a rational man would say that everyone is entitled to an opinion, and taste in arts such as music is completely subjective. unfortunately i am not a rational man, so i tell the bastard who disliked this to shove his fiddle up himself. if he even plays one.
@100nemesis100 yes zino plays well too, and a video of menuhin would be great. i just hate how people backhandedly dismiss certain interpretations as inferior and not worth listening to( @DrMontague). the fact that someone can actually play such a show piece is absolutely remarkable, and as a violinist i admire them.
this is difeent from Perlman.More scratchy tone but very very musical.I can't believe all the jewish virtuoso who didn't escape Hitler can u believe it the hebrews are tops in everything except sports.My black bros beat everone there. I wish we had more than Andre Watts and a few women time forgot.
My father studied this at The Paris Conservatory--all the advanced students had to master it--Neveu, Menuhin, Ciompi, Szeryng. My father had devised a fake fingering for the 4 repeated note figure where the player repeats the same pitch on all 4 strings--1:56 on. He taught everyone to play the D string twice and slyly cover the G with one's hand position so it "seemed" as if it were being played.
Consequently they all played it perfectly and the professors were all shocked and confused!
this is the first i've heard of this recording - amazing bow technique. it might be my favorite recording of this - i Do like Perlman's recording too, though. when Menuhin got older his bowing was imprecise. he loved music but he cared more about Living - which isn't a bad thing - after all the pressure and attention on his playing that he endured as a child..
Menuhin was magic and beautiful to look at as a young man.He was always clever .Did he try to do to much or did he lose some of the fire.This is electric and exciting because he pushes himself to the utmost.Deadly spiccato! Longevity is difficult even with a advertising machine behind you!
@nzmft85 from what i understand, when Menuhin was in his 30's or 40's, he spent a while trying to completely re-analyze and re-structure his technique and musicality, and it screwed him over
@nzmft85 Three reasons ( that i know of) Firstly, his early studies were quite unstructured, which meant that later in life he had to apply himself and 're-learn' the techniques needed.
Secondly, He suffered a lack of confidence due to the negative comparisons to Heifetz that some of the press were making.( Menuhin talks about this in one of his books) Thirdly he suffered from an ( undiagnosed i think) shaking disease.Late in life you could see him shaking visibly. Still my favourite :)
Although i myself prefer Heifetz i have to admit that iv yet to hear a better version of this being played by Menuhin. Sure Perlman is de best today he still never managed to get the sound off the fiddle that Heifetz and Menuhin got off there fiddles
Wow ! - I listened extensively to all renditions of this some time ago, before this was uploaded, but this knocks spots off them all for pure brilliance. He doesn't quite achieve Franscescatti's gorgeous lyricism though. I think people tend to neglect the fact that Menuhin's left hand was, IMO, as good if not better than anyone else's, perhaps because he often played things too fast and because other aspects of his playing let him down.
Menuhin is my favorite of all violinists. His control and precision were unmatched and yet his pure-spirited musicality, especially in later years, simply soared. His talent was matched with the best of instruments, a Guarnerius, I believe, with a tone as pure as any I have heard. One of my favorite recordings is his Bach sonatas and partitas in stereo, which I have on LP and cannot find on CD or elsewhere. His Beethoven concerto recording with Furtwängler is also the best I've heard.
You're right cjh37878--only a precious few years for Ginette Neveu who died at 30 in a plane crash. This must be, I think, a very early recording of Menuhin. Do you know the date noprodigyboy? I'm thinking maybe he's 16?? The pianist??
Great, freewheeling, endearing playing by the boy wonder!
This piece was learned by all the advanced students of Jules Boucherit at The Paris Conservatory. Menuhin, Neveu, Ciompi & Bobesco all played it as encores for many years thereafter.
what d u mean by post-recording? maybe u like him, i dunno, if so i like him too. but the problem is that he just made the same mistake, tried to play fast and ruined the originality of this masterpiece while trying to show how fast his fingers are. in terms of rthym, perlman plays it better than any other players
Recording technology changed the way artists played. In the same way that the invention of the camera changed the way painters painted. Yes, I love his playing too.
Yes, but of the 3, Menuhin was the greatest at fast stuff, Perlman was all-around (not surpassing the others in their specialties), and Heifetz was vibrato and left hand pizzicato.
Perlman had discussed this recording in the 'Art of Violin' documentary, and I'd been looking for it ever since. Thank you so very much for this upload!
excellent recording, i love how he maintains a high tempo in combination with a clear and precise tonality, something that vengerov and perlman lack especially with this piece, if you honestly think they are good compare it with this, they play it too fast and yet can't manage their trills properly as Menuhin can
@lawlaw122 this is a fantastic recording. i fully agree with everything u said about it. but i also LOVE Perlman's version. don't u like it as well? for me thats definitely one of the best performances of this piece.
@lawlaw122 Personally In think they all play this piece too fast. It always sound as they are playing twenty to the dozen. If the tempo had have been just a touch slower then this would for me have been a perfect interpretation. Mind you with the free VLC player you can now actually slow the music down and not lose the pitch.
Look at all the people who have flagged your comments as spam and voted you down,
You have complained about people voting you down…..
Yet “YOU” block people from commenting as soon as you don’t like what they are saying when pointing out your wrongs, and you then “Nah Nah Nah Nah” and block your ears by tapping the block user button.
There is a God and our God is “Good”
He is not evil , The evil one here is “YOU” Bad doctor.
This was the heavy metal of the age. At least it had the same intensity.
cetnikz 4 months ago 2
his trills sound almost like the strings of a guitar... so beautiful!
NONAROSSA 6 months ago
D. Garret starts playing the same part at minute 2:24 while Pearlman starts it at 2:19 and Yehudi at 2:14.
NONAROSSA 6 months ago 2
THAT'S THE BEST RECORDING NOBODY ELSE CAN SING LIKE THIS ESPECIALLY AT 0:32
MultiBono2010 8 months ago
bravooooooooooo
1995areg 11 months ago
Alright, who's the idiot who accidentally hit the dislike button!?
squareff255 11 months ago 3
a rational man would say that everyone is entitled to an opinion, and taste in arts such as music is completely subjective. unfortunately i am not a rational man, so i tell the bastard who disliked this to shove his fiddle up himself. if he even plays one.
ahpedrami 11 months ago 4
@ahpedrami Well said! and I do run the risk of playing the violin.Such a shame there is no video of Yehudi like the one of Zino.
100nemesis100 11 months ago
@100nemesis100 yes zino plays well too, and a video of menuhin would be great. i just hate how people backhandedly dismiss certain interpretations as inferior and not worth listening to( @DrMontague). the fact that someone can actually play such a show piece is absolutely remarkable, and as a violinist i admire them.
ahpedrami 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Holy mind-fuck!!!
Shaojian 1 year ago
Holy head-fuck!!!
Shaojian 1 year ago
lol 127 likes, 0 dislikes! Unbeatable
logodaedally 1 year ago
the TENTHS WERE PERFECT!!! just like mine!!! hahaha
saintmichael104 1 year ago
At his best, no one greater!!
mrwasbesonders 1 year ago
Amazing.
cetnikz 1 year ago
What a beast
MrLindenson 1 year ago
Perlman himself said there was nobody better in this piece.
MrUggamugga 1 year ago
lovely
8hotchocolate8 1 year ago
this is difeent from Perlman.More scratchy tone but very very musical.I can't believe all the jewish virtuoso who didn't escape Hitler can u believe it the hebrews are tops in everything except sports.My black bros beat everone there. I wish we had more than Andre Watts and a few women time forgot.
lovesGenet 1 year ago
@lovesGenet ...your bros rock...Wynton Marsalis...Art Tatum...Duke Ellington...etc...
politicopol 1 year ago
My father studied this at The Paris Conservatory--all the advanced students had to master it--Neveu, Menuhin, Ciompi, Szeryng. My father had devised a fake fingering for the 4 repeated note figure where the player repeats the same pitch on all 4 strings--1:56 on. He taught everyone to play the D string twice and slyly cover the G with one's hand position so it "seemed" as if it were being played.
Consequently they all played it perfectly and the professors were all shocked and confused!
maxreger100 1 year ago 10
Doesn't Perlman play on the same violin as Menhuin did?
harino45 1 year ago
@harino45 yes sometimes, when it's the "Soil" Stradivari.
MrUggamugga 1 year ago
2'17 second to nobody !!
Rephrat 1 year ago
noprodigyboy I would really appreciate a recording date for this and Menuhin's Hora Staccato which you also posted!
Love this rendition!The best performance of Bazzini ever recorded!
Amazing was the young Menuhin!
HeifetzRanew 1 year ago
@HeifetzRanew
Hello, Please listen to my upload of this piece with Menuhin too, the Sound is much more better
Mozart99900 1 year ago
this is the first i've heard of this recording - amazing bow technique. it might be my favorite recording of this - i Do like Perlman's recording too, though. when Menuhin got older his bowing was imprecise. he loved music but he cared more about Living - which isn't a bad thing - after all the pressure and attention on his playing that he endured as a child..
zhaydhee 1 year ago
Menuhin was magic and beautiful to look at as a young man.He was always clever .Did he try to do to much or did he lose some of the fire.This is electric and exciting because he pushes himself to the utmost.Deadly spiccato! Longevity is difficult even with a advertising machine behind you!
lovesGenet 1 year ago
The best thing about this is that he seems to be having so much fun. What a wonder--what a talent. Unsurpassed in my opinion.
As flawless as it is possible to play this fiendishly difficult piece--and what a tempo.
Makes me smile every time I come back to it.
ipmoic 1 year ago 2
@ipmoic what did his playing degenerate so dramatically?
nzmft85 1 year ago
@nzmft85 from what i understand, when Menuhin was in his 30's or 40's, he spent a while trying to completely re-analyze and re-structure his technique and musicality, and it screwed him over
NoStringsAttached08 1 year ago
@nzmft85 Three reasons ( that i know of) Firstly, his early studies were quite unstructured, which meant that later in life he had to apply himself and 're-learn' the techniques needed.
Secondly, He suffered a lack of confidence due to the negative comparisons to Heifetz that some of the press were making.( Menuhin talks about this in one of his books) Thirdly he suffered from an ( undiagnosed i think) shaking disease.Late in life you could see him shaking visibly. Still my favourite :)
shiveringflower 1 year ago
quoting ...Izzy Perlman..."Menuhin...the original wunderkind...his lutein...nobody better..."
politicopol 1 year ago 3
Great playing,as always.Vasa Prihoda's audio only version is also superb.(his filmed version is strangely slow)
shiveringflower 1 year ago
ya dejen de hincharme las pelotas comparando a menuhin con heifetz solo escuchen y comenten por cada uno tiene su estilo y tocan diferente
wexinger159quemier 2 years ago
excellent, but perlman's russia recording is still my all time fav
246trinitrotoluene 2 years ago
Although i myself prefer Heifetz i have to admit that iv yet to hear a better version of this being played by Menuhin. Sure Perlman is de best today he still never managed to get the sound off the fiddle that Heifetz and Menuhin got off there fiddles
gibsonpaddy 2 years ago
Menuhin and Perlman were great at playing this piece,I love it
rawautube 2 years ago
He's the best, beyond comparison!!!
Can never decide:
Should this make me play now or give it up for ever?! ;oD xxxxx
marloesCComm 2 years ago 5
Play now! Don't give up!! :)
MissCartoonist 2 years ago
i say never give up for somthing you think is worthy enough.
i play violin myself and this melody made me start playing..
gool luck! =]
alonline 2 years ago
Wow ! - I listened extensively to all renditions of this some time ago, before this was uploaded, but this knocks spots off them all for pure brilliance. He doesn't quite achieve Franscescatti's gorgeous lyricism though. I think people tend to neglect the fact that Menuhin's left hand was, IMO, as good if not better than anyone else's, perhaps because he often played things too fast and because other aspects of his playing let him down.
jaschenski 2 years ago
I'm speechless. That was truly marvelous. Never heard better.
calloffthedogs 2 years ago 3
Wow, this is beyond perfection.
ak47andawp 2 years ago
Menuhin is my favorite of all violinists. His control and precision were unmatched and yet his pure-spirited musicality, especially in later years, simply soared. His talent was matched with the best of instruments, a Guarnerius, I believe, with a tone as pure as any I have heard. One of my favorite recordings is his Bach sonatas and partitas in stereo, which I have on LP and cannot find on CD or elsewhere. His Beethoven concerto recording with Furtwängler is also the best I've heard.
DarthChuckster 2 years ago 2
my thoughts entirely...thank you noprodigyboy for bringing this to our attention
goroundit123 2 years ago
i agree but if i'm not wrong his violin was the stradivarius "soil". His beethoven is fantastic!!!!
Itachi1846 2 years ago
He did own the soil, but I think he sold it to Itzhak Perlman in 1986. He also owned the Lord Wilton Guarneri del Gesù.
DarthChuckster 2 years ago
2:14 Absolutely beautiful.
HKOverlord117 2 years ago
Wow......Amazing!!!!!
chocoluckystar 2 years ago 2
3:46 OMG!!! Can't sound sweeter than that! I don't know if he is the best, but he would be surely tied with Paganini.
pedrodot 2 years ago
yehudi is the best violinist
kwastormayt 2 years ago 5
You're Sure about that?
sirshungo 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Heifetz is de best
gibsonpaddy 2 years ago
What are you ? you treat the matter as it's an ideology!! every body know's that ! man
rawautube 2 years ago
My favorite interpretation of this piece.
elitetrooper4 2 years ago
perfect!!!
daividrick 2 years ago
When I saw Perlman's, I thought it was untouchable. lawlaw122 is right. Menuhin rises the bar in clarity and trills.
vioano 2 years ago 7
You're right cjh37878--only a precious few years for Ginette Neveu who died at 30 in a plane crash. This must be, I think, a very early recording of Menuhin. Do you know the date noprodigyboy? I'm thinking maybe he's 16?? The pianist??
Great, freewheeling, endearing playing by the boy wonder!
ipmoic 2 years ago
This piece was learned by all the advanced students of Jules Boucherit at The Paris Conservatory. Menuhin, Neveu, Ciompi & Bobesco all played it as encores for many years thereafter.
ipmoic 2 years ago
Not really many years for poor Neveu... she had so much talent...
At least Yehudi can lighten the tone for us with his recordings.
cjh37878 2 years ago
amazing...Yehudi...you brought us happiness...by your music and humanity...thank you...Rest in Peace
canxbuster12 2 years ago 3
i like how he plays!
elenagon1001 2 years ago 2
somehow i find this interpretation too fast even though it seems perfectly executed
themusicdr 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
he's no sense of rthym. watch perlman and then see how truly it can be played
25842685 2 years ago
is y'r thinking post-recording?
Neilhoven 2 years ago
what d u mean by post-recording? maybe u like him, i dunno, if so i like him too. but the problem is that he just made the same mistake, tried to play fast and ruined the originality of this masterpiece while trying to show how fast his fingers are. in terms of rthym, perlman plays it better than any other players
25842685 2 years ago
Recording technology changed the way artists played. In the same way that the invention of the camera changed the way painters painted. Yes, I love his playing too.
Neilhoven 2 years ago
1:09 ?????!! awesome
hildagrim 2 years ago
YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Neilhoven 2 years ago
how good are the tenths around 2:20.
nzmft85 2 years ago 2
they are all gods...
geoslav 2 years ago 3
Yes, but of the 3, Menuhin was the greatest at fast stuff, Perlman was all-around (not surpassing the others in their specialties), and Heifetz was vibrato and left hand pizzicato.
cjh37878 2 years ago 4
True master of the violin!
takamori400 3 years ago 24
Perlman had discussed this recording in the 'Art of Violin' documentary, and I'd been looking for it ever since. Thank you so very much for this upload!
puccinifan 3 years ago 2
perlman said in the "Art of Violin..." interview..."nobody better..."
Diamondmineboy 2 years ago
excellent recording, i love how he maintains a high tempo in combination with a clear and precise tonality, something that vengerov and perlman lack especially with this piece, if you honestly think they are good compare it with this, they play it too fast and yet can't manage their trills properly as Menuhin can
lawlaw122 3 years ago 23
you are right. this is played so precisely and clean for both notes and tempo
zhujun516 1 year ago 2
@lawlaw122 lol did u just say perlman can't manage his trills properly?
Tristius 1 year ago
@lawlaw122 this is a fantastic recording. i fully agree with everything u said about it. but i also LOVE Perlman's version. don't u like it as well? for me thats definitely one of the best performances of this piece.
Menuhin is a true master - AMAZING! :)
aweitzer1 1 year ago
@lawlaw122 Personally In think they all play this piece too fast. It always sound as they are playing twenty to the dozen. If the tempo had have been just a touch slower then this would for me have been a perfect interpretation. Mind you with the free VLC player you can now actually slow the music down and not lose the pitch.
DrMontague 11 months ago
@DrMontague Dr Montage you’re a hypocrite!
Look at all the people who have flagged your comments as spam and voted you down,
You have complained about people voting you down…..
Yet “YOU” block people from commenting as soon as you don’t like what they are saying when pointing out your wrongs, and you then “Nah Nah Nah Nah” and block your ears by tapping the block user button.
There is a God and our God is “Good”
He is not evil , The evil one here is “YOU” Bad doctor.
Screwdriver2000 11 months ago 2
@DrMontague Oh well all your comments from now on will be flagged as spam
Telecom2222 11 months ago
@lawlaw122 I completely agree. Although, u have to admit that anyone that can play this like the 3 of them deserve some credit.
TheKrAzyViolinist 8 months ago 2
flawless.
inbisvontu 3 years ago
ive never been a fan of menuhin, but i must say this recording blows me away...brilliant
tennisballer17 3 years ago 5
good
emre010203 3 years ago
what a colourful sound!! the best recording of this piece in my opinion,i like perlman's and vengerov's too.thanks alot for sharing.
farzadvengerov 3 years ago