Added: 5 years ago
From: 4356771
Views: 432,231
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (802)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Ms Underwood brings it!!!!!!

  • Carrie has done a Guns and Roses cover with Slash...do a search

  • Awesome job Carrie! I'm really thinking there ain't nothing you can't do! Totally AWESOME!

  • Who the fuck would prefer Fergie over this. Brilliant cover :) too bad Slash can't see that.

  • She could sing the phone book and still sound awesome!

  • American idol struck gold when they put this girl through. She's without a doubt the most talented person to come from that show. 

  • @Danklin24 Jennifer Hudson may take exception with this comment.

  • Sweet Child O' mine.

  • Schwing!!

  • Sing it GIRL!! You can sing the phonebook and sound awesome!!

  • Another blockbuster Carrie Underwood cover performance... she needs to make an entire cover album some day... she's the best in the business - look out Beyonce, Lady Gaga, or Katy Perry... Carrie is on another level...every time, its not even close... well Beyonce is pretty good live, she does work hard, but Carries combines talent, power, class, and humility in a way not seen before in music. Team CU !!

  • Too amazing. <3

  • Not bad, afterall... Some of the new "singers" cannot do what '80 singers did. But this is a very good version.

  • Carrie needs to take lessons from Gretchen Wilson!

    Carrie has talent and a great voice but these "rock songs"

    are not suited to her.....she can't work'em like Gretchen

    or Steive Nicks or Ann Wilson (Heart).

  • @KStarlet1967 gretchen wilson? LMAO . take lessons in writing crappy songs? singing the same type of song over and over ? being bitter over passing bhc?

    Carrie is a better singer than Gretchen can EVER hope to be, gretchen does NOT have the range for these songs.

  • @KStarlet1967 I disagree.. carrie nails this song and her rendition of heart's "alone" both on Idol and the ones she sang post idol are very good. When you have a voice as strong as hers.. you can pretty much sing anything.. and I actually think she rocks the rock songs quite well.

  • @KStarlet1967

    Carrie blowwwwwws Gretchen away!!! hello!!! She just sings white trash, country songs!!! Not good at all. That's why Carrie has won so many awards; she sings all types of music and looks natural and gorgeous in all her videos.  That's why she has national make up commercials, too!! Gretchen is only good at looking like trash and drinking draft beer good. yikes......

  • guitar player was bleh

  • Slash's guitar is missing.

  • @GuyWithBluePoop it just isn't as crisp as when Slash play it.

  • @TDM646367 Well who can compare to Slash? No one can touch the man.

  • @Greg7871

    STFU you idiot she has her own songs 13 straight number 1's so go suck a dick you idiot. Why would you hear a cover of a song when YOU KNOW you are watching with a prejudice mind, In your mind no one beats the orginal artist yet you make it a point to hear covers just so you can leave dumb shithead messages, do us all a favor and just stfu.

  • jesus is that a chello

  • Uhmm..WOW...Always thought she has a great voice, but this just blows me away. Great cover of a classic.

  • This is an awsome female cover!!

  • liking the half mic stand.. easy to see who her vocal hero is !

  • WTF?????? WHAT HAS SHE DONE TO SWEET CHILD O' MINE?????? this makes me prefer Fergie singing it!!!! GNR RULEE there's no need to fuck the song up ¬¬

  • carrie makes every song ten times better!! she's the best!! i love her so bloody much!!

  • what cant she sing?!!!...amazing :))))))

  • I I'll see her live on a free concert this summer""!!!!

    can't waittttttttttttttttttttttttttt­ttttttttt omgomgomg...

    (rockefeller center, at the today showwwwwwww.....she'll be there!)

  • carrie shows that she can sing anything she's awsome

  • You GO Axel Dudette! WOW....GREAT JOB!

  • Rip Rev

  • Nothing like the original but this cover is quite good, could be the best I've heard of this song

  • SO GOOD!!!!

  • Ich finde sie so gut, weil sie es einfach so macht. In Jeans und T-shirt.. Nichts Besonderem also und es sieht trotzdem klasse aus !!

    So eine tolle Frau ♥

  • haha that first guitarist doing the solo is shit, lucky his pal brings it back for him! good job seconf guy!

  • The guitarist does such a bad job of the solo...........

  • eh guitarists and their auto wahs...use a real one god damnit.

  • cool song version and HOT woman

  • I love both versions actually, Of course I love the original version....you can't beat classic GNR. But I really love Carrie's version too! She rocks!

  • She sang this too slow.For those of you who said this version is better,LOL. You seriously need to watch the original version by Guns N'Roses.Way better!Nobody can sing like Axl Rose!!!She's o.k. though:)

  • It was way too slow.She's o.k., but nobody can sing like Axl.And I don't know what version all of you have been listening to, but the original version by Guns N' Roses is WAY better than this.

  • i just want to ask some of u guys , who da fuck is axEl ??? come on people its AXL , its like "i love guns but Axel" fuck if u love guns u should know his names axl

  • In all fairness does Axl even know who he is? I mean, Really. Chinese Democracy has been promised IN FULL for 13 years!!! Where the FUCK is it!!!!?????? AXL can't keep a guitar player that wears a fuckin' KFC Bucket on his head but WE are supposed to give a flying fuck about his next project.?!?!?! Laughable horseshit!!

  • Holy smokes woman! That was freakin awesome! I am a huge GnR fan and that just about the best take I've ever seen on that song. That was incredible! I'm with the k98556, too bad Izzy and Slash weren't playing guitars, that would have blown the roof off the place. I bow to Queen Carrie!

  • Wow, you look "just a little" better than Axl!

  • It's good but I don't see what's so original. It's totally a copy--unlike Sheryl Crow's version.

  • Hey , I love guns n roses but I would rather watch this Sweet Child Of Mine sing than cracxel anyday !

  • Wow, that was damn good. Damn damn good. Only wish Slash and Izzy were backing her up. Wow.

  • really good....her vocals are amazing

  • I could be bias because she is one of my favorite artists. I know its all about taste but I dont see how anyone could not like this. Oh well Carrie is the best.

  • I like guns r roses. She is phenomenal live. I like this rendition of the song. A least she made it her own. Carrie is not like Axel but thats great because I like her the way she is. Carrie is the whole package.  I like watching her covers because to me she does a great job on them. I thought that when an artist covers a song they were supposed to make it their own and not do the original.

  • one of the greatest female voices of all time.

  • @zyesa i dunno about that. haha

  • I'm a huge Guns N Roses fan and was ready to diss this just because every other cover of this song I've heard is complete pants - but... and it pains me to say this Carrie has bought her own style to this song and not just tried to copy GnR's version -very good ;) xx

  • I love carrie and she did a real great job

  • she owned that stage.

    that was amazing..

  • wow! i love how carrie underwood can sing any genre of music and kick butt! i love this chick!

  • This was a great performance. If you don't realize that, then you know nothing about music. By the way, her guitarist is awesome.

    Yes, GNR is more rockin' and does this song more powerfully, but this was an absolutely stunning perormance. If you don't see that, just stop commening on music because you are simple wrong and ahve no taste or judgment.

  • i think she did pretty good....it was a lil slow but she made it her own and it wasnt bad...

  • prrr fofa!!

  • makes me appreciate the raw talent of GNR...lol

  • My thoughts exactly...

  • 100% real bad ass

  • Too slow for me...

  • And here's someone who didn't watch the whole video before commenting.

  • how in the world anybody can dispute a live performance like that . she is not axle rose, nor does she want to be. what she is, is the real deal.

  • esta versión no transmite nada, tocarla así en público es claramente hacer el ridiculo

  • Comment removed

  • was this at meritt bc it rocked

  • was this in merritt in bc it rocked

  • she must love gnr she has so many covers of them

  • My Gosh, she freakin rocks. How the hell can someone rock that much?

  • omg she can really sing anything and its even better than the orignal artsist

  • No one will ever beat GNR!

  • zomg shes good but the guitar sounds suckish.but overall, 7/10

  • does post work>

  • dam shes hot.

  • this girl seriously cannot mess up any song.

  • Its a gun and roses song, how in the fuck is not in some way gonna sound like axel? any of you fuckin losers that think she is trying to sound like him, low lifes, its a cover, get a life.

  • Comment removed

  • most people don't realize that shes copying axl rose with the mic stand and pretty much the whole performace.........i enjoyed it though........

  • I would drink her bathwater

  • that's sick....but kinda funny.

  • lol yaa it is....both :p

  • 1) NOBODY should Cover this song

    2) Carrie has done the BEST JOB covering this song that I've seen

    3) CARRIE UNDERWOOD>>>>Kelly Clarkson>>>>Sheryl Crow when it comes to female singers covering this song

    4) The only criticism I have is Carrie should have copied the dance that Axl Rose does when he sang this song live but other than that it worked {Simon Cowell Voice}

  • this is very beautiful, she is so good I can't believe it. but you have to admit it is f*ing good song. and don't forget that it was written and sung by a male singer. and axel didn't always suck. only most of the time :)

  • luv you Carrie

  • Pretty great...shes amazing

    love her

  • I LOVE U CARRIE =)

  • this is far better than guns n roses live. slash and axle sounded like a cat fight atop a car compactor. Slash played like he'd never picked up a friggin guitar and as far as Axl is concerned...hmm well. Guns n Roses sucked without a billion overdubs... sucked live.

  • she did really good thoughh, this song is extremely hrd to do because Axl Roses has a very unique voice, his vocals aren't good anymore but they were really good.

  • She was probably raised on this type of music.

  • good version of carrie.axl rose is the king of hard rock.

  • i like this version a lot better than the original. i never thought Axl had that good of a voice. And Carrie has an awesome voice

  • are you fucking high!?!?!?!?! Axl didnt have a good voice?? ha ha ha yeah ok.

  • axl rose is one of the greatest rock n' roll front men ever and thats not a long list....

  • she could sing everything & the kitchen sink and be amazing! :) I love you Carrie!

  • awesome. really like this version. i'm sure axl would appreciate that his work would translate into this genre.

  • Her version was surprisingly good.

  • good!

  • she sounds good

  • wow u got it all wrong

  • so david cook, carrie not credible? they sing 10 times better than the guitar heros you may applaud in bars. \

    and carrie actually is an amazing singer, one of the best in the world. sorry, wherever she came from, idol or not.

  • Goddess.

  • the "she come off as fake or smug" is quite baseless & ridiculous.

    If a person has talent, then he/she deserves attention and famous, period. If that person find out a fast way to be recognized, then good for him/her.

    Winning a reality show doesn't = instant success. Someone successes because he/she truly has goods to deliver.

    People who criticize her just because of AI boost need to blame themselves for their lack of luck or talent or commitment or....all 3 of them.

  • not that good... sorry :P

  • Godlike \m/

  • Simply one of the best American rock songs of all time.

  • she did kill it..never thought she could sing this kinda song!!!! notice the change in her voice ! @_@ the nbest American Idol ever...she's amazing

  • i think that female background singer for carrie is the hottest fucking thing.....

  • It seems like she noticed the camera at around 2:20 lol. She didn't kill the song, she can sing a lot better compared to people who think that she can't sing this song.

  • If we're talking about Carrie Underwood cover songs, then I would have to say that my favorite is when she did a rendition of Roy Orbison's "Crying". That is my all-time favorite. I think she did it for American Idol.

  • you are good... love it

  • lol the female country version of the song

  • song is awesome for her as well as when she did paradise city live during her carnival ride tour she's awesome no matter what she's singing..

  • Heh, her voice is always like that...go watch other live concerts of her.

    If you don't know what her voice sounds like from the beginning, don't try to make up stuff