Added: 2 years ago
From: kevinvestfossen
Views: 34,035
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (123)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the lead singer is good. But the harmony singers are the real stars in my opinion here. They steal the scene away each time they both sing. 

  • LOL first line "my eyes are open wide" and his eyes are shut :p Great song though!

  • if you think that this version sucks or that Shinedown can't get down live then watch the Somewhere in the Statosphere live version from KC,,,fuckin awesome

  • I like it when Barry Kerch is on he makes that song great u need the drummer

  • Brent makes it happen EVERYTIME he sings! They sounded AWESOME!

  • this is the only band that had a song that helped me and help a lot more people i can say if i did not find this band i would have just been dead ..... this song saved my life <33333 :(

  • This version sucked

  • People dont understand he is one of the best singers around.

  • i love the combination of the two vocals :) just gorgeous!

  • WHY YOU SAY HE SUCKS i say pretty damn awesome... am i the only one who knows what's good when he hears it?

  • I like that they do different versions of their songs, it shows a lot of new sides of them, and the backing vocals are amazing! GHEEZUZ!

  • Check out: Shinedown - "Simple Man" - Carnival of Madness Tour as well as other videos from the "Anything & Everything Tour" - Thanks!!!

  • You all have to remember that is voice is used up a lot when they are out on the road touring. You can hear how raspy his voice is but you're gonna have that playing 4 nights a week on the road.

  • Original meaning the way the world heard it for the first time

  • Great song. But I hate it when bands stray so far away from the cd recording. Idk I guess I'm just one of those people who prefers originals.

  • Dowwnload the audio from this track at speedyconversion doht cohm.

  • heey guys checkk out my version of this and comment?! :D

    /watch?v=8Od62rSYnbU

    thankkks<3

  • brent smith is fuckin amazing live i saw them live.... you must be a fuckin retard

  • The lead guitarist is the one screwing up the harmonies. The guy on Brent's right is singing the actual melody (for the most part), while Brent is singing the lower harmony with some of the melody mixed in (during the chorus). The guy on his left isn't having a very good day here...

  • Look up the fox uninvited guest for a 10x better performance :D

    shinedown ftw

  • sorry shinedown fans bretts voice sucks live!! sully of godsmack blows him out of the water !! 

  • @slipknotftw1000 okay im a huge godsmack fan. They are amazing, especially live. But Brent's voice is truly amazing. Sully would tell you he doesn't have a great voice. he didn't even start until he was about 30.

  • bullshit hes bad live check out "shinedown in my house" on youtube brent sounds amazing just playing for a house party

  • If you think Brent sounds bad live, learn good music. With just a voice and acoustics, no fancy studios, these guys sound amazing. idk what the hell your all talking about, he has an amazing voice. If a band cant sound good with out studio effects and cant with just acoustic, then its not really anything to be impressed about. Singers have good days and bad days, so before you judge him about his singing, watch more of this shows and shut the fuck up

  • WOW UR ON FUCKING CRAACK IF YOU THINK BRENT SMITH SUCKS.! ITS THE FUCKING BACKUP SIGNERS but brent is fucking amazing go check out his acoustic shit , he sings so fucking awesome!

  • OFF.

  • Don't get me wrong, I LOVE BRENT, I do x3! He is AWESOME-NESS, ETERNAL & EPIC! And this acoustic verion is magically delicious. But, has anyone but me noticed, that in this particular video he is quite similiar to that of one Alan Rickman, the actor who played Professor Severus Snape in the Harry Potter series of movies? HAHAHA!!! Wouldn't lemme link a pic, but look it up! Brent my love, please, keep it on the more O-riginal tip, will ya, huh? <3

  • Well, two points of view on Brent's live performances. This band released acoustic versions of Simple Man, 45, Save Me, I Dare You, and Some Day. They should definitely release one for Second Chance after watching this. The acoustic version would be awesome!

  • @ericlord821 they have, check itunes

  • It's called an acoustic version! Friggin' awesome! Learn your music clown.

  • i personally love this version.. never hurts to change it up. I saw them live 2 months ago and he hit ALL the high notes

  • I don't know what you're talking about. His vocals seem pretty normal.

  • COME ON, that's just the way his voice is, and their fans LOVE it

  • yeah but still ... he is my fav band ... in the 1st place ... no other can take it ... i juz dont like him in live ...

    he didn't put much effort though he can i think ...

    my fav songs are save me,45,one,i dare you,trade urself in,someday,shed some light on me,breaking inside,2nd chance,call me ... but anyway man most of all his songs are damn good and touching lyrics ... unlike other singers ...

  • so HOW THE HELL can you think he don't sings live?

    90% of ALL live shows, he sound just as good as the studio versions.

  • @kevinvestfossen *cough cough* better than the studio

  • @kevinvestfossen nah im pretty sure its more than 90%

  • @silentkillersss are u kiddin me. he is so bad live. honestly he just doesnt have the voice to be live.

  • lol. I can agree during there live band sets, he often tries to hit notes he cant live, but acoustically he does a phenominal job because he doesnt try to hit high notes, he just stays in key. And what he does is interesting to hear. The studio version of their new album is so poppy, its good to hear their acoustic sets. It feels like theres some soul in it

  • @silentkillersss ive seen these guys live and they were just as good as they are on cd if not better...man you really need to see them live before u start making criticisms based on watchin one video

  • the lead singer is bad live ??? wtf, YOU MEAN THE Backuppsinger i hope..

  • Comment removed

  • @kevinvestfossen nope, guitarist on the left is a better singer than brent lol

  • @kevinvestfossen Very bad live... let it be written.

  • @frankmalboeuf the lead singer is AMAZING live dude.

  • @frankmalboeuf How could you say this is even remotely sub par on any part!?

    They've destroyed all mainstream bands with this remote performance, these guys are brilliant with the soul to back it up dood!

  • @frankmalboeuf this is brent smith, a vocal god, but i gotta admit his voice is quote hoarse here...u gotta check out all his old stuff acoustic live, he'l blow you away

  • @frankmalboeuf you must be a dumbass brent is one of the best vocalist ever!

  • This is an acoustic version of the song. Listen to the other versions.  Most bands do perform their songs differently acoustically and this one is very good acoustically. Yes, this song is sung quite high, but for certain occasions, the song is changed for that mood.

  • At least they didn't lip synch it like most bands do on shows like this.

  • I strongly believe that the singer just can't keep up with his own range that he puts out in the studio. Watch all the other youtube videos of them live, he can't hit the notes he recorded originally. he SHOULDNT put more on his plate than he can eat.

  • @GWBBrainwash Was just thinking the same thing. Pisses me off bad!

  • What are you talking about???Shinedown is one of the few bands at this kind of music with so beautiful music and lyrics..and his voice rocks..Great band,please dont talk about his hair just listen their music

  • That's a new way of lookng at things, and I buy into it! Make them come up with a different version for Sat Night Live. I like it.

  • Sorry I'm not myself. I just listened to the real verson, and now i understand why all the fans are pissed about this performance. Did they forget how to play it?

  • i thought it was great and songs should never be performed the same way the original verison goes

  • sorry I'm a bit testy. I am pissed at YouTube for taking off the real version and I miss it.

  • It's a great 90's song built for the third millenium. Let's cut them song slack. If this live version was the first time we had all heard this song, we would have voted for it. Otherwise, hey..YOU try singing live on TV!

  • I agree, his hair is a little silly, but hey he's in a band lol. I like it regardless :P

  • I meant the other guys' hair too. It's just not age appropriate. They're not 15.

  • I love the band and the song, but really, the hair is just silly.

  • wat's silly about his hair?

  • :( why did he change the song...... it was sooo much better before and he changed it when he performed

  • I love this song- I love Shinedown-I love Brent Smith-Awesome Voice

  • or maybe he just changed it for an acoustic performance, which most artists like to do...

  • There's this thing called voice fatigue, he's probably conserving what voice he had that day. Of course he can hit those notes, but the voice is just like any other muscle, it's gotta' be rested sometimes. So yeah, he doesn't hit the notes here, but I think he does damn well to compesate for it.

  • i'm a huge shinedown fan, i've seen them twice now. but this is an epic song, and i know brent can hit those high notes, but this is so boring to listen to. when, if he did hit those notes, i'd love to listen to this version more :(

  • i love shinedown i do...and i love this song. but this wasnt the best he couldve reached the note he did in the studio recording and also, no offense to long-haired people (i have long hair, too) and i know its the rock style but if u have to wave your hair from ur eyes 3:24 uve gotta cut it shorter

  • this song you can tell he say she waved

  • Great!

  • Awesome as always!

  • Fabulous as always! Just missed Barry. :(

  • Rocked it !!

  • I have loved you all for years! Just keeps getting better and better!

  • i wish he gave it that little bit more, i think it would've sounded better

  • same...i guess it was hard for him to reach the note.

  • Awesome!!! I recorded it on DVR:D Brent has an awesome voice. I could listen to his voice all day long:D

  • There's only been 3...

  • love shinedown!!! saw them in concert a few months ago and they were awesome! love all three albums <3

  • I love this one with Shinedown on the Today Show.,especially Brent Smith.Brent Smith is the greatest & the best singer in the world.I also love his beautiful face & long hair.I'm glad that I was able to record this on my video tape on the vcr while my family wasn't home.Shinedown is the greatest & the best rock band in the world.Zebrina

  • A-holes, quit commenting and dont watch it.

  • I love it. I think it would be better without the backup vocals and if Brent would let it out more :P

  • Comment removed

  • His voice sounds better with electric guitars, bass, and drums, trust me, ;)

  • haha did this guy just say that greenday and the white stripes are better than shinedown? hahahahahahaha

  • I dont understand all the complaining This is exactly how they have played this song acoustically on everything I have ever seen them on. He never singing the actual high parts live on tv. Its always a toned down version of the song. Live TV isnt exactly where you want to go for broke and sound terrible.

  • as good as Shinedown is, i dont think this is a very accurate portrayal of their skill. this wasnt one of their best acoustic performances

  • ok i'm done

  • thanks, asshole x3

    but why don't u like them, they have some very good music ^^

  • it's enough now, man...stop, please

  • is this is not real music... the for fuck

    NOTHING IS

    tell me what real music is, ''man''?

  • i love shinedown. that's a freaking gay hat though

  • Dang, was this just on yesterday? (Sept 2?)

    Just saw them last Fri night. Stellar, as usual :)

  • he has an amazing voice acoustic..i got the wonderful opportunity to hear them sing Simple Man live acoustic when they came to my town it gave me goosebumps all over his voice is an amazing raw talent not seen much these days!

  • i hope, for the next album...

    that he really uses his voice, for real...

    i has SOO much talent with his voice

    i'm sure he is not using 50% !!

    so, nor the next record... i think he is going to sing his heart out! (just a blind thought)

  • he*

  • Thank you so much for putting this online. I´m in Europe and we don´t have the show here.

  • me to, i live in fucking Norway ... i have awsome sources :3 !

  • she said that she thought he ~ Brent ~ was Meatloaf...... so not cool if your going to have someone on your damn show learn who the fuck the are!! but he handled it like the gentlemen that he is. now dont get me wrong i love Meatloafs music but damn to even think that Brent looks like him???!!?!?! WTF Hell No!.... ok Ill shut up now...lol

  • you weren't alone there

  • them two lady broadcasters are freakin idiots and are annoying as hell. I quit watching the today show because of those two. But I freakin love shinedown, thank god for youtube!

  • HAHAHAHAA!!! U r friggin hilarious! I so agree w/ your comments. I love Meatloaf 2 & immensely admire his talent (though Brent's is my fav) but the dude could be his father!

    I did like the one commentator singing word by word. That was so cool. Shows that SD is finally getting the attention they deserve more than ANY band around today.

  • This my favorite new band. The whole new CD is awesome. I think this a great acoustic performance. Keep in mind that these guys are usually sleeping at this time after a show, so they may have been a little sleepy, but still great.

    Thanks for posting. My DVR only got the first three hours too.

  • Thanks so much for posting this vid!!! I DVRed the Today show but only recorded the first 3 hrs. and they didn't perform till the 4th hr. so thanx alot man!!!

  • Oh yeah, and one more thing to all you haters, just keep in mind, this is acoustic...Brent's voice sounds better with Electric Guitars and drums and bass guitars in the background. I'd know, I've seen them live several time this year.

  • lucky you, i was hoping that they where comming to norway .. but NO

    i better hope for next year ^^

  • it never used to be like that, and personally i don't think that's the way it is now, all of his acoustic performances were such a better showcase for his amazing voice. but it's harder for him to do the little changes to the acoustic stuff that made it feel much more personal when he's got back up singers. That's why this is my favorite performance of this song yet, its got some of those little changes, a throw back to the old stuff

  • that was god'ish said...

    could't have said it better myself :)

    thanks for the comment ^^

  • Wow. It looks like Eric dyed his hair, and Brent cut his,, Aw, I liked Brent with longer hair. </3

    Shinedown is amazing. 'Nuff said. :3

  • saw this today, it made me laugh that the blond thought he looked like Meatloaf. this is my favorite acoustic version of the song.

  • "that blond guy" has a name, and he is amazing. :P

  • ive seen shinedown 3 times in concert and this is by far the worst performance of this song that i have seen them do. don't get me wrong i love shinedown, obviously, since ive gone to see them 3 times

  • You can't expect them to sound perfect! Psh. I don't like Second Chance anyways. I like the live version of it though. IDK, I think it shoulds OK considering the studio version sucks.

  • i wasnt saying they should sound perfect. im just saying of all the times ive seen them live they sounded so much more badass. just saying this performance isnt a good representation of their talent and brent's amazing voice

  • You removed Kathy Lee hehehe good ... very rude and stupid of her say that to Brent

  • i didn't get to see it when it was on, what did she say?

  • I didn't get a chance to watch it... what did she say to him?

  • what did she say???

  • nice

  • Comment removed

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more