Holy shit..look at these fat fucking killing machines..men #8 in the world and women #3 for obesity and they cry about aid?? YT search "Fat Gaza"..these fuckers need a diet!! #3 for obese women IN THE WORLD..r u kidding me..these twats need a salad & learn how to leave some food 4 others in need..its repulsive watching these gluttonous beasts shovel food in their mouths and then cry "We are being starved"..u kidding..your eating food that can go to the people who r really starving..fucking pigs
Israel fully intended to enjoy normal economic relations with Gaza after it left, as evidenced in part by the facilities built along the border for precisely this purpose.
The border was open.
Then Hamas was elected to govern. The Quartet (the US, UN, EU and Russia) applied three simple
conditions: Hamas must recognize Israel, renounce violence, and abide by previous agreements.
Hamas refused all three, and instead chose to launch rockets, missiles and mortars at Israeli towns.
Shame on Arab-leaders...ShameShame on Egypt and Saudi Arabic.
They are the shame of all Muslims in the world. God bring them to the hell Inshallah.
God bless Hamas, Palestine, Hezbollah, All Muslims, Iran and Venezuela. Palestine is for Palestines. Maybe its now captured by US and Israel, but its only for Palestines.
They ganna win, no doubt about it! Maybe not now, but very soon. Iran is coming Israël, get ready for the hell.
Maybe we are loosing our brothers and sisters in there, but Israel never should win. Because, Palestine is Palestine and it will be for ever. 1,5 milliard Muslims are behind there country, Palestine.
Get rid of Hamas and all pro-palestinian terror groups!!
The palestinian people and other radicalised young muslims (there are loads here in the UK)need to be educated and shown that growing up with hatred and racism in their hearts will end up being used in propaganda videos/used as human shields and without a friend in the world to fight their 'cause'!!!
fuck hypocrite israel,,drop bombs and then offer aid! such is the mind set of these kike nigger ass jews! fuck you evil demons! rot in hell you israeli sub human assholes!
yes i agree, they bomb them into tomorrow then give them 900000 dollars...but then how do we know they are giving them $900000???? because hillary pillary says so? and we believe this war mongering woman, i think she is building Palestine up for the time it is returned to the israelis, its just a screen she hides behind...think about it...does this woman tel the truth?
hamas will be around and they will retaliate against EVIL KIKE MOTHERFUCKERRS! ISRAEL WILL NO RETALIATION LIKE NO OTHER@! FUCK YOU ISRAEL YOU ARE THE PITS OF HELL,,LUCIFERS PEOPLE! ISRAELIS DESERVE TO DIE! CANT WAIT TILL HAMAS BLOWS YOUR KIKE KIDS HEads off! fuck hypocrite satanic jews!
G-D will destroy you and evil people like you. You just wait. See the revenge G-D ALMIGHTY has in stored agains't you. You think G-D is a joke? You think G-D is a lier when He says that those who attack Israel G-D will destroy them? Look at history, look at all the evil empires, they have been destroyed people like you are soon to be history. G-D is the Greatest.
Are all US politicians OK with Apartheid and Ethnic Cleansing?
Will Israel EVER obey International Law?
Why does the US veto every single United Nations SC action against Israel when Israel breaks the law?
Why doesn't the US Media use the words "Occupation" or "Violation of International Law" and that ISRAEL HAS TENS OF THOUSANDS OF HEAVILY ARMED SOLDIERS ON PALESTINIAN LAND?
Ha-aretz Newspaper January 25, 2002: The military commentator Amir Oren quoted an Israeli officer in the occupied territories as saying that his commanders must
"first analyze and internalize the lessons of earlier battles - even, however shocking it may sound, how the German army fought in the Warsaw ghetto".
Well, watching how Israel harasses and terrorizes Palestinians I am not surprised. As Palestinians resist and struggle for their independence, Israel manipulates the truth.
hi,i live in israel,and believe me that it is so sad for us too to know that inocent children and women die from our bombs.
here children and women die too.
israel sends a lot of medical stuff,and food to gaza, and also kids in gaza were treated in a hospital in israel"hakarmel".8 years southern israel gets bombs from hamas.we can't be in silence no more!.we must destroy the hamas, so israel will be safe.we and the phalastiniens are'nt the evil here.the only guilty in this story is the hamas
Are all US politicians OK with Apartheid and Ethnic Cleasing?
Will Israel EVER obey International Law?
Why does the US veto every single United Nations SC action against Israel when Israel breaks the law?
Why doesn't the US Media use the words "Occupation" or "Violation of International Law" and that ISRAEL HAS TENS OF THOUSANDS OF HEAVILY ARMED SOLDIERS ON PALESTINIAN LAND?
As Ariel Sharon once said during his millitary career - shall I say war crime years when he massacred villages and villages of Palestinians in a mass Zionist Displacement startegy - renamiing the village and changing history to make them Jewish. He then said why do you say America this America that don't you know we own America, and they will do what we say to do.
goto ifamericansknewDOTorg and learn about the evil that is Zionism
i am a syrian if you read youre history you'll know what i'm talking about there once was a country called greater syria after world war greater syria was palestine syria jordan iraq bits of turkey. we have a history of resustants for instant we resist all forms of occupation like the iraqis resisted the americans the lebanese resisted the israelies the palestinians resisted the israelies the jordanians resisted the PLO, so who fucked up the middle east the french and the british
Aside from prayers and comments people please lets do something constructive. Donate to charities like Islamic relief (online is sooo easy) who go out and help all over the world including th gaza strip regardless of race, religion or gender and has consultative status with the UN and is a major DEC (disasters emergency committee) member.
Am a tell you something some of you probably don't know about Arab Culture.
We all Arabs know that it's so easy to divide us. Our enemies see that and use that disadvantaged like Hamas and Fatah here. Fatah got the support of the U.S or whatever but if you look at the big picture they have the same enemy= Israel, and because that country knows it cant beat them together, it systematically divides them. I support Palestine, i think they should merge (hamas, fatah ) so life will be better.
Hamas was elected and supported by the majority of Gazans. Hamas has declared war against Israel and launches terror attacks against Israel. Hamas uses civilians(enemy non-combatants) as shields. This shows that they have no regard for anyone's lives. I think it is utterly contemptible that the same people who rejoice after another Muslim terror attack should not complain when Israel strikes back. The Gazans are just like the Jap and German enemy non-combatants in WW ll.
You mean the place that has declared war against Israel and is sworn to their destruction. Anyone who supports Hamas is a Jew hater or a complete dupe.
After the 1948 War, normal people who had lost a war would have faced reality and welcomed all Pallies as fellow Arab brothers in the huge territories they had. But no.
For 60 years we have had this fake refugee thing instead of a practical, peaceful resolution. Arabs have to look deep within to see the real enemy:......themselves.
Sad really... the Palestinian's could never really construct a viable country... failing to fight the Isrealis they only fight themselves...They are truly blessed that the Jewish state has not bulldozed their entire community into the Ocean....
All they have to do is renounce killing innocent Israeli women and children, and they will live peacefully in Gaza. They are the aggressors, not the Israelis.
Israel never even started doing that. Any innocent person that dies is a result of an ACCIDENT. They only target terrorists. If terrorists would stop firing rockets, the IDF would stop targeting them and there would be peace. If Israel were to stop, rockets would still rain on Sderot.
Ever seem strange to you how the resistance is regularly engaged as school is let out and the target is 'in the vicinity'? Don't kid yourself. Its genocide. "Accident" is an emotional response to the reality.
That's a laugh. Two points: 1. If Israel wanted to wipe out the Palestinians, they have the military capability to do it in 2 days. Nukes aside they have very heavy bombs. 2. Israel has a very strict policy of not harmingcivilians. Soldiers have been prosecuted for negligence. Explain that. This is unlike hamas that cheers and honors people in the street for killing israeli civilians.
LOL. Your trite hypotheticals reveal your shallow understanding of the situation. For having a very strict policy they sure do harm alot of civilians dont they? Soldiers prosecuted...thier little bread and circus has you fooled now doesn't it? Yawn... Go to Palestine, as I have, and get a clue.
I agree that lot's of civilians have been killed. That doesn't mean its on purpose. When you shoot a terrorist in a civilian area from a plane, it is tough to be perfect. The IDF is so moral that it often doesn't shoot when civilians are nearby, letting terrorists run free. Soldiers that intentionally kill are isolated incidents.
I am not sure where you get your info. According to every source I have read, only about 5000 Palestinians died since the intifada. Anyway, the point is that Israel does not target inoccent civilians. The ones that die are only killed by accident. This is why israel can't be compared to the nazis - because they have good intentions for all good people. Palestinians, however, kill innocent israelis intentionally.
are you american please open youre mind up don't watch the american news about the middle east it all controlled about the jews it only from the jewish point of view
I was not aware that I was being lied to by America. However, don't you think that American news is more likely to be true. It is a free press where people can freely speak about anything. Nothing is censured unless it is not backed by evidence. Islamic media, however, is heavily censured if the government does not like it. If what you are saying is true, wouldn't I have at least heard about it from all of the anti-israel publications that I read?
Furthermore, there are so many organizations that bash Israel constantly - (b'tzelem, peace now etc ...) - who stand up for palestinian rights every day. They have never claimed that Israel in general tries to kill innocent civilians or that 2 million pals died since the intifada. They are based in Israel and are free to say anything. Why didn't they?
what's that? is it a tv show? how can i view it? Also, I am not saying that it's inaccurate, but I think you should leave that option open in your mind. Please let me know how I can view it.
the other thing is, what does it mean when some one says HYE why do u give alot of attention to people we kill!!!why don't you go for epople in DarFur,Rowanda and leave us alone in this spot of the world killing this Palestinians.
shame on u all,if Hamas takes Money from Iran AND Hamas it self denies it then what should we say when FAtah takes money from the people who occupies Palestine(israel and U.S.A) CAN SOME STUPID IMAGINE THAT, then the whole world blames Hamas for somthing they creat to hold on their blames.
Why is everybody cocerned about israel/palestine, do you see anyone starving or homeless, they even have hospitals,schools, tv, they all are well clothed, What about the millions murdered and starving in Rowanda, Darfur, Cheyneya,ect, they would give anything to live in gaza.
bizarre. they're all a bunch of fanatics causing their own misery. they elected this messianic sect called hamas and now they lament their predicament. BS. they are a jihadi compulsive society that chooses war. boo hoo.
people act ignorant or change facts just to fit their myths and agendas.
Go to the Archives of USA, the country that made Irael, and search "Palestine", you will find documents about Palestine in the 1800's with Jerusalem as Capital. Also you could check the NY Times at that time. Also you could research your Univirsities and you will find that you only like to live a lie because you can
Il y'a 14 ans une jeune fille venais de fêter son anniversaire mais quand tout à coup un jeune homme l'étrangla maintenant que vous aver lu se message un esprit viendra vous voir toute les nuits sauf si vous suiver ces instruction :
Guess What, Tony Blair is being pumped up and prepared to be peace broker for ME,can you imagine how impartial he is ?
As PM he couldn't kill people of Iraq and Afghanistan, with him we will listen Alqaida has come to Palestine as well ?
Palestine was cohibited and is loved by All believers, be it Jew,Christien or Muslim.Except NEOCON and Zions, both keep people of their countries to be hostage of fear.
young polish Jew, who as usual in Sabbath, went to pray in his synagogue couple months ago, also didn't get his answer. He only asked, why can't he enter the temple. Instead of an answer, he got kicked.
- 'I saw this with my own eyes' - says Mike Urbaniak, the editor of Forum Of Polish Jews and correspondent of European Jewish Press in Poland. - 'I saw how my friend is being brutally attacked by security agents from Israel, without any reason.'
most of the people want israel back. its the fanatic blood thirsty sickos that want death and violence. israel gave them jobs and a decent economy. decent medical care and hamas gives them death and violence. chaos
in ireland it did not happen over night it took years there was a lot of hate and bitterness on boath sides. Yes its true that berty and blair worked hard . but if the ian pasley and jerry adams did not want peace it would not have worked. All they can do is try.
imagne a world where churches, mosques and synagogues stand side by side. where children of all religions play together. where people of other cultures party together. where we respect our differences and build on what we have in commune.Its time to look forward? time to learn from the past.PEACE is the only way forward.LIFE IS TOO SHORT
You need help katsiv, you are talking about humans. i see alot of hate in you . try praying God will help if you ask him.give love to people and you will be loved give hate and you will be hated.
What hurts me is to see little children of any religion be born into such violence The children are the future why do they grow up in a land of hate when its love that we have to teach to children. life is too short for war.
Correct me if i misunderstood, you want all of Israel? included Tel-Aviv, all of Jerusalem, Eilat, Ashkelon, Ashdod, Haifa, Tiberias , Beer-Sheva, Rishon-Lezion, Hedera, Natania, Rehovot etc... All of Israel? What a dream! but i think its more of a nightmare mainly for Palestinian people, because with such dream you doom your people for suffering countless generation to come...
JAJAJAJA!! un terrorista palestino reza para que Israel vuelva a gobernarles de nuevo!! JAJAJA!! ¿Donde quedó el odio a la "malvada ocupación israelí"?
MALDITOS DE HAMAS !!! ARRUINARONNNNNNNNN TODOOOOOOOOO......... MALDITOS !!! los palestinos no queremos mas muertes !!! han empeorado las cosas !! en vez d estar unidos como palestinos !!..... han logrado lo peor
Listen to the Palestanian man who talked about having Israel come back and rule. This is what I've been saying all along. There should absolutely be a sovereign Palestine. However, they need to get their own house in order before they make demands on anyone else. It so sad because all they seem to care about is HATE and as you see at the end of the video, they intend on passing the HATE on.
I hope God forgives you. You should pray for them that they will learn to live in harmony with each other and with god.I pray for you that you will see the light of your ways.
I'm sure they would prefer Israel to occupy gaza instead of the bloody fratricide their engaged in right now. If they're willing to kill their own brothers how can they be expected to live in peace with Israel?
You don't see UNSW as a great uni but you do see UWS as one? Dude UWS is the least prestigious uni in sydney. You only don't believe i go to uni coz i go to a better uni then you
No you see as long as you finish school in Australia then they can admit you into UNSW based on your Australian school performance. If you lived in Gaza as you said and came over here then you can't get into the university based on that can you. You'd have to wait till you're 21 and go based on a mature aged student
Bullshit. If you were accepted into UNSW then as if you wouldnt go. I could have easily gone to UWS. The Uai's to get in are way lower. It's actually harder to get into UNSW cause it's a much better university. I don't believe you would've possibly been accepted into UNSW if you're a 19 year old from Gaza. Cause you need to be 21 and a mature age student
I do go to uni. I go to UNSW. Where do you go?? I didn't mean literally bomb making. If you were doing a course to assist an organisation in which Australia classifies at terrorist, then you wouldn't announce it here. I bet you're just a Palestinian Australian who's never even been to Palestine. If you've seen some of the stuff Hamas has done you wouldn't support them
You're full of shit Aode, if you were doing a course to help in making bombs you wouldn't say it on the world wide net. I think it's funny how that Palli guy wanted Israel to rule Gaza again. Or is he yet another Zionist pig Aode? And unblock me. Why are you so scared to argue?
and how many lives do you think it will take . how many women and children will die on both sides before it ends. its a big price to pay for a strip of land that can be shared.I learned to share when i was a child. we can agree to disagree respect our differences live in peace.
Noble semtiments Liz but the Israelis dont want peace. Non-jews are treated as second class citizens in Israel and the Israelis keep voting human rights abusers like Sharon and olmert into power.Decent people around the world need to force the Israelis to the negotiating table or their atrocities will continue.
Grange In northern Ireland years ago people would have said the same thing that you say.Its very sad that so many people lost there lives in ireland before pease was made we can learn by the errors of others. dont you agree
That's because some woman in your past was shtupped by a Crusader or your family was originally Christian or Jewish and your ancestors were forcibly converted to Islam.
aode, and you certainly deserve hamas and the chaos they are bringing. You deserve your leaders stealing money from you and living in mansions while keeping the rank and file population impoverished. End the arab occupation of Israel! Am Yisroel Chai!
What do you need an education for? Aren't you gonna martyr yourself to kill Israelis? Or is that just the kinda thing you only expect others to do for you?
muslims killing muslims. If a muslim dies, there's a 90% chance it was another muslim who killed him. You see it in gaza, in iraq, in afghanistan, in egypt. Muslims are killing muslims everywhere you find them.
The pro- israel feeling seemes to be shared by the woman in "Canibalism 1" who states that the palestinian militants wanted to strip her when they attacked, whereas "not even the Jews did that to me"
what? muslims never attack the west. One incident is 9/11, but it was probably the Jews. THe West always attack muslims. The Holy land has been in the control of muslims for over 12 centuries. THe jews, christians and muslims lived there peacefully, until the Zionist Jews came and TERRORIZED the arab populace (both Muslims and Christians). You definately dont know your history
the "holy land" belonged to the jews far before islam existed. the "zionists" came and gave the "holy land" back to its proper owner, israel, judah. then islam started attacking the state of israel. it was owned by the jews b.c. then islam came and took it a.d. scattering judah across the world. then israel returned against all odds. exactly what is stated in the Bible.
This earth does not belong to us. We were put on earth by God to live good lives.All through history people have killed and died for nothing.all gods creations should live in harmony we have to love god and each
other.your religion is not important to love god is.
i am guessing this veiw of yours comes directly from your own mind. it seems as though you stand by no one religion but hold your own veiw of,"what you like, you beleive and you are for. and what you don't like you do not beleive and you are against." i being a christian beleive plenty of things that i wish were a tad bit different, because the being who stated them didn't kill for his people, he died for them..... and then rose from the dead.
We have no idea of the extent of that feeling - that Israel should go back in and take over - because it is very dangerous to say things like that!! But it is probably a pretty high number, especially among the 'older' population.
No act is too low, if it forwards the interests of the Left. No act is just, if it weakens that influence.
The Left murdered 100 million people last century in the pursuit of their interests. What makes you think they'd balk at a few million more now? Really now - where do you think the terrorists of the world are getting all the ordinance they fire off and use for bombs?
┼ It's not hard to figure out. Jooos are fighting for inhabited land. That puts them squarely on the side of injustice, and on the wrong side of the war for the territories
Where is the International Solidarity Movement? Where is Amnesty International? Where are the screams of outrage from the UN? Oh I forgot. Palestinian deaths don't count unless Israel can be blamed.
This has been flagged as spam show
Holy shit..look at these fat fucking killing machines..men #8 in the world and women #3 for obesity and they cry about aid?? YT search "Fat Gaza"..these fuckers need a diet!! #3 for obese women IN THE WORLD..r u kidding me..these twats need a salad & learn how to leave some food 4 others in need..its repulsive watching these gluttonous beasts shovel food in their mouths and then cry "We are being starved"..u kidding..your eating food that can go to the people who r really starving..fucking pigs
SRVClapton1990 1 year ago
im not sorry for u u are bad arabians FUCK U ALLLL!!!!!! im an arabian !! and i say thatttttttttttttttttt
U SUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK MOTHERFUCKERS U MUST DIE U KILLERS !!! U THIFESSSSSS
REPLAY ME 2 KNOW WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
b7bhak7be 1 year ago
2:40 - "We Pray that Israel will come back and rule us again" --- They wanted Hamas and they got Hamas.
extazy17 1 year ago
Israel nice people treat the people of gaza just as bad as hitler treated them what a world we live in the hey
wilkinson8707 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Israel fully intended to enjoy normal economic relations with Gaza after it left, as evidenced in part by the facilities built along the border for precisely this purpose.
The border was open.
Then Hamas was elected to govern. The Quartet (the US, UN, EU and Russia) applied three simple
conditions: Hamas must recognize Israel, renounce violence, and abide by previous agreements.
Hamas refused all three, and instead chose to launch rockets, missiles and mortars at Israeli towns.
razzer321 2 years ago
American bombs, coming to a country near you soon!
girlznguitarz 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Israel's latest war crimes:
Attempting to bulldoze houses with civilians inside.
Killing civilians trying to escape under the protection of white flags.
Opening fire on ambulances attempting to reach the wounded.
Using white phosphorous shells in civilian areas.
mixmatosis 3 years ago
Shame on Arab-leaders...ShameShame on Egypt and Saudi Arabic.
They are the shame of all Muslims in the world. God bring them to the hell Inshallah.
God bless Hamas, Palestine, Hezbollah, All Muslims, Iran and Venezuela. Palestine is for Palestines. Maybe its now captured by US and Israel, but its only for Palestines.
AFG2009boy 3 years ago
They ganna win, no doubt about it! Maybe not now, but very soon. Iran is coming Israël, get ready for the hell.
Maybe we are loosing our brothers and sisters in there, but Israel never should win. Because, Palestine is Palestine and it will be for ever. 1,5 milliard Muslims are behind there country, Palestine.
We are going to win, Inshallah...
AFG2009boy 3 years ago
Get rid of Hamas and all pro-palestinian terror groups!!
The palestinian people and other radicalised young muslims (there are loads here in the UK)need to be educated and shown that growing up with hatred and racism in their hearts will end up being used in propaganda videos/used as human shields and without a friend in the world to fight their 'cause'!!!
PeaceTruth2009 3 years ago 2
israel left gaza and gaza citizen choose the hamas. now, the hamas concerned the gaza
citizen life? no! the hamas only care about killing more and more israeli citizen!
the hamas send kasam and grad missile to israel and kill israeli citizen every day!
gaza citizen get killed only because the hamas shoot on israel citizen and soldier
from the gaza citizen. every day israel give the humanitarian aid to gaza citizen and
they send kasam and grad missile as a thanks...
kiilthehamas 3 years ago
fuck hypocrite israel,,drop bombs and then offer aid! such is the mind set of these kike nigger ass jews! fuck you evil demons! rot in hell you israeli sub human assholes!
phsyco348 3 years ago
yes i agree, they bomb them into tomorrow then give them 900000 dollars...but then how do we know they are giving them $900000???? because hillary pillary says so? and we believe this war mongering woman, i think she is building Palestine up for the time it is returned to the israelis, its just a screen she hides behind...think about it...does this woman tel the truth?
girlznguitarz 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I hope world is smart and see all things of fashists from hamas . When they finished kill jewish will start kill in Europe ...
Hammermaher 3 years ago
/watch?v=NjU_O7IRb34
debvillya 3 years ago
Hamas won't be around much longer, and that's a good thing for everybody.
SeanEdwardsCA 3 years ago
hamas will be around and they will retaliate against EVIL KIKE MOTHERFUCKERRS! ISRAEL WILL NO RETALIATION LIKE NO OTHER@! FUCK YOU ISRAEL YOU ARE THE PITS OF HELL,,LUCIFERS PEOPLE! ISRAELIS DESERVE TO DIE! CANT WAIT TILL HAMAS BLOWS YOUR KIKE KIDS HEads off! fuck hypocrite satanic jews!
phsyco348 3 years ago
@phsyco348
G-D will destroy you and evil people like you. You just wait. See the revenge G-D ALMIGHTY has in stored agains't you. You think G-D is a joke? You think G-D is a lier when He says that those who attack Israel G-D will destroy them? Look at history, look at all the evil empires, they have been destroyed people like you are soon to be history. G-D is the Greatest.
extazy17 1 year ago
CAUSE = OCCUPATION a 60 year bitter displacement and genocide against the Palestinian
CONSEQUENCE = Hamas an armed resistance of common people fed up of relying on the 2 faced subordinate to Zionist so called Western Democracies..
ALANSARALHAQ 3 years ago
ballsauce I liked it so much I reposted it :)..
Why do you US candidates do backflips for AIPAC?
Are all US politicians OK with Apartheid and Ethnic Cleansing?
Will Israel EVER obey International Law?
Why does the US veto every single United Nations SC action against Israel when Israel breaks the law?
Why doesn't the US Media use the words "Occupation" or "Violation of International Law" and that ISRAEL HAS TENS OF THOUSANDS OF HEAVILY ARMED SOLDIERS ON PALESTINIAN LAND?
ALANSARALHAQ 3 years ago
Ha-aretz Newspaper January 25, 2002: The military commentator Amir Oren quoted an Israeli officer in the occupied territories as saying that his commanders must
"first analyze and internalize the lessons of earlier battles - even, however shocking it may sound, how the German army fought in the Warsaw ghetto".
Well, watching how Israel harasses and terrorizes Palestinians I am not surprised. As Palestinians resist and struggle for their independence, Israel manipulates the truth.
soisthetruth 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hi,i live in israel,and believe me that it is so sad for us too to know that inocent children and women die from our bombs.
here children and women die too.
israel sends a lot of medical stuff,and food to gaza, and also kids in gaza were treated in a hospital in israel"hakarmel".8 years southern israel gets bombs from hamas.we can't be in silence no more!.we must destroy the hamas, so israel will be safe.we and the phalastiniens are'nt the evil here.the only guilty in this story is the hamas
mm2453 3 years ago
Why do you US candidates do backflips for AIPAC?
Are all US politicians OK with Apartheid and Ethnic Cleasing?
Will Israel EVER obey International Law?
Why does the US veto every single United Nations SC action against Israel when Israel breaks the law?
Why doesn't the US Media use the words "Occupation" or "Violation of International Law" and that ISRAEL HAS TENS OF THOUSANDS OF HEAVILY ARMED SOLDIERS ON PALESTINIAN LAND?
ballsauce666 3 years ago 12
As Ariel Sharon once said during his millitary career - shall I say war crime years when he massacred villages and villages of Palestinians in a mass Zionist Displacement startegy - renamiing the village and changing history to make them Jewish. He then said why do you say America this America that don't you know we own America, and they will do what we say to do.
goto ifamericansknewDOTorg and learn about the evil that is Zionism
ALANSARALHAQ 3 years ago
Celebrate the barbarians killing each other.
Maxwedge12000 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Mohammed was fucking pedophile and fuck all those insurgents in Iraq....take the quran and shove it up your ass
Eite Sharmota iben sharmota fuck islam the Qoran is trash and allah sucks
Fuck Islam.........
Bomb Iran - Bomb Iran now.
Muslim men mate with camels
Shoot a Muslim, save a camel
Eite Sharmota iben sharmota
fuck u and your mother fuck
fuck you Hamas Islamists I COME FUCK ALL HAMAS!!!
idfisrarel1 3 years ago
racist that what you are.you ara a fried of muslim you have only a big mouth
rachidma82 3 years ago
they are making us look like terrorists that pro jewish media
acg9mm 3 years ago
i am a syrian if you read youre history you'll know what i'm talking about there once was a country called greater syria after world war greater syria was palestine syria jordan iraq bits of turkey. we have a history of resustants for instant we resist all forms of occupation like the iraqis resisted the americans the lebanese resisted the israelies the palestinians resisted the israelies the jordanians resisted the PLO, so who fucked up the middle east the french and the british
acg9mm 3 years ago
look whats happening in the westbank now IOF{israeli ocupation force} are raiding lots of houses because now hamas is going into the westbank
acg9mm 3 years ago
Aside from prayers and comments people please lets do something constructive. Donate to charities like Islamic relief (online is sooo easy) who go out and help all over the world including th gaza strip regardless of race, religion or gender and has consultative status with the UN and is a major DEC (disasters emergency committee) member.
LearnB4judging 3 years ago
muslims are weak and dumb. that is why they were so easy to conquer as god demanded.
God hates muslims, that is why their not allowed in Israel.
I am a Proud christian and an american! Read the bible it clearly says muslims have no right to exist in the holy land. their all criminals!
that is why we put them in guantonamo!
Americans are the only christians waging the war against these rapists and are proud to be allies with israel to crush them!
Vote for Freedom in 08 by voting for McCain!
tigpoppa 3 years ago
tigpoppa...go die.
Amira94A 3 years ago
Those muslims will never win because they are divided by petty infighting.
I am a proud non-religious American Zionist.
14grig6perl41 3 years ago
Mcains a zionist
acg9mm 3 years ago
Am a tell you something some of you probably don't know about Arab Culture.
We all Arabs know that it's so easy to divide us. Our enemies see that and use that disadvantaged like Hamas and Fatah here. Fatah got the support of the U.S or whatever but if you look at the big picture they have the same enemy= Israel, and because that country knows it cant beat them together, it systematically divides them. I support Palestine, i think they should merge (hamas, fatah ) so life will be better.
internetshock 3 years ago 2
fatah will never merge with hamas because they are pro american
i suppport hamas because they are pro ressistant and remember all us arabs are resistent people like iraq,palestine,syria,jordan and lebanon
we will not let any person occupy our land but to bad there is corruption in this world
acg9mm 3 years ago
Hamas was elected and supported by the majority of Gazans. Hamas has declared war against Israel and launches terror attacks against Israel. Hamas uses civilians(enemy non-combatants) as shields. This shows that they have no regard for anyone's lives. I think it is utterly contemptible that the same people who rejoice after another Muslim terror attack should not complain when Israel strikes back. The Gazans are just like the Jap and German enemy non-combatants in WW ll.
jakefree24 3 years ago 2
free the biggest prison on earth. GAZA
FREESTYLE772 3 years ago
You mean the place that has declared war against Israel and is sworn to their destruction. Anyone who supports Hamas is a Jew hater or a complete dupe.
jakefree24 3 years ago 5
@jakefree24 Hamas is only protecting its people from Israeli Terrorists You r not Jews but evil Zionists
shadowofears 7 months ago
correct its a vitual prison we are not aloud in or out because of the wall
acg9mm 3 years ago
r u serious or just dum whoever that calls himself dmf2114!!!!
my goddddddddddddd
go bump ur head over the wall that u ADORE
raah79 4 years ago
ARABS....just that word sounds like a curse !
I thank you God I wasn't born one.
armenians4israel 4 years ago
After the 1948 War, normal people who had lost a war would have faced reality and welcomed all Pallies as fellow Arab brothers in the huge territories they had. But no.
For 60 years we have had this fake refugee thing instead of a practical, peaceful resolution. Arabs have to look deep within to see the real enemy:......themselves.
BooBooLane 4 years ago 3
Sad really... the Palestinian's could never really construct a viable country... failing to fight the Isrealis they only fight themselves...They are truly blessed that the Jewish state has not bulldozed their entire community into the Ocean....
andyacton 4 years ago
The Palestinians had a viable country,years before the bloody Israelis invaded.
TransientTarget 4 years ago
All they have to do is renounce killing innocent Israeli women and children, and they will live peacefully in Gaza. They are the aggressors, not the Israelis.
dmf2114 4 years ago
If only Isreal would renounce the same, at a ratio of over 10:1 compared to Palestinian resistance.
ayebretwalda 4 years ago
Israel never even started doing that. Any innocent person that dies is a result of an ACCIDENT. They only target terrorists. If terrorists would stop firing rockets, the IDF would stop targeting them and there would be peace. If Israel were to stop, rockets would still rain on Sderot.
dmf2114 4 years ago
LOLZ - Got crack?
Ever seem strange to you how the resistance is regularly engaged as school is let out and the target is 'in the vicinity'? Don't kid yourself. Its genocide. "Accident" is an emotional response to the reality.
ayebretwalda 4 years ago
That's a laugh. Two points: 1. If Israel wanted to wipe out the Palestinians, they have the military capability to do it in 2 days. Nukes aside they have very heavy bombs. 2. Israel has a very strict policy of not harmingcivilians. Soldiers have been prosecuted for negligence. Explain that. This is unlike hamas that cheers and honors people in the street for killing israeli civilians.
dmf2114 4 years ago
LOL. Your trite hypotheticals reveal your shallow understanding of the situation. For having a very strict policy they sure do harm alot of civilians dont they? Soldiers prosecuted...thier little bread and circus has you fooled now doesn't it? Yawn... Go to Palestine, as I have, and get a clue.
ayebretwalda 4 years ago
I agree that lot's of civilians have been killed. That doesn't mean its on purpose. When you shoot a terrorist in a civilian area from a plane, it is tough to be perfect. The IDF is so moral that it often doesn't shoot when civilians are nearby, letting terrorists run free. Soldiers that intentionally kill are isolated incidents.
dmf2114 4 years ago 2
Israel has a very strict policy of not harmingcivilians not true
acg9mm 3 years ago
and how many palestinians have died in these "accidents"
acg9mm 3 years ago
how many innocent palestinians died in this nakba so far 2000000+ israel is the closest nation to nazi germany
acg9mm 3 years ago
I am not sure where you get your info. According to every source I have read, only about 5000 Palestinians died since the intifada. Anyway, the point is that Israel does not target inoccent civilians. The ones that die are only killed by accident. This is why israel can't be compared to the nazis - because they have good intentions for all good people. Palestinians, however, kill innocent israelis intentionally.
dmf2114 3 years ago
are you american please open youre mind up don't watch the american news about the middle east it all controlled about the jews it only from the jewish point of view
acg9mm 3 years ago
I was not aware that I was being lied to by America. However, don't you think that American news is more likely to be true. It is a free press where people can freely speak about anything. Nothing is censured unless it is not backed by evidence. Islamic media, however, is heavily censured if the government does not like it. If what you are saying is true, wouldn't I have at least heard about it from all of the anti-israel publications that I read?
dmf2114 3 years ago
Furthermore, there are so many organizations that bash Israel constantly - (b'tzelem, peace now etc ...) - who stand up for palestinian rights every day. They have never claimed that Israel in general tries to kill innocent civilians or that 2 million pals died since the intifada. They are based in Israel and are free to say anything. Why didn't they?
dmf2114 3 years ago
watch occupation 101
acg9mm 3 years ago
what's that? is it a tv show? how can i view it? Also, I am not saying that it's inaccurate, but I think you should leave that option open in your mind. Please let me know how I can view it.
dmf2114 3 years ago
Thank "hAMAS" for your Power being cut OFF! Better buy candles Quick! Ha ha ha!
trooper4thcav 4 years ago
Way to shoot yourself in the foot hamas!! We were so close to peace until you bumbling idiots fucked it up with your idiotic coup! FUCKEN RETARDS!!!
redelman431 4 years ago
redelman-Stupid,inbread IDIOTS dont want PEACE! They just wanta BITCH and kill their own PEOPLE! Now watch them bitch when Isreal cuts there POWER!
trooper4thcav 4 years ago
eeerm the jews made divisions between the muslims, what a surprise! jews behind this,
cenile jewish settlers
scientist4eva 4 years ago
And Hye(hek).....why dont u go FUCK THE HECK UR SELF...or may be find some one to hick ur ass up.
kkkhl 4 years ago
the other thing is, what does it mean when some one says HYE why do u give alot of attention to people we kill!!!why don't you go for epople in DarFur,Rowanda and leave us alone in this spot of the world killing this Palestinians.
STRANGE JEWISH PROPAGANDA...!!!!!
kkkhl 4 years ago
shame on u all,if Hamas takes Money from Iran AND Hamas it self denies it then what should we say when FAtah takes money from the people who occupies Palestine(israel and U.S.A) CAN SOME STUPID IMAGINE THAT, then the whole world blames Hamas for somthing they creat to hold on their blames.
kkkhl 4 years ago
Why is everybody cocerned about israel/palestine, do you see anyone starving or homeless, they even have hospitals,schools, tv, they all are well clothed, What about the millions murdered and starving in Rowanda, Darfur, Cheyneya,ect, they would give anything to live in gaza.
midnightrider56 4 years ago
i was thinking the same after seeing the cambodian children then this...
victoriaaspen123 4 years ago
bizarre. they're all a bunch of fanatics causing their own misery. they elected this messianic sect called hamas and now they lament their predicament. BS. they are a jihadi compulsive society that chooses war. boo hoo.
wasabilou 4 years ago
people act ignorant or change facts just to fit their myths and agendas.
Go to the Archives of USA, the country that made Irael, and search "Palestine", you will find documents about Palestine in the 1800's with Jerusalem as Capital. Also you could check the NY Times at that time. Also you could research your Univirsities and you will find that you only like to live a lie because you can
zagzegnee2 4 years ago
Jerusalem was Israels capital in c.1000 BC...but this fact does not explain the savage fratricide in gaza today besides their innate desire to war.
wasabilou 4 years ago
Palestinians are beautiful people. specially that guy wif green eyes! Israelis causes the Palestine people to fight each other now.
skyrine79 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Il y'a 14 ans une jeune fille venais de fêter son anniversaire mais quand tout à coup un jeune homme l'étrangla maintenant que vous aver lu se message un esprit viendra vous voir toute les nuits sauf si vous suiver ces instruction :
Reecrire ce message dans trois autre vidéo
missiness63000 4 years ago
isn't it so much better in gaza after Isreal pulled back!
liberalism! is the DEVIL!
jcook681712000 4 years ago
Guess What, Tony Blair is being pumped up and prepared to be peace broker for ME,can you imagine how impartial he is ?
As PM he couldn't kill people of Iraq and Afghanistan, with him we will listen Alqaida has come to Palestine as well ?
Palestine was cohibited and is loved by All believers, be it Jew,Christien or Muslim.Except NEOCON and Zions, both keep people of their countries to be hostage of fear.
Fixhist 4 years ago
young polish Jew, who as usual in Sabbath, went to pray in his synagogue couple months ago, also didn't get his answer. He only asked, why can't he enter the temple. Instead of an answer, he got kicked.
- 'I saw this with my own eyes' - says Mike Urbaniak, the editor of Forum Of Polish Jews and correspondent of European Jewish Press in Poland. - 'I saw how my friend is being brutally attacked by security agents from Israel, without any reason.'
PolandSoldOutInYalta 4 years ago
most of the people want israel back. its the fanatic blood thirsty sickos that want death and violence. israel gave them jobs and a decent economy. decent medical care and hamas gives them death and violence. chaos
ykayman 4 years ago
AND? SO WHAT.
zartantheassasin 4 years ago
its statements like this that will ensure you will never rule the world or "your land" get off your wacko religion drug you idiots.
deftdrummer 4 years ago
Tony Blair and Bertie Ahern pressurised/encouraged all parties towards peace in NI.I dont see any parties pushing for peace in the middle east.
Grange34 4 years ago
in ireland it did not happen over night it took years there was a lot of hate and bitterness on boath sides. Yes its true that berty and blair worked hard . but if the ian pasley and jerry adams did not want peace it would not have worked. All they can do is try.
elizabeth91070 4 years ago
imagne a world where churches, mosques and synagogues stand side by side. where children of all religions play together. where people of other cultures party together. where we respect our differences and build on what we have in commune.Its time to look forward? time to learn from the past.PEACE is the only way forward.LIFE IS TOO SHORT
elizabeth91070 4 years ago
You need help katsiv, you are talking about humans. i see alot of hate in you . try praying God will help if you ask him.give love to people and you will be loved give hate and you will be hated.
elizabeth91070 4 years ago
What hurts me is to see little children of any religion be born into such violence The children are the future why do they grow up in a land of hate when its love that we have to teach to children. life is too short for war.
elizabeth91070 4 years ago
Correct me if i misunderstood, you want all of Israel? included Tel-Aviv, all of Jerusalem, Eilat, Ashkelon, Ashdod, Haifa, Tiberias , Beer-Sheva, Rishon-Lezion, Hedera, Natania, Rehovot etc... All of Israel? What a dream! but i think its more of a nightmare mainly for Palestinian people, because with such dream you doom your people for suffering countless generation to come...
IsraeliXdude 4 years ago
Funniest : muslims kill muslims
U Stupid donkey
joestone69 4 years ago
TejanoChimbo: Siempre es mejor echarle la culpa al otro, no?
AndresHerutJaim 4 years ago
¿no echaran ahora de menos al odiado Israel? ¿no querrán vivir bajo el yugo del estado judío opresor? je je je
AndresHerutJaim 4 years ago
JAJAJAJA!! un terrorista palestino reza para que Israel vuelva a gobernarles de nuevo!! JAJAJA!! ¿Donde quedó el odio a la "malvada ocupación israelí"?
JAJAJAJA! ahora que se jodan!
AndresHerutJaim 4 years ago
.
┼ The US and Israel are stoking a leadership war. Hopfully it won't engulf the general population, which hates to see it, and wants no part of it
TejanoChimbo 4 years ago
Oh... READ my glorious reply at markbnj dot blogspot dot com /2007/06/mideast-sick-to-my-stomach.html
markbnj 4 years ago
MALDITOS DE HAMAS !!! ARRUINARONNNNNNNNN TODOOOOOOOOO......... MALDITOS !!! los palestinos no queremos mas muertes !!! han empeorado las cosas !! en vez d estar unidos como palestinos !!..... han logrado lo peor
chibiproductions 4 years ago
Listen to the Palestanian man who talked about having Israel come back and rule. This is what I've been saying all along. There should absolutely be a sovereign Palestine. However, they need to get their own house in order before they make demands on anyone else. It so sad because all they seem to care about is HATE and as you see at the end of the video, they intend on passing the HATE on.
Morr6565 4 years ago
It's iran that is stirring up civil war
declantynan 4 years ago
I love these videos of these cockroaches killing each other!! We Demand More!!
AussieJTFer 4 years ago
I hope God forgives you. You should pray for them that they will learn to live in harmony with each other and with god.I pray for you that you will see the light of your ways.
elizabeth91070 4 years ago
I'm sure they would prefer Israel to occupy gaza instead of the bloody fratricide their engaged in right now. If they're willing to kill their own brothers how can they be expected to live in peace with Israel?
wasabilou 4 years ago
You don't see UNSW as a great uni but you do see UWS as one? Dude UWS is the least prestigious uni in sydney. You only don't believe i go to uni coz i go to a better uni then you
Decimated3 4 years ago
No you see as long as you finish school in Australia then they can admit you into UNSW based on your Australian school performance. If you lived in Gaza as you said and came over here then you can't get into the university based on that can you. You'd have to wait till you're 21 and go based on a mature aged student
Decimated3 4 years ago
Bullshit. If you were accepted into UNSW then as if you wouldnt go. I could have easily gone to UWS. The Uai's to get in are way lower. It's actually harder to get into UNSW cause it's a much better university. I don't believe you would've possibly been accepted into UNSW if you're a 19 year old from Gaza. Cause you need to be 21 and a mature age student
Decimated3 4 years ago
Lol UWS has nothing on my uni. Anyone can get into university of western sydney
Decimated3 4 years ago
I do go to uni. I go to UNSW. Where do you go?? I didn't mean literally bomb making. If you were doing a course to assist an organisation in which Australia classifies at terrorist, then you wouldn't announce it here. I bet you're just a Palestinian Australian who's never even been to Palestine. If you've seen some of the stuff Hamas has done you wouldn't support them
Decimated3 4 years ago
You're full of shit Aode, if you were doing a course to help in making bombs you wouldn't say it on the world wide net. I think it's funny how that Palli guy wanted Israel to rule Gaza again. Or is he yet another Zionist pig Aode? And unblock me. Why are you so scared to argue?
Decimated3 4 years ago
We love you Hamas.
Not all westerners are Zionists.
Would Hamas accept a white atheist as a soldier ?
I hope so.
Grange34 4 years ago
hope you get shot in the back by a "hammas" or PLO supporter
markbnj 4 years ago
and how many lives do you think it will take . how many women and children will die on both sides before it ends. its a big price to pay for a strip of land that can be shared.I learned to share when i was a child. we can agree to disagree respect our differences live in peace.
elizabeth91070 4 years ago
Noble semtiments Liz but the Israelis dont want peace. Non-jews are treated as second class citizens in Israel and the Israelis keep voting human rights abusers like Sharon and olmert into power.Decent people around the world need to force the Israelis to the negotiating table or their atrocities will continue.
Grange34 4 years ago
Grange In northern Ireland years ago people would have said the same thing that you say.Its very sad that so many people lost there lives in ireland before pease was made we can learn by the errors of others. dont you agree
elizabeth91070 4 years ago
yes I do
Grange34 4 years ago
And they are doing such a good job! Yippee!
efuseakay 4 years ago
tell me all Palestinians, how are gays treated in your country? What does Mohammed say about gays? The Qu'ran?
silverPjs 4 years ago
That's because some woman in your past was shtupped by a Crusader or your family was originally Christian or Jewish and your ancestors were forcibly converted to Islam.
TeachESL 4 years ago
nor do i want to.
sadly for the 'Palestinians', that hamas governs them.
ygalg 4 years ago
aode, and you certainly deserve hamas and the chaos they are bringing. You deserve your leaders stealing money from you and living in mansions while keeping the rank and file population impoverished. End the arab occupation of Israel! Am Yisroel Chai!
LaLi66 4 years ago
What do you need an education for? Aren't you gonna martyr yourself to kill Israelis? Or is that just the kinda thing you only expect others to do for you?
JusticeFish82 4 years ago
muslims killing muslims. If a muslim dies, there's a 90% chance it was another muslim who killed him. You see it in gaza, in iraq, in afghanistan, in egypt. Muslims are killing muslims everywhere you find them.
daytraderaz1 4 years ago
Says the guy who's living it up in Australia while his "people" are suffering.
JusticeFish82 4 years ago
The pro- israel feeling seemes to be shared by the woman in "Canibalism 1" who states that the palestinian militants wanted to strip her when they attacked, whereas "not even the Jews did that to me"
yfyai 4 years ago
This will be Iraq in 20 years or less if we or the UN maintains an occupation there.
IrrigatedPancake 4 years ago
sad days over there.
PETEYPOPOFF 4 years ago
i like how they say israel got forced to attack palestine, cuz of the rocket attacks. lol.
subhanrukh 4 years ago
This is just bizarre....
lamalo80 4 years ago
But but but Islam is a RELIGION OF PEACE! (Behead those that insult islam!)
Give them a country!
PrincepsSenatus 4 years ago
THEY have a country. IT's where MECCA is.
GO BACK there, and stop attacking the WEST!
OR just declare a Jihad, and attack EUROPE again!
markbnj 4 years ago
what? muslims never attack the west. One incident is 9/11, but it was probably the Jews. THe West always attack muslims. The Holy land has been in the control of muslims for over 12 centuries. THe jews, christians and muslims lived there peacefully, until the Zionist Jews came and TERRORIZED the arab populace (both Muslims and Christians). You definately dont know your history
arshadsyed 4 years ago
the "holy land" belonged to the jews far before islam existed. the "zionists" came and gave the "holy land" back to its proper owner, israel, judah. then islam started attacking the state of israel. it was owned by the jews b.c. then islam came and took it a.d. scattering judah across the world. then israel returned against all odds. exactly what is stated in the Bible.
llipskey 4 years ago
This earth does not belong to us. We were put on earth by God to live good lives.All through history people have killed and died for nothing.all gods creations should live in harmony we have to love god and each
other.your religion is not important to love god is.
elizabeth91070 4 years ago
i am guessing this veiw of yours comes directly from your own mind. it seems as though you stand by no one religion but hold your own veiw of,"what you like, you beleive and you are for. and what you don't like you do not beleive and you are against." i being a christian beleive plenty of things that i wish were a tad bit different, because the being who stated them didn't kill for his people, he died for them..... and then rose from the dead.
llipskey 4 years ago
Am I blind or whaat?
This guy in balaclava has green eyes??!!!
magabund 4 years ago
I just sent this video to Olmert! I told him that Gazans, themselves, want Israel to go back in!
TeachESL 4 years ago
We have no idea of the extent of that feeling - that Israel should go back in and take over - because it is very dangerous to say things like that!! But it is probably a pretty high number, especially among the 'older' population.
TeachESL 4 years ago
great vid.
rulllar 4 years ago
Kudos to the reporter for keeping it neutral.
mrfingersisalive 4 years ago
islam is death & death is islam!!!!!!!!!!
numkles 4 years ago
"We pray that Israel will come back and rule us again"
That says it all right there. Too bad the guy who said that will most likely not be available for comment next time around...
letsgoskatepool 4 years ago
No act is too low, if it forwards the interests of the Left. No act is just, if it weakens that influence.
The Left murdered 100 million people last century in the pursuit of their interests. What makes you think they'd balk at a few million more now? Really now - where do you think the terrorists of the world are getting all the ordinance they fire off and use for bombs?
DrCruel 4 years ago
Very sad. The world should see how these children are being brought up. Islam cannot rule itself but only through blood and suffering.
astronmr20 4 years ago
this is really good reporting...no bias whatsoever
mrgrieves9876 4 years ago
Religion of Peace my white rear-end.
philspice1 4 years ago
eventually agreed? Israeli hospitals always take Palestinians.
programmusic 4 years ago
Where are the human shields? The ones that set themselves up to stop IDF troops from arresting killers? ISM? Where are you in this mess?
Holed up in Israel, trying to figure out how to blame the jooooos.
myfreepress 4 years ago
┼ It's not hard to figure out. Jooos are fighting for inhabited land. That puts them squarely on the side of injustice, and on the wrong side of the war for the territories
TejanoChimbo 4 years ago
Where is the International Solidarity Movement? Where is Amnesty International? Where are the screams of outrage from the UN? Oh I forgot. Palestinian deaths don't count unless Israel can be blamed.
Sabraguy 4 years ago
Troo dat! Apparently as far as the UN and Amnesty International are concerned, Muslims cannot commit war crimes, only the U.S. and Israel can.
JayAreDubya 4 years ago
Stick your Jewish settlements up your ass
TejanoChimbo 4 years ago
what settlements brother? Israel moved out of the strip, remember?
astronmr20 4 years ago
┼ I know what you're not doing
TejanoChimbo 4 years ago
Really... Azza Is ALL yours. And MUSLIMS are killing MUSLIMS....
markbnj 4 years ago