@kriteon That's rather underhanded. When you create multiple masterpieces, and reach the level of popularity his music has, then you may say that the rest of his pieces aren't beautiful.
He plays this beautifully. However, this is not a beautiful piece. Shouldn't it have just a tad more scherzo? A little more lilt would make this a perfect performance. But it's still very good.
@TheLovelyPiano thats the point loveley piano. He has deliberately taken it slower than Kempf and all the others because he believes it should be at this tempo. If you want it faster listen to Kempf. I know which one I prefer.
i played violin for 3 years at the age of 20..(i'm going back to it soon, DV)..anyways, i learnt, self-learning, the first movement of this piece in only 4-5 months! and as arTToxcz said, you like it, you learnt it so easy.. it is not hard at all! i love MLS 1st mvt. since i was a little girl.. and i could teach myself what is already in my heart..i applied it with my fingers+practice! ;-)
5 Months is nothing to brag about for learning 1st movement, I learnt it after 2 weeks to play, (obviously longer to work on my interpretation I'm constantly finding new things), anyway that was after playing piano for 2 1/2 months
@Iliketorave1 Learning Beethoven in a matter of weeks is nothing to brag about either. The sheer level of emotion put into composing a piece like the moonlight sonata should be allowed to develop in a performer's playing. A person cannot fully play a piece (especially Beethoven) until it is within them, not only in their minds, but also in their hearts. It is only then that the beauty and deep complexity of his music can be expressed.
Mhmm...that's all cool, but what does that have to do with artists live and well today like Barenboim? I wasn't dissing others like Argerich (the only living one you mentioned). Barenboim isn't "unheard of." Of course the others you mentioned are great. That's no grounds to say Daniel Barenboim, a respected musician, is "worse than mediocre," because in fact he is excellent. It's hard to have an opinion saying he's not. You may not enjoy him as much but he's still a great pianist .
@maxhansendk It was useful to see the capital letters and exclamation marks on NOT!! because I wouldn't have understood the word without that help. Hope you don't play this very gentle movement the way you write. This is a beautiful piece, beautifully played, and the only thing I hear is the emotion and the structure perfectly entwined. That's the sign of a great artist, when player and composer become one.
He is (look at his legs), however, Beethoven specifically wrote on this piece to use as little to no pedal throughout the entire piece. Though Barenboim uses the pedal, he uses it sparingly,so I really love his interpretation!
@xXwaveXxdat I ment that he plays with the energy and the joy of a 17 Y.O. kid. Of course that his tecnique is only reachable with a lot of time and study...
i like daniel's playing, but i must say , that in this piece there r some passages he have played " by note " with violence and this piece is supposed to be quiet generaly .... i liked him better in the 3rd movement.... however, he is still an incredible piano player .... :)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Can someone pleeease help me out. Theres a group called Bond and they have a song called Allegretto, does anyone know the original artist and what is the full name? I've been looking for years and I can't seem to find it. Please help, anybody is welcome to answer. Thank you all.
Barenboim at Beethoven as you'd expect from him. True to the original, romantic style. Personally I think that's a good thing, though a little more "daring" in the dynamics or slight accents in the tempo sections might help an already great performance go through the roof :)
I feel that if there is going to be any criticism, it should NOT be offensive whatsoever, this is a video of an amazing piano player, there are many others to play Moonlight sonata here on youtube and i'm sure that they'll please everyone, but people: don't criticise as hard as you do, just search some other piano palyers and thats it
I like barenboim's interpretations of this and the moonlight; however I feel that the moonlight was performed at too great a speed and with less passion than possible; this movement is performed almost too slow and the bass in the Trio is not brought out sufficiently. Rock Beethoven
Um...this IS the "Moonlight". There are three different movements, but they're all the "Moonlight" Sonata. This is the second movement, as clearly described by the title...
This has no wit...no surprise,no dynamic as he glides tastefully comatose through almost all structural aspects.A PERFORMANCE FOR SHY AUTISTS ONLY.On Youtube Kempff buries this in a way that is almost against the Geneva convention.
Increible sentido de orquestacion, puedes oir una verdadera orquesta en la manera en que interpreta el movimiento, se me hacia aburrido este movimiento pero ahora veo un enfoque mas artistico a este movimiento.
hola oye yo veo todos los lunes master classes con daniel baren boim son super uenos
oye pregunto si tu te sabes los 3 Movimientos de la Moonlight es q si te sabes el tercero el del presto agitato ami me complica hacerla con las 2 manos osea con la mano izquierda xfa si sabes algo escribeme = vale adios
i prefer 2nd movement !! this has no tune :xx 1st is sad and slow it's perfect!
CandyLoveSteven 2 weeks ago
IMPECABLE !!!! ڰ✿ڰ✿ڿ✿ڰ✿ڿ
ivymabel 2 months ago
i prefer this movement over the other two...so beautiful its unlike anything else beethoven has ever written
kriteon 10 months ago
@kriteon That's rather underhanded. When you create multiple masterpieces, and reach the level of popularity his music has, then you may say that the rest of his pieces aren't beautiful.
CheeseBoyz 8 months ago
@CheeseBoyz i can say whatever the fuck i want who are you?
kriteon 7 months ago
Realmente maravilloso !!!
kalonice100 1 year ago
people are so violent - 'kill yourself' - what the hell is the point of such a comment ? no wonder this world looks the way it does ...
ophira1 1 year ago
This is better than Kempff
APRCVG188 1 year ago
Sorry PauuLiiZz, at 17 obviously you do not have the experience, musicality and maturity of a 65 year old genious.
toomuchmoretolearn 1 year ago
Like how the first movement is about 8 minutes, the third is 7 minutes and the second is about 2 minutes...
Nintendogene 2 years ago 5
He plays this beautifully. However, this is not a beautiful piece. Shouldn't it have just a tad more scherzo? A little more lilt would make this a perfect performance. But it's still very good.
TheLovelyPiano 2 years ago
@TheLovelyPiano thats the point loveley piano. He has deliberately taken it slower than Kempf and all the others because he believes it should be at this tempo. If you want it faster listen to Kempf. I know which one I prefer.
timsaxstanfield 1 year ago
dunno y i juz like mvt 1..and mvt3
augustinecool 2 years ago
lool.. same feeling ^_^
4028814 2 years ago
nice!
amantdemusique18 2 years ago
i love moonlight sonata at all..... mvt1 mvt2 and mvt3
9ballalex 2 years ago
I think its just about if you enjoy and feel the music you want to learn. If you like it, it should be easy.
arTToxcz 2 years ago 2
is this easy to play for someone that's been playing for 5 years?
superjam18 2 years ago 2
It's isn't that hard. The 2nd movement is often understated because of the fame of the other two movements, but nice nonetheless.
airplanedude550 2 years ago 3
sure! I've been playing for two years and I memorized this in a month. Not as good as this pianist tho T.T
hunterbender 2 years ago
it is not hard at all, 2mvt.!
i played violin for 3 years at the age of 20..(i'm going back to it soon, DV)..anyways, i learnt, self-learning, the first movement of this piece in only 4-5 months! and as arTToxcz said, you like it, you learnt it so easy.. it is not hard at all! i love MLS 1st mvt. since i was a little girl.. and i could teach myself what is already in my heart..i applied it with my fingers+practice! ;-)
4028814 2 years ago
@4028814
5 Months is nothing to brag about for learning 1st movement, I learnt it after 2 weeks to play, (obviously longer to work on my interpretation I'm constantly finding new things), anyway that was after playing piano for 2 1/2 months
Iliketorave1 2 years ago
well good.. seems you had a lot of time in comparison with a violinist :-p
4028814 2 years ago
@Iliketorave1 Learning Beethoven in a matter of weeks is nothing to brag about either. The sheer level of emotion put into composing a piece like the moonlight sonata should be allowed to develop in a performer's playing. A person cannot fully play a piece (especially Beethoven) until it is within them, not only in their minds, but also in their hearts. It is only then that the beauty and deep complexity of his music can be expressed.
keenboy1310 1 year ago
El que dice que es mediocre que intente tocar el piano.Daniel es un gran musico
jaschaheifetz87 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Worse then mediocre playing...
Sorry Barenboim...But you have no place among great piano players.
maxhansendk 2 years ago
You're a nobody, maxhansendk. You don't know a great pianist when you see one.
tfman15 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I consider Josef Hofmann the greatest of all time piano players! So do most professional collegues like Sergej Rachmaninov...
Claudio Arrau is second on my list. Rachmaninov is third.
Then comes players like Glenn Gould, Emil Gilels and Martha Argerich...
There are probably hundreds of "unheard piano talents"Extraordinaire..."
Barenboim is NOT!! among them...
maxhansendk 2 years ago
Mhmm...that's all cool, but what does that have to do with artists live and well today like Barenboim? I wasn't dissing others like Argerich (the only living one you mentioned). Barenboim isn't "unheard of." Of course the others you mentioned are great. That's no grounds to say Daniel Barenboim, a respected musician, is "worse than mediocre," because in fact he is excellent. It's hard to have an opinion saying he's not. You may not enjoy him as much but he's still a great pianist .
tfman15 2 years ago
Comment removed
ThePVGS1 1 year ago
Shut up.
APRCVG188 1 year ago
Comment removed
ingettorix 1 year ago
Comment removed
ingettorix 1 year ago
@maxhansendk It was useful to see the capital letters and exclamation marks on NOT!! because I wouldn't have understood the word without that help. Hope you don't play this very gentle movement the way you write. This is a beautiful piece, beautifully played, and the only thing I hear is the emotion and the structure perfectly entwined. That's the sign of a great artist, when player and composer become one.
ingettorix 1 year ago
I GIVE UP! I BLOCK U!
APRCVG188 1 year ago
i liked it
GenQuietRiot 2 years ago
obviously he uses it..
MatteMacPiano 2 years ago
is barenboim using pedal or?
elisdagbok 2 years ago
i think you should use the pedal
shaddowrouge 2 years ago
He is (look at his legs), however, Beethoven specifically wrote on this piece to use as little to no pedal throughout the entire piece. Though Barenboim uses the pedal, he uses it sparingly,so I really love his interpretation!
godXofXpath 2 years ago
gaah, aint strange why it listen so diffrent. just cant make to hear any pedal.
elisdagbok 2 years ago
this piece is like a minuet... right???
brentbanaagbaab 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
but..he is jewish!?
Trazom89 2 years ago
Daniel Barenboim is the best piano player that i've ever heard...he's 65 and play like he's got 17
PauuLiiZz 3 years ago 47
i agree a lot but ive never seen a 17 y/o playing like Barenboim :P
Chopinco 2 years ago 2
@PauuLiiZz teenage freshness ? :))
l1ghtmaster 1 year ago
@PauuLiiZz sry i can't stand that. HE DOES NOT PLAY LIKE HE'S GOT 17!!!!!!!!!
He plays with the experience of a man, who got more to know in his life then the tiny unexperienced less of skill from a 17 year old child.
xXwaveXxdat 11 months ago 2
@xXwaveXxdat I ment that he plays with the energy and the joy of a 17 Y.O. kid. Of course that his tecnique is only reachable with a lot of time and study...
PauuLiiZz 11 months ago
It's so fantastic!!!Thank you for sharing!
wault511 3 years ago 2
you are pro
Elcomunisto 3 years ago
i like daniel's playing, but i must say , that in this piece there r some passages he have played " by note " with violence and this piece is supposed to be quiet generaly .... i liked him better in the 3rd movement.... however, he is still an incredible piano player .... :)
sarah143t 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
better of you for shure...
astilleros11000rpm 3 years ago
i know he's better than me... i adore daniel's playing , im just saying that the 3rd movement touched me a lot, but this one didnt.
sarah143t 3 years ago 13
And by the way, where is it exactly that it touched you?
Heru1805 3 years ago
it touched her feelings like it did with me
elisdagbok 2 years ago 2
@sarah143t I'm agree with you, i think he plays it with much more feeling than a real presto & agitato played
FiatObscuritas 1 year ago
@sarah143t yeah!! the first and the 3rd mvt are amazing!! this one is average
raoulhery 1 year ago
daniel barenboim is amazing!!
i have videos in my account
shirchay 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Can someone pleeease help me out. Theres a group called Bond and they have a song called Allegretto, does anyone know the original artist and what is the full name? I've been looking for years and I can't seem to find it. Please help, anybody is welcome to answer. Thank you all.
nbcs 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It's Allegretto by Karl Jenkins
aleciccio89 3 years ago
Barenboim at Beethoven as you'd expect from him. True to the original, romantic style. Personally I think that's a good thing, though a little more "daring" in the dynamics or slight accents in the tempo sections might help an already great performance go through the roof :)
Palkab 3 years ago
I feel that if there is going to be any criticism, it should NOT be offensive whatsoever, this is a video of an amazing piano player, there are many others to play Moonlight sonata here on youtube and i'm sure that they'll please everyone, but people: don't criticise as hard as you do, just search some other piano palyers and thats it
LuisCaicedo 3 years ago 2
I like barenboim's interpretations of this and the moonlight; however I feel that the moonlight was performed at too great a speed and with less passion than possible; this movement is performed almost too slow and the bass in the Trio is not brought out sufficiently. Rock Beethoven
cathydoc2 3 years ago 2
Um...this IS the "Moonlight". There are three different movements, but they're all the "Moonlight" Sonata. This is the second movement, as clearly described by the title...
SaxHero 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This has no wit...no surprise,no dynamic as he glides tastefully comatose through almost all structural aspects.A PERFORMANCE FOR SHY AUTISTS ONLY.On Youtube Kempff buries this in a way that is almost against the Geneva convention.
smithsherman 4 years ago
Increible sentido de orquestacion, puedes oir una verdadera orquesta en la manera en que interpreta el movimiento, se me hacia aburrido este movimiento pero ahora veo un enfoque mas artistico a este movimiento.
manonpiano 4 years ago 3
hola oye yo veo todos los lunes master classes con daniel baren boim son super uenos
oye pregunto si tu te sabes los 3 Movimientos de la Moonlight es q si te sabes el tercero el del presto agitato ami me complica hacerla con las 2 manos osea con la mano izquierda xfa si sabes algo escribeme = vale adios
Faxtork 4 years ago
This has the "Allegretto' feel of a mechanized Rhinocerus in heat,chasing after a fly.Beethoven definitely would have recognized this...on LSD.
smithsherman 4 years ago
Sweetie, if you're not a music critic, you should take to the art. If not, post YOUR interpretation.
Otherwise, be a dear and kill yourself. Mahalo.
mishaonbass 4 years ago
damn that's stupidity, I hate the thing about that you can't criticize anything without being told to post your own video.. grow up, arse.
FredeGF 3 years ago 4
Absolutely agree with you.
Brahmsain 4 years ago 2
You seem to be an expert on Beethoven and LSD! :P Very related fields indeed! Keep it up.. were you sexually abused as a child?
liszt85 3 years ago