Evanescence. Simple. '-'
Amy Lee is a fraud....heard her live and she sucked!!!! Sucked bad....no where near close as Within Temptation, Leave's Eyes, The Gathering, Eyes of Eden, Tarja, etc. etc. etc.
Amy Lee is singled out because she is one of the few well-known gothic pop/rock mucisians, but if you look at other artists in any other genre, they all are very closely alike, and no one says anything because most of them are either male or so widespread that a generic formula in music has been accepted
This Amy Lee vs Carly feud has been ongoing for two years, haha, I remember when this song was released and it all started. Come on guys, it's a great song.
@MrNASCARracing We are the Fallen is a pick up where Evanescence's album "Fallen" left off. 3 of the members are from Evanescence thus the similar sounding music. They felt that they were heading in a bad direction with Evanescence so to preserve this genre of music they broke off and eventually made this band "We are the Fallen"
Ok, I see major differences between evanescence and this band...this is the first time I listened to this...I saw all of the gripe comments...but I see differences not similarities, what? other women other than amy lee can't dress like that? it is called a style, they share a style. so what? everybody just needs to chill, besides this song is slower than evanescence songs, it is more drawn out...it sounds good as well(not that evanescence doesn't)
Sorry, just too similar to not compare. Sure, the girl is beautiful and has a good voice, but the overall band's theme is just too Evanescence. I'm not picking on any individual. The way they're presenting themselves seems to just be a copy, instead of making it their own. The song itself in my opinion is pretty boring as well. But whatever. Just my opinion. But if you like it, then who am I to criticize your taste.
All of you so indignant about the Evanescence/Amy Lee comparisons should just calm down. The two bands do have a strikingly similar sound. Deal with it. That being said, just because they sound alike doesn't mean THIS band isn't good. I liked the song....still sounds an awful lot like Evanescence though. But since Evanescence has been successful, how is that a problem? Imitation IS the sincerest form of flattery they say. If you like 'em....great. keep listening. If you don't, great....move on.
If you think Carly sounds like Amy then you are delusional, watch the Cirque Des Damnes videos and you'll see just how different they are. You only think they sound alike because you're trying to find similarities between the two, only to put Carly down in the process. Carly is her own person, she is NOT Amy 2.0 - the sooner you realize that, the sooner we can all move on with this subject.
I wonder- her vocals are actually kind of buried in this mix beneath the instrumentals- is this to make the fact that she's trying to sound like Amy Lee less noticeable? I only ask because I did my research and listened to some of the other songs off this album and she doesn't always sound like this. Is it a coincidence?
this is what happened; "Evanescence" shared their talent in to two, put half of it in to "We are the Fallen" and then put the other half in to the new "Evanescence" that is why "We are the Fallen" is trying to be as good as "Evanescence" but can't meanwhile "Evanescence" still manages to be good enough but not the same like how it was before. Only if they can all come back together......
why the hell are there even comments about amy lee and evanescence?? They're different bands altogether now... you don't go to a nightwish video and say it would sound better if amy lee sang it, do you?? No, didn't think so.
I loved evanescence but it just gets on my nerves when people start to comment about them when it's irrelevant.
The band took an Amy Lee look alike who sings, dresses and they tried to replace Amy. But too bad Amy Lee can ROCK out all by herself. Her talent kicks but 100 times more than this chicks does
I think peolpe don't complain about her voice or something. It's just kind of embarresing that they dress her up EXACTLY like amy lee. It's the hair, the make up, she does the same moves like amy and everything. That's the point why everybody is complaining!
Wtf y ppl compare amy lee to this band like stfu ppl and enjoy the damn music these damn artists work their asses.off to make. Like rlly is there any mature ppl on youtube?
Does the reason ppl compare her to Amy Lee is b/c in the begging she really sounds like Amy Lee... Kinda have a same style but their still different people/artists
This video reminds me of a movie I saw recently. It's called 'After.Life' starring Christina Ricci... pretty damn good movie.. I reccomend checking it out.
@monika92br yeah she could have been better if she wasn't imitating someone else.
her voice, the music video, the theme, those three men from evanescence, everything -- it makes me wanna feel bored by the end of the video and look out for more songs from amy lee. carly smithson is still under her shadow.
I comment my opinion: This video is AWESOME! But the singer kinda kills it :/ I mean if it was Amy Lee, then this might have been a lot more popular...
ppl, i have one question for you...do you like the song?
if so...why compare it to anyone else's?i mean, come one...everyone has its own style of singing, shes not like amy lee because shes not amy lee.
why waste time commenting tht you dont like her singing cuz she doesnt sound like someone else? its not even relevant to the song you're commenting on -.-
Seriously, I wish people would stop BITCHING about how Carly is just a wannabe Amy Lee, how Annette is a wannabe Tarja and etc, and it's annoying. I wish that people would grow up and accept that although We are the Fallen and Evanescence have similar sounding music, it does not mean one is better than the other, I like them both equally :)
@BlackandWhiteDragons i would say the same but if u look at her American idol audition, or even later in the season, her natural voice is wayy different... now she has most of the old evanescence band members and u can tell she tries to sound like amy with her voice... same with the look. and even with the genre with the music...
@imyourfreak Well, I don't watch American Idol 'cause I'm not American and I don't live there PLUS I have no interest in following it online, so I'm only going on what I know.
I can see she might be influenced by amy lee, but she is an individual and has a different style. subtle, but different. enjoy the music and leave out all the rest, yes?
. It is still the common temptation of our modern age. Rather than submit to God men attempt to set themselves up to be their own god.This is the same reason why adam and eve fell out of favour with god. They were tempted by the prospect of being like god. Just like satan.It was the original sin caused by free will. Because of this sin everybody else is now paying the price for sin
Meh, pretty decent, don't compare them to evanescence though, evanescence is better.
Fergieh8er12 2 hours ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you cant compare The Greatest EV with "this one"
NymphOfHeaven 4 hours ago
I like them both amy is talented and so is carly is to but once an evanescence fan always an evanescence fan :}
xXhannahXbearXx 4 hours ago
PAPARIA MANTOLES :)
AMYADDICTED 7 hours ago
@AMYADDICTED What do you mean?? what language is that???
FanOfUlrich 7 hours ago
@FanOfUlrich NADIAS GREEK MY FRIEND DURIM <3
AMYADDICTED 7 hours ago
@AMYADDICTED MWREEE KOUKLAROS MWREEEE!!! BY THE WAYY KANAS PLIKTRAS AN ENDIAFERETAI NA KLIKAREI EDW!!!
FanOfUlrich 7 hours ago
She sounds alike Amy Lee. But this is different, musically talking, to the path that both bands have embraced. And if the singer was trying to imitate Amy, it's a total failure because she isn"t singing as well as Amy. And We are the fallen is more rock, less dark. And they don't have this dark energy that evanescence has. But they're very good!!!
olivermanton 10 hours ago
Sounds abit like Evanescence, but they r still rly good ^^.
Rawrz4799 11 hours ago
I love those outfits!!!
pixy2k2 12 hours ago
Ben Moody, said that We Are the Fallen differs from Evanescence in that "everyone is equal" and that it has "more energy than Evanescence could ever muster."He also stated, "We cannot try to be who we are. If there is some similarity in sound, it's because that genre was created by us. !!! ;-)
Bogdanovici24 16 hours ago
A rip off from Evanenance!!!!! Evanenance 1000% better, love Amy lee and Evanenance and the new album rocks!!!!!! :)
DruidDarkwitch 16 hours ago
I don't get this. When I turn off the sound, they all are appearing to be playing something real nasty...yet the sound itself is good enough only to put me to the sleep...weak and without juice (it's just MHO freaks)
DireEagle 22 hours ago
ya she looks like amy lee ya they do pitches like her but its still different
epictacoqueen 1 day ago
never like "we are the fallen" when they was just doing "evanescence" covers but gotta admit not their doing their own thing im really starting to love the music
thomasA5g36 1 day ago
jajaja sierto la chica tiene el mismo estilo de amy lee pero amy es mejor jajaja no es verdad las dos son muy buenas las amoooo!!
dryxiify 1 day ago
They are awesome! Shut up, haters!
VelkokralovnaBylanta 1 day ago
Youtube sucks ass, I can't even watch videos on here anymore. The layout is all jumbled up and it's much more complex then the previous design. (Btw I love this song)
Shardzy 1 day ago
I like both bands so it doesn't matter to me. I especially love this song.
o0MissyNichole0o 1 day ago
she did all that just to kill the darker side of her?
...damn shes got patience
nats7004 2 days ago in playlist Good Songz
I like the chorus in this song !
mmentalbeat 2 days ago
amy lee is more better
BimbaBellaxD 2 days ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
why we are in this life?? and Where are we going after it?? there are alot of answers!! but...
there is only one correct answer , and it's here
(youtube.com/watch?v=z-W_NfyAP3Q)
if it doesn.t work write this link in youtube search and you will find the video
thank you
THUNDERXLIGHT1 2 days ago
omg u guys this girl cannot help how she looks or her voice so unless you are amy lee or can sing better than this chic then shut it because i love both evanesance and we are the fallen
animeangel26forever 2 days ago
Imagine being in a state like Juliet's (Romeo and Juliet), temporary death, but while you're in that state, people wish to bury you. And during the funeral you come back to life. But no one can hear you screaming, it's a closed coffin. It's a scary thought.
TeenSpirit195 2 days ago
There will never be another Evanescence. EVER.
TheElisaloo 3 days ago 14
@TheElisaloo Why? Amy Lee would not only welcome this new artist, but probably wish to record a song with her! Amy Lee knows and recognizes and honors great singers and bands. Why are you so narrow-minded? I truly adore Amy Lee, yet have learned from her to give credit, where credit is due.
ForlornSuicide 1 hour ago
this song is awsome
brianamichael1 3 days ago
i love this song and this band, they are simply amazing. the message is so relevant to everyone that it is awe inspiring.
rosarayne 3 days ago in playlist dark 2
you bury me alive!! :/
GAB37307 3 days ago
ahahahaha. this is like the a terrible evanescence with an even worse lead singer trying to be amy lee. it's just funny. :')
CortniCoversSongs 3 days ago
If Amy Lee actually had a good voice live, it would be this band.
Pr3ttyToy 3 days ago
the singering is not that good
kingmoe493 3 days ago
I hope Ben Moody realized what he'd left when he left Evanescence to create this clone. I mean look at Evanescence now, still having number one records across the world.
joegibzz500 3 days ago
the both of them are great
mennatarek2468 3 days ago
she sometimes looks like amy!
MsPshyco 3 days ago
Comment removed
MsPshyco 3 days ago
Stop Kony 2012!!!!
Babyloser19 3 days ago
OH MARGOT!! i didn't know of this band! This is Evanescence without Amy. What a fake! they are really the fallen....
It's not a bad song anyway...
morganabve 3 days ago
Still can't compare to Amy Lee.
unknown13690 3 days ago 3
She looks like Amy! gossh!
Patolober 3 days ago
Amy Lee has more range and depth. This woman sounds very little like Amy Lee if you pay attention. This woman's voice is more masculine.
CaitlynB2010 3 days ago
crap.
1236547899874563211 4 days ago
Both bands are great.
Now stfu and enjoy the music.
yellow224 4 days ago
She looks like a Amy Lee wanna be ._.
MyWerewolflover14 4 days ago
How did the original members of Evanescence become an Evanescence clone?? They would be SO GOOD if they didn't look and sound exactly like, well, Evanescence.
jessiemetalbitch 4 days ago
the new evanescence album blows this shit out the fucking water
link000000 4 days ago
womp
playahater32 4 days ago
I like this video
tuny1209 4 days ago
Ué? A formação antiga do Evanescence monta uma banda e colocam uma mulher que parece e soa como a Amy Lee. Vai entender...
JessicaBoueres 4 days ago
Wait. Is this Evanescence without Amy? That's why they named themselves "We Are The Fallen"... Oh dear...
theamvgirlx 4 days ago
...I like her voice better than Amy's...sorry guys but I like a lower pitch in girl leads.
theamvgirlx 4 days ago
Evanescence...
Lizz7544 4 days ago
Obviously those who compare "We Are The Fallen" with "Evanescence" don't know a thing about pitches. There's a definite difference. Plus, you have such a problem with people sounding similar to Amy Lee? Then please, do us all a favor that appreciate music being music, go away and don't come back. Go listen to Evanescence and don't listen to We Are The Fallen: It's that simple.... Really.... =) Anyways.... "You bury me alive.... And everybody's gotta breathe...." <3
LitianMarie 4 days ago 29
Comment removed
ignacio3103 2 days ago
@LitianMarie Even when our singers will die...their music, their teachings, their concerts, their ways to see the world will live in our eyes and when i get old and i listen to My Immortal of Evanesncence and when i cried i'll say: thanks Amy lee to made me understand this life...thanks amy to show me how beautiful could be this life with the right person beside you...amy you will live forever in yours fan's eyes...i hope to meet you some day in other side...just...thanks....
ignacio3103 2 days ago
Comment removed
ignacio3103 2 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@LitianMarie did you say all that for what i said ? if you didn't realize they are a copy of Evanescence (they are good, very good) look at the singer..she dresses like Amy Lee...they want to be like Evanescence..i like this song..it has got a good sound..i apreciate the good music and it's good music..maybe i'm wrong or maybe i'm right...but i'm sure about one thing: we listen the best music on earth..we listen ROCK i'm fan of Evanesncece but i'm more fan of the rock and the ROCK'LL LIVE 4 EVER
ignacio3103 2 days ago
@LitianMarie I have to say this. Amy Lee has the most amazing voice that I have heard in years!!!! But, this artist has an amazing voice as well and this song really rocks and speaks to me, just like Amy Lees songs can speak to me. How can people compare them negatively? After all, both are the future of great female artists!!!! I don't know who had the stupidity to pit them against each other, when both are great and both lead us forward in musical creativity and emotion
ForlornSuicide 1 hour ago
why do u have to compare them with the evanescence . ?
armidervi 4 days ago
wueon pero si apenas puse este tema dije o.o ´´EVANESCENCE`` no es mi culpa que la mina cante igual sorry
e.e la mina es linda y tienen buenas guitarras pero aun asi e.e es mierdaaa...
Dreamsthrash19 5 days ago
Noo deben comparar este grupo con Evanescence,cada cual tiene su talento y son excelentes grupos los dos!! Yo disfruto de la musica de ambos! Exitooo We Are The Fallen!!!! =D y si no tienen nada bueno que desearle al grupo mejor no escriban nadaa y ahorrense los comentarios envidiosos
TheJenn4Blue 5 days ago
@TheJenn4Blue No comparemos algo que es igual? escuchaste alguna vez comparar a Slipknot con Korn, o a Kiss con Led Zeppelin?... o a los Beatles con Rolling Stones?... no? PORQUE NO SUENAN IGUALES (ESTOS SON EXTREMOS). Es mas... el guitarrista es el ex de Evanescence. No jodamos... autocrítica la puta madre. O por lo menos crítica. Carajo.
PinataAnarquista 5 days ago
@PinataAnarquista pues lee tu comentario y ahí sabrás por que tienen LA ESENCIA ;)
Sele2punto0 4 days ago
@Sele2punto0 Y si... aparentemente tenía (y tiene) una visión muy exacta de lo que debería ser SU banda. Bueno, bien por Moody que lo logró... pero, lamentablemente, las comparaciones van a ser inevitables. Saludos.
PinataAnarquista 4 days ago
Nao e' a mesma coisa..como antes...ela nao chega nem aos pes.da amy...sinto mto.mas esolheram errado...
LEHHize 5 days ago
Anyway... Evanescence fell down, they're nothing without Amy Lee and so Nightwish without Tarja... Within Temptation and Lacuna Coil rules!!!!
Sadeeka8788 5 days ago
Comment removed
Fahzioan 5 days ago
@Fahzioan I'm sorry, do you have a dick in your mouth? Because I believe what you tried to say came out wrong babe. Amy Lee is first? I think so.
SuperRaeMe 5 days ago
a banda e boa...o Ben Moody quis fazer dessa mulher uma especie de Amy lee,mas nao conseguiu..desculpa Ben ,mas Amy Lee so tem uma.
2012eduh 5 days ago
Eles nunca serão o Evanescence. Fato '-'
Carly Smithson é boa no vocal, mas não chega nem aos pés da Amy Lee.
Além disso Ben Moody, John Lecompt e Rocky Gray não valem NADA fora do Evanescence. Cometeram um grande erro saindo do Evanescence para entrar numa banda tão vulgar como essa.
HellMaster006 5 days ago
Evanescence is sooooooooooo much better.... Ben Moody and the other guys are NOTHING without Amy Lee. And Carly has a low style, nothing too special. This is nothing compared to Evanescence. Simple. '-'
HellMaster006 5 days ago
Amy Lee is a fraud....heard her live and she sucked!!!! Sucked bad....no where near close as Within Temptation, Leave's Eyes, The Gathering, Eyes of Eden, Tarja, etc. etc. etc.
NigelFang77 5 days ago
@NigelFang77 But then again, it's obvious, out of Within Temptation and Evanescence which one is better, I mean, you can't even compare them...
theamvgirlx 4 days ago
Evanescence need we are the fallen, we are the fallen need Amy lee
EnDyReader 6 days ago
the veil reminds me of "The Ministers Black Veil" Its a short story not a song
siriobiwan 6 days ago
well its okay, but i kind like wt better.
Ikibrii 6 days ago
Because they do not bury her?
Fuck Carly!!
FaN1BEP 6 days ago
Alone sound a cheap copy of Evanescence they were never compared to them in spite of it ex-of the group
FaN1BEP 6 days ago
Amy Lee is singled out because she is one of the few well-known gothic pop/rock mucisians, but if you look at other artists in any other genre, they all are very closely alike, and no one says anything because most of them are either male or so widespread that a generic formula in music has been accepted
lilsweetmami18 6 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
they are not bad but evanescence is way better...
ignacio3103 6 days ago 67
ehhh amy lee is WAY BETTER!!!! :)
jessierami21994 6 days ago 2
Traders and Fakes, Amy Lee she is not! Copy cats are lame.......
bobgreen77 6 days ago
La cara de piedra de terry & john y ni te digo de el explotadr de Ben , Garcas totales. #ListoLoDije
pRInCeZzitah13 6 days ago
FAIL!
pRInCeZzitah13 6 days ago
Its awesome but it could have been better if Amy was still there
MoiDixMoisGuy 6 days ago
First time listening to them :)
I love!
lordhappybuny13 6 days ago
Tryhards.
95vbb 6 days ago
Thumbs up if you want this band to play at your funeral
TeenEmo13 6 days ago in playlist My Favourite Emo Rocking Tunes
does she have an accent...? when she says "sorrow" it kinda sounds like she might but i can't tell..
fifilafi321 6 days ago
@fifilafi321 Yes, she does actually. She's got an Irish accent.
FashionZombies27 6 days ago
@FashionZombies27 I thought it was something! Thanks (:
fifilafi321 5 days ago
its sad to hear ben moody fought with amy.
ZdnXXX 1 week ago
@ZdnXXX sad to hear amy lee kicked everyone out of evanescence :/
gerbils4 1 week ago
lol i love the dudes trying to act hard while being lied by a chick
shnoogums1 1 week ago
carly looks like my socials teacher.... weird
WalkingDeadGirll 1 week ago in playlist Amazing!!!
Now we know who did the many great songs in the Old Evanescence... ;)
hnrqfernandes 1 week ago
woahhh Carly almost looks and sounds like Amy Lee that's sooo awesome!!! XD :D
vampireemomistress16 1 week ago
i thought the chick was amy lee and i was all what she changed the band then i was all oh nope thats not her aha
TheCheyannebrown 1 week ago
Dear lord it never occurred to me she would look so similar to Amy Lee. Almost scary. Great song though.
mnikolajuk2 1 week ago 2
This Amy Lee vs Carly feud has been ongoing for two years, haha, I remember when this song was released and it all started. Come on guys, it's a great song.
AdrianLeeKellett 1 week ago
is it just me or... John LeCompt just got hotter?
rockerofrustrao 1 week ago
Why all of the things I like have to be subject of comparisons? evanescence/WATF....the hunger games/battle royale.....hahahaa it´s anoying! :p
Anyway I spose I like the things that create controversy! haha
ephimer 1 week ago
Stfu, just be glad there's someone out there as hot as Amy to drool over, 'cause I am.
RuikeiWolf 1 week ago
I hate cover bands....
Evanescence Part II ????
rafaelpadulla 1 week ago
Woah! I just felt... anxious about being buried alive while I was watching this video... SO intense..
Txesare 1 week ago
Amy Lee Ripoff...... Be Original!!!
MrNASCARracing 1 week ago
@MrNASCARracing We are the Fallen is a pick up where Evanescence's album "Fallen" left off. 3 of the members are from Evanescence thus the similar sounding music. They felt that they were heading in a bad direction with Evanescence so to preserve this genre of music they broke off and eventually made this band "We are the Fallen"
ri8002 1 week ago 3
She sounds more like Amy Lee than Amy Lee
VexatiousByBlood 1 week ago 35
@VexatiousByBlood :O WHAT? NONSENSE -.-
pano0lis1990 4 days ago
She can be who she wants, just because she has a similar style does not mean she copies. Can Carly not do what she loves without being criticised?
BethMerry1995 1 week ago 3
LOL. Evanescence= Bring Me To Life, WATF= Bury Me Alive. XD
shestupefies 1 week ago
a q la cantante es fanatica de amy lee jajajja XD
lordcorvus777 1 week ago
Ok, I see major differences between evanescence and this band...this is the first time I listened to this...I saw all of the gripe comments...but I see differences not similarities, what? other women other than amy lee can't dress like that? it is called a style, they share a style. so what? everybody just needs to chill, besides this song is slower than evanescence songs, it is more drawn out...it sounds good as well(not that evanescence doesn't)
kelseynsuggs 1 week ago 4
Sorry, just too similar to not compare. Sure, the girl is beautiful and has a good voice, but the overall band's theme is just too Evanescence. I'm not picking on any individual. The way they're presenting themselves seems to just be a copy, instead of making it their own. The song itself in my opinion is pretty boring as well. But whatever. Just my opinion. But if you like it, then who am I to criticize your taste.
deficitsense08 1 week ago
Good rock band! forget the douche bag comparisons
KevinBurris3 1 week ago
I love it! great song, great video
KevinBurris3 1 week ago
on another note.. Her dress is pretty
fifilafi321 1 week ago 2
All of you so indignant about the Evanescence/Amy Lee comparisons should just calm down. The two bands do have a strikingly similar sound. Deal with it. That being said, just because they sound alike doesn't mean THIS band isn't good. I liked the song....still sounds an awful lot like Evanescence though. But since Evanescence has been successful, how is that a problem? Imitation IS the sincerest form of flattery they say. If you like 'em....great. keep listening. If you don't, great....move on.
dubbledprincess 1 week ago
Comment removed
The25Sister 1 week ago
Can't knock it, it's a great song.Shades of early Paradise Lost.
tonywildchid 1 week ago
Evenescence Part 2?
contreritasgrupo 1 week ago 2
If you think Carly sounds like Amy then you are delusional, watch the Cirque Des Damnes videos and you'll see just how different they are. You only think they sound alike because you're trying to find similarities between the two, only to put Carly down in the process. Carly is her own person, she is NOT Amy 2.0 - the sooner you realize that, the sooner we can all move on with this subject.
AmysEvArmy 1 week ago 2
I wonder- her vocals are actually kind of buried in this mix beneath the instrumentals- is this to make the fact that she's trying to sound like Amy Lee less noticeable? I only ask because I did my research and listened to some of the other songs off this album and she doesn't always sound like this. Is it a coincidence?
audioengineer1624 1 week ago
cheap copy of evanescence....... meh
MyTunes991 1 week ago 5
this is what happened; "Evanescence" shared their talent in to two, put half of it in to "We are the Fallen" and then put the other half in to the new "Evanescence" that is why "We are the Fallen" is trying to be as good as "Evanescence" but can't meanwhile "Evanescence" still manages to be good enough but not the same like how it was before. Only if they can all come back together......
vodka4199 1 week ago
anyone who even think We are the fallen are not good enough
well i say " Mister Go And SELL YOUR EARS !!!! Cause You Have No Need For Them "
MsDarkshades 1 week ago
freaks me out because she looks freakishly similar to my Manager...
fifilafi321 1 week ago
why the hell are there even comments about amy lee and evanescence?? They're different bands altogether now... you don't go to a nightwish video and say it would sound better if amy lee sang it, do you?? No, didn't think so.
I loved evanescence but it just gets on my nerves when people start to comment about them when it's irrelevant.
souleaterhana 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Here is a great song for you
watch?v=kEe260z453k
AdrienneNowak 1 week ago 10
AMY LEE AND EVANESCENCE FOREVER!!! XD
henj38 1 week ago 2
Obviolsly ... She's trying to be Amy Lee... But..no way
rafaelpadulla 1 week ago
The band took an Amy Lee look alike who sings, dresses and they tried to replace Amy. But too bad Amy Lee can ROCK out all by herself. Her talent kicks but 100 times more than this chicks does
sfphotodesigns 1 week ago
I think peolpe don't complain about her voice or something. It's just kind of embarresing that they dress her up EXACTLY like amy lee. It's the hair, the make up, she does the same moves like amy and everything. That's the point why everybody is complaining!
xXxEndlessxDarkxXx 1 week ago 3
I LOVE THIS SONG!!!! WHO GIVES A FUCKING FLYING FUCK WHAT THEY THINK, SHIT!! IM HERE FOR THE MUSICCC!! NO COMPARING PPLE TO ANYTHING :D
JetStar9115 1 week ago
"Mommy, I Wanna be Amy Lee"
MahBiafra 1 week ago 42
@MahBiafra
Ohh its easy, she just needs eat a lot of big macs and put a chicken egg in your mouth while she is singing and she will be like Amy...
Sry Amy for that ;)
hnrqfernandes 1 week ago
WOW - THAT SUCKS! WHAT A FUCKING JOKE!
LizDickey08 1 week ago
Wtf y ppl compare amy lee to this band like stfu ppl and enjoy the damn music these damn artists work their asses.off to make. Like rlly is there any mature ppl on youtube?
skaterpunkrulezz 1 week ago
Does the reason ppl compare her to Amy Lee is b/c in the begging she really sounds like Amy Lee... Kinda have a same style but their still different people/artists
SylvverInWonderland 1 week ago
This video reminds me of a movie I saw recently. It's called 'After.Life' starring Christina Ricci... pretty damn good movie.. I reccomend checking it out.
lDyles 1 week ago
can someone tell me why is carly with former evanescence members?...no wonder this group looks like an evanescence wannabe...
theenigmaboy123 1 week ago 3
@WeAreTheAftermath i bet she started dressing like that WHEN she went on idol...to seem like she always dressed like that...
theenigmaboy123 1 week ago
@PRAX808 agreed
theenigmaboy123 1 week ago
WTH? A WANNABE AMY LEE???
theenigmaboy123 1 week ago
This Is Sooooo Fuckin Cool! <3
TheCher777 1 week ago
wow i like this
tamusiaa1 1 week ago
this girl is better
monika92br 1 week ago
@monika92br yeah she could have been better if she wasn't imitating someone else.
her voice, the music video, the theme, those three men from evanescence, everything -- it makes me wanna feel bored by the end of the video and look out for more songs from amy lee. carly smithson is still under her shadow.
Quaidddable 1 week ago
amy lee and this chick and this band, as evaneshit, fuck!
is the same shit. period
aldoalberto 1 week ago
I comment my opinion: This video is AWESOME! But the singer kinda kills it :/ I mean if it was Amy Lee, then this might have been a lot more popular...
Baby7Lucky 1 week ago
I hate Carly but somehow I LUV the song and video :)
APoorTalentedGirl 1 week ago
almost she can sing =/
AnonymousxMind 1 week ago
Thumbs up for the windowed casket!
will75110 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos
This has been flagged as spam show
ppl, i have one question for you...do you like the song?
if so...why compare it to anyone else's?i mean, come one...everyone has its own style of singing, shes not like amy lee because shes not amy lee.
why waste time commenting tht you dont like her singing cuz she doesnt sound like someone else? its not even relevant to the song you're commenting on -.-
seriousman006 1 week ago 53
Seriously, I wish people would stop BITCHING about how Carly is just a wannabe Amy Lee, how Annette is a wannabe Tarja and etc, and it's annoying. I wish that people would grow up and accept that although We are the Fallen and Evanescence have similar sounding music, it does not mean one is better than the other, I like them both equally :)
BlackandWhiteDragons 1 week ago 36
@BlackandWhiteDragons I agree she could never be Amy! But she is good!
will75110 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos
@BlackandWhiteDragons i would say the same but if u look at her American idol audition, or even later in the season, her natural voice is wayy different... now she has most of the old evanescence band members and u can tell she tries to sound like amy with her voice... same with the look. and even with the genre with the music...
imyourfreak 1 week ago
@imyourfreak Well, I don't watch American Idol 'cause I'm not American and I don't live there PLUS I have no interest in following it online, so I'm only going on what I know.
BlackandWhiteDragons 1 week ago
@imyourfreak She tries to much, you can hear it in her throat ... I observe voices, idk. o-o
Queen0Winter 1 week ago
I think someone should post an amy lee video in response to this.
HakimaDarkCobra 1 week ago
I can see she might be influenced by amy lee, but she is an individual and has a different style. subtle, but different. enjoy the music and leave out all the rest, yes?
TheDevimangel 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos 5
That is not Amy Lee. One way you can tell, Amy Lee's way better
AdThe27th 1 week ago 4
evenescence was obviously a major influence on this band
CassieBobby 1 week ago
liked the song (:
JoAxilier 1 week ago
This is NOT Evanescence.
FlyingWinegum 1 week ago
Amy lee is still better
MoiDixMoisGuy 1 week ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
YOU ARE NOT A GOD
. It is still the common temptation of our modern age. Rather than submit to God men attempt to set themselves up to be their own god.This is the same reason why adam and eve fell out of favour with god. They were tempted by the prospect of being like god. Just like satan.It was the original sin caused by free will. Because of this sin everybody else is now paying the price for sin
MrTrott2hot 1 week ago
are you guys retarded? THAT IS AMY LEE. LITERALLY.
DominikaKAP 2 weeks ago
@DominikaKAP I dunno what the fuck you've been smokin', but you sir are wrong.
MISANTHROPY647 2 weeks ago 2
@MISANTHROPY647 trololol
JANNAxRAWR 1 week ago