I dont think they changed it too much or too little, I think its just a really weak, impotent cover... sorry dudes, all musical allegiances and biases aside... this sucks.
To all those saying that The Cruxshadows didn't do this justice because they didn't change it enough to give an original feel, sometimes a band just loves a song so much that they WANT to do it virtually unchanged.
@bilbosilbo dont contribute negative comments to beautiful songs just because it doesnt fit your taste and you can not yet understand the meaning and truth within the band.
A great PSB tune like this is greatful remix material for any electronic act..... I would really like to see VNV nation do an interpretation on this PSB classic! Crux fails a bit here because they dont really add something new to this great song musically speaking...
A great PSB tune like this is greatful remix material for any electronic act..... I would really like to see VNV nation do an interpretation on this PSB classic!
to the dumbasses who are too shallow and feeble minded to comprehend the cruxshadows: click the dislike button, flaunt your pathetic super-minority opinion, and then go shoot yourself. the end.
I wish I could be Rogue for just an hour, so that I could have an idea of what it's like to be so awesome. Really, he's pretty much the coolest guy alive.
I didn't even realise that this was a cover until just now. :P Why do so many good songs turn out to just be covers? But this is beautiful the first time Iheard it and still is
I hadn't heard the song before, that's why. It's not because I'm "retarded." A better word to use would be "ignorant". Also, I don't have much in the way of a life.
@TestaXDizzy Why on earth would you think that? It is never that simple. This is because no one is born evil. Not even Hitler or Stalin where. Lass If you don't understand the why of something you will never understand the what. Nothing is ever just black and white no mater how much we wish it was.
@heroheidr while i agree that noone is born evil i have to say that in fact everything is black and white no matter how much we want to see everything in shades of grey.
@Decimator16 : This is probably a matter of perspective, but... I find it to be just the oppostie. There is nothing so good that it does not contain some evil, there is nothing so evil that it does not contain some good. Where ever there is light, there is also darkness.
@heroheidr True bout that! (: ...And what is real evil? This that are clearly and lighting up can be more frightning and evil than things unknown in the dark.... :')
@heroheidr true but what i mean to say is that there is always a right and wrong choice, even if there are those that would think differently, look up the last two paragraphs of the book The Last Centurion by John Ringo(no spoilers there), his books are what introduced me to the cruxshadows in the first place
@heroheidr I've noticed that “God” is nothing but a codeword for “society”. Your comment has an interesting sound when read in this light: “If individuality is a stigma, perhaps it's time to change societies.” What do you think?
"For everything I long to do, no matter when or where or who has one thing in common too...it's a, it's a, it's a, it's a sin. Everything I've ever done, everything I'll ever do, every place I've ever been, everywhere I'm going to...it's a sin!"
We are all going to hell. Hope my basket has a seat belt. ;-)
@moshkenstein Fuck you, you retarded piece of shit. The Cruxshadows are most definitely not lame. You're the lame one, for not having anything better to do than to find a video by a band you hate, just to flame it. If you were gay? You probably are gay, fucknuckle. Be offended, nobody gives a shit.
@ElektrikShuffler HAAAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAA! Your YouTube name sounds like a villain from the 60s Batman TV show. "Holy shittastic musical taste, Batman! Its the Elektrik Shuffler! Use your Fallacio Repellent Spray!"
Linda versão dessa canção do Pet Shop Boys. Linda mesmo e a voz do Rogue
GyrgeFenrisnox 6 days ago
I like this more than the original !!!
Dirkvreugd 3 weeks ago
@Dirkvreugd
jep . . . .
TiburNeltoben 1 week ago
I dont think they changed it too much or too little, I think its just a really weak, impotent cover... sorry dudes, all musical allegiances and biases aside... this sucks.
warjunky444 1 month ago
saw these guys in concert and got to go on stage with them, they are simply amazing, no words to describe them :)
firemaker61785 1 month ago
I love Cruxshadows in so many artistic and personal ways...
Pinkspiderable 2 months ago 2
These guys have come to Nashville quite a bit in the past but I have somehow managed to never see them in concert. I need to work on that!
Steelwheels591 3 months ago
O yes Xd
gabrielrocha123 3 months ago
Comment removed
gabrielrocha123 3 months ago
Pet shop boys is better !!
darwleg 4 months ago
This is so good: it's a sin!
xD
winterknightx 4 months ago
If you were surronded by women liked that it would be hard not to make a move of some kind.
greenghost2008 5 months ago
@greenghost2008 He's married to Jessica, one of the dancers in the band. They recently had a kid.
outstretchedwings 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The Pet Shop Boys, have you heard...
basketcase2312 5 months ago
do as you will so long as you hurt none to hurt that is a sin
MrDead1972 5 months ago
As a ministers son I compleatly relate to this song.
MalfaidarCraven 5 months ago
It used to be all I heard from my Catholic grandmother—“It's a sin; it's a sin”—but “The word of Sin is Restriction.”
xXvolhvXx 5 months ago
Look up Horst couture. That dude, the one that does all that knows 3 of these people cause their his friends lol and he's my art teacher XD
TheRose545 5 months ago
HEHE i know 3 of the band members bands friend and somewhat manager lol. Hes also an artis plus photogropher and so much more
TheRose545 5 months ago
fantastic cover/well done
dalek1952 6 months ago
To all those saying that The Cruxshadows didn't do this justice because they didn't change it enough to give an original feel, sometimes a band just loves a song so much that they WANT to do it virtually unchanged.
OdinWolf74 6 months ago 11
@OdinWolf74 Very true. It must be a lovely feeling to master a song you've always loved!
loquatiousbadger 3 weeks ago
i prefer the old lineup ...
kbbyerly1 6 months ago
ahh not that bad of a pets shop boys cover .
brandoncipelle 6 months ago
I can't help it... I no longer am in the goth scene, but I still listen to Cruxshadows and stare at him as if I'm fourteen. SWOON....
onlyelise 6 months ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This band REALLY sucks
bilbosilbo 7 months ago
@bilbosilbo Yes you listened to them and though enough to make your stupid comment. Brilliant.
wynternight777 6 months ago
@bilbosilbo
Another poser comment, made by someone who belongs with the rest of the masses.
spinglasshydra 6 months ago
@bilbosilbo dont contribute negative comments to beautiful songs just because it doesnt fit your taste and you can not yet understand the meaning and truth within the band.
AkumaxTamashii 6 months ago
I love that they really made it more like their own style...
Hate covers who are exact copies of the original.
Love it...
DrFilch 7 months ago in playlist Cruxshadows (And sisters of mercy)
@DrFilch I agree, a Cover is meant to honor the original song not copy it exactly.
Drrailaa 7 months ago
they did a great remake of this song :)
i love cruxshadows
forbiddendreams69 7 months ago
They did The Petshop Boys justice with this cover.
40YearOldGirlgin 7 months ago
Still, after all these years..
Love them
SmokingRosey 7 months ago
Amazing cover!
meatballhead15 8 months ago
"WILL YOU FORGIVE ME! I TRIED NOT TO DO IT!!"Please, forgive me. I was always a terrible child!:(
NimwenEleniel 8 months ago
@NimwenEleniel xDDD
NimwenEleniel 7 months ago
@NimwenEleniel xDDDrandom
NimwenEleniel 7 months ago
great!
KYKLOPAS1234 8 months ago
love it!
villesangel69 9 months ago
Five people are too ashamed they would totally sin for Rogue. (I would).
LeftWingOfIcarus 9 months ago
love
AuroraLilyLauren 9 months ago
boah,ist das schlecht!...muss an der "Band" liegen :D:D:D
mpollonize 9 months ago
fail
pokopiko83 10 months ago
i love this version better than pbs
GothMetalhead999 10 months ago
A great PSB tune like this is greatful remix material for any electronic act..... I would really like to see VNV nation do an interpretation on this PSB classic! Crux fails a bit here because they dont really add something new to this great song musically speaking...
1976redstorm 10 months ago
A great PSB tune like this is greatful remix material for any electronic act..... I would really like to see VNV nation do an interpretation on this PSB classic!
1976redstorm 10 months ago
sehr geiler song!
SchwarzerFuchs1 1 year ago
Pet Shop Boys is amazing.
vaucemir 1 year ago 2
so powerless!
mpollonize 1 year ago
This seriously sucked and I really expected something different from the original.
This is like original but much flatter and monotonous.
BraceZenith 1 year ago
I'd go gay for all these girls around him. :)
dragmio 1 year ago
@dragmio that makes no since at all
winterbornfan 1 year ago
The Cruxshadows are the best band ever. It makes no difference what numptie views are posted here, they still are the best \m/..
islewytch 1 year ago
to the dumbasses who are too shallow and feeble minded to comprehend the cruxshadows: click the dislike button, flaunt your pathetic super-minority opinion, and then go shoot yourself. the end.
aesutton 1 year ago 3
@aesutton I like how both of you people that replied to me are in such an uproar
edhideous 1 year ago
@bloodycountess1313 I didn't, I stopped after a few seconds.
edhideous 1 year ago
This is pretty lame, really guys. Look at these silly nut jobs.
edhideous 1 year ago
@edhideous all i have to say is if you don't like it, DON"T FUCKING WATCH IT!
bloodycountess1313 1 year ago
@edhideous
ignorant fuck. you know nothing of them.
aesutton 1 year ago
Funnily enough, I saw The Pet Shop Boys "It's A Sin" on television the other day.
I always laugh at Sir Ian McKellen as a Vampire.
WoodRatGirl 1 year ago
@WoodRatGirl well, the video you've watched is Heart, not It's a Sin.
I DO LOVE the Pet Shop Boys btw, and still prefer the original version of this song, which is absolutely perfect, the way it is.
psbelena 1 year ago
Nett nice song !!
goebi72 1 year ago
This gives me chills
rockkerzz 1 year ago
By coincidence, when the Cruxshadows cover songs they always seem to be from my own list of favourites!
Have y'all heard "Here comes the rain again"? Eurythmics cover.
loquatiousbadger 1 year ago
Are those dismembered violins or what are the string instruments that look like violins?
SolarEclipse1897 1 year ago
@SolarEclipse1897 They're electric violins.
CruxshadowSeraphim 1 year ago
@CruxshadowSeraphim Sweet!
SolarEclipse1897 1 year ago
The Original is by The Pet Shop Boys. Circa 1987.
AFKJay 1 year ago
sounds familiar to clan of xymox, all i have
drknys117 2 years ago
rouge must have a very exciting life. Wish I had a life like that....Great art!!!
vampin6 2 years ago
@vampin6
I wish I could be Rogue for just an hour, so that I could have an idea of what it's like to be so awesome. Really, he's pretty much the coolest guy alive.
Dracoa79 1 year ago
hey, is this off an album / single / ep, or is it live only? Its one of the better covers I've heard - much better than And One's cover anyway
batslap2k 2 years ago
it´s a sin...
love it
anusielle 2 years ago
WOW! I love this. True it's not really different from the original...but this song suits his voice so well :) wOOt!
renate69 2 years ago 2
this is great!
villesangel69 2 years ago
cruxshadows has a tendency to make the covers they do sound better or as good as the origianl.
this song is no different.
RogueShadow89 2 years ago 5
I didn't even realise that this was a cover until just now. :P Why do so many good songs turn out to just be covers? But this is beautiful the first time Iheard it and still is
Kira666Uchiha 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
you're fucking retarded. how could you not know this was a cover?
bongobill635 2 years ago
I hadn't heard the song before, that's why. It's not because I'm "retarded." A better word to use would be "ignorant". Also, I don't have much in the way of a life.
Kira666Uchiha 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ok, you're ignorant. If your life sucks, you probably need to be fucking more dudes instead of staying on youtube all night.
bongobill635 2 years ago
I'm only 18. I haven't been around for very long. I probably wasn't even alive when that song was released!
Kira666Uchiha 2 years ago
LMFAO
cry0m0nkey 2 years ago
Why do I keep finding my favourite songs covered by the Cruxshadows?
Probably because the Cruxshadows have taste! :)
loquatiousbadger 2 years ago 5
@loquatiousbadger
I'm finding the same thing happen with my favourite songs!
loquatiousbadger 1 year ago
If being who you are is a sin perhaps its time to change gods
heroheidr 2 years ago 85
@heroheidr maybe it's a sin for a reason & not just beuracracy?
DarkFoxV 1 year ago
@heroheidr Exactly.
MRDxBlackRain 10 months ago
@heroheidr Unless, of course, you ARE the problem. For example, if your a murderer.
TestaXDizzy 10 months ago
@TestaXDizzy Why on earth would you think that? It is never that simple. This is because no one is born evil. Not even Hitler or Stalin where. Lass If you don't understand the why of something you will never understand the what. Nothing is ever just black and white no mater how much we wish it was.
heroheidr 10 months ago 14
@heroheidr while i agree that noone is born evil i have to say that in fact everything is black and white no matter how much we want to see everything in shades of grey.
Decimator16 4 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Crüxshadows
@Decimator16 : This is probably a matter of perspective, but... I find it to be just the oppostie. There is nothing so good that it does not contain some evil, there is nothing so evil that it does not contain some good. Where ever there is light, there is also darkness.
heroheidr 4 months ago 2
@heroheidr True bout that! (: ...And what is real evil? This that are clearly and lighting up can be more frightning and evil than things unknown in the dark.... :')
RezzKalozzTV 3 months ago
@heroheidr true but what i mean to say is that there is always a right and wrong choice, even if there are those that would think differently, look up the last two paragraphs of the book The Last Centurion by John Ringo(no spoilers there), his books are what introduced me to the cruxshadows in the first place
Decimator16 3 months ago
@heroheidr silly, you can never really change 'gods', all you can do is change the name that you call your father/mother by.
AkumaxTamashii 6 months ago
@heroheidr I've noticed that “God” is nothing but a codeword for “society”. Your comment has an interesting sound when read in this light: “If individuality is a stigma, perhaps it's time to change societies.” What do you think?
xXvolhvXx 5 months ago 3
@heroheidr a-fucking-men.
666Lachrimae666 5 months ago
Truer words could never be said:
"For everything I long to do, no matter when or where or who has one thing in common too...it's a, it's a, it's a, it's a sin. Everything I've ever done, everything I'll ever do, every place I've ever been, everywhere I'm going to...it's a sin!"
We are all going to hell. Hope my basket has a seat belt. ;-)
love2men4life 2 years ago 3
ensalada...
ensalada...
ensalaaaaaaaa...
Es Así!
patitomarto 2 years ago 3
@patitomarto lol
kunamoto2 2 months ago
woop ^_^
Deadcat323 2 years ago 3
This is real art!!! I love it!!!!
vampin6 2 years ago 3
When did this song come out?
Also, I'd totally go gay for Rogue.
KravenDS 2 years ago 58
@KravenDS Pretty sure you already are. This song is lame. This band is lame. If I were gay, I'd be offended by this shameless display of androgyny.
moshkenstein 1 year ago
@moshkenstein Fuck you, you retarded piece of shit. The Cruxshadows are most definitely not lame. You're the lame one, for not having anything better to do than to find a video by a band you hate, just to flame it. If you were gay? You probably are gay, fucknuckle. Be offended, nobody gives a shit.
ElektrikShuffler 1 year ago 2
@ElektrikShuffler HAAAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAA! Your YouTube name sounds like a villain from the 60s Batman TV show. "Holy shittastic musical taste, Batman! Its the Elektrik Shuffler! Use your Fallacio Repellent Spray!"
moshkenstein 1 year ago 2
@moshkenstein I'll reply to your comment later when I'm not too high to understand your horrible grammar.
ElektrikShuffler 1 year ago
@ElektrikShuffler Really? You're just going to procrasturbate out on me?
moshkenstein 1 year ago
@moshkenstein Now that I'm sotally tober, what was your desired message, sir trollsalot?
ElektrikShuffler 1 year ago
@KravenDS If you listen to this band chances are you would go gay for any guy.
ilheawdan 1 year ago
It's a sin that Rogue's so hot! >:D
DarkShadowMegadeth 2 years ago
I love the original version of this song but this is just fucking beautiful. There is no better artist that could redo this
Trystof 2 years ago
Sexy Hexieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
5stars
TomFicker von Mich <3
Ich liebe dich !!
N.T.B
Echt heel lovely =3
OrangeMermaidSarah 3 years ago 2