I hope you people know that is not Ian nor his voice in this footage. Watch "Here are the Young Men" video of the real live footage of Ian preforming the song Digital.
Ian Curtis died four years prior to my birth; how in God's name can one justify calling a posthumous fanbase 'poseurs?' Ian's legacy is immortal. While some might not fully grasp the extent of his creativity, it's difficult to justify such claims.
it doesnt mean anyones a poseur, 10 years ago there wasnt even a youtube. Now that its here, people "with" the videos have uploaded them and guys like you are here commenting on them
yeah but 10 years ago the internet didnt have anything close to youtube where people can leave comments. How do you know we werent watching them before on VHS? . If anything, your the poseur, the guy who thinks he's the only one whos really into joy division since day 1 and everyone else is below him, hahaha. 15 years ago I was ordering JD tapes through BMG, sorry I didnt let you know so I could get my official Joy Division card
So you´re calling us posers cause we couldnt find out about them? That makes sense. I always thought you were a true fan if you sincerly liked the music, no, you have to find out about them in some retro, unorthodox way.
Oh well as long as i get to listen to the music i dont care if im being called a poser or not.
woah woah woah easy, everyones entitled to an opinion i mean yes this documents ian curtis and joy division more because it's souly about them but 24 hour party people was about all the start of revoloutionary music in manchester starting off with post punk/new wave bands like joy division, the buzzcocks, the jam, the stooges etc then on to madchester music with happy mondays and new order, but as far as my opinion goes on a subject that has nothing to do with the point i was saying...
24 hour party people is better than this film: funny and entertaining, this films top notch but i like 24 hour party people better, can't deny that it's a shithot film?
i reckon he did a good job of it though to be fair, not all of them can sound just like them but that was o.k, tell you what though and here's a point for control over 24 hour party people at least sam riley who was playing Ian Curtis in this sung the songs instead of lip synching them like Sean Harris did when he played ian in 24 hour party people.
Feel it closing in, Feel it closing in, The fear of whom I call I feel it closing in, I feel it closing in, Day in, day out, Day in, day out, Day in, day out, Day in, day out, Day in, day out, Day in, day out.
This beat is bananas.
obunkystaind 4 months ago 7
after listening to joy division its hard to listen to anything else :/
bddb9 6 months ago 6
greaaaat song....greaaat band!....great...band and songs!....great!..., cheers, Bandogz.
BANDOGZ30 8 months ago
Is there an extended version of this like there is for some of the other Control performances?
TripleBuggerOff 9 months ago
This is excellent but rather soft om computer!
furakkueroru 10 months ago
absolutely brilliant
TheWheels777 11 months ago 2
I hope you people know that is not Ian nor his voice in this footage. Watch "Here are the Young Men" video of the real live footage of Ian preforming the song Digital.
AntiMusick 1 year ago
Ian Curtis died four years prior to my birth; how in God's name can one justify calling a posthumous fanbase 'poseurs?' Ian's legacy is immortal. While some might not fully grasp the extent of his creativity, it's difficult to justify such claims.
KingOfCarrotflowers 1 year ago
r.i.p ian
nickvanhornfilms 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
day IN! day OUT! day IN! day OOOUT!!!!
obunkystaind 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
day IN, day OUT, day in, day OUTTTTT!!!!!
obunkystaind 1 year ago
I did the Ian dance at a school dance senior year 4 years ago.
Nobody got it.
But i wish he were still here doing it.
deathbypowerglove 1 year ago 4
wombatts fuck off
zzbozz 1 year ago
Sam Riley deserves the Golden globe, the oscars, the BAFTAs, EVERYTHING for this performance. He will KILL as Kerouac in On the Road!
anniemihn 1 year ago 3
fuckin stupid , 24 Hour Party People's portrayal of this scene beats the shit out of this whole film any day of the fucking week.
StChiara 1 year ago
@StChiara cuz it was mimed i honeslty prefer this one cuz the actors actually made an effort to sound like JD not just mime them
0mgwtfbbq21 1 year ago
@StChiara you mean when they mime the song?
robertokeano 1 year ago
What a film!! What a fucking awesome acting performance!!!! Moved me to tears man
steverabbits 1 year ago 2
good job !
mickeybaumann 1 year ago
i love this song and band also this movie is amazing but the ending is definately depressing
metalxxxhead01 1 year ago
@RyogaXvX, I didn't know that Joy Division's music was limited for certain people. :]
Emmoth666 2 years ago 4
Im glad all the posers have finally recognised Joy Division. 10 years ago you couldnt find any of thier videos.
RyogaXvX 2 years ago
it doesnt mean anyones a poseur, 10 years ago there wasnt even a youtube. Now that its here, people "with" the videos have uploaded them and guys like you are here commenting on them
StrokedGT 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
10 years ago there was an internet, I downloaded JD videos all the time. And 10 years before that VHS and Books.
piss off poser.
RyogaXvX 2 years ago
I wasn't even alive in Joy Divisions prime, still like the band. The posers are arse wipes like you who think they own a right. Piss off you prick.
fookziz 2 years ago 6
yeah but 10 years ago the internet didnt have anything close to youtube where people can leave comments. How do you know we werent watching them before on VHS? . If anything, your the poseur, the guy who thinks he's the only one whos really into joy division since day 1 and everyone else is below him, hahaha. 15 years ago I was ordering JD tapes through BMG, sorry I didnt let you know so I could get my official Joy Division card
StrokedGT 2 years ago 2
@StrokedGT - - - LOL - - - Great post, StrokedGT. Did you ever get your "official" Joy Division card? You deserve one just for this post alone!
sidDkid87 1 year ago
@RyogaXvX your a faggot
somcop13 2 years ago
haha well your arn't you a lovely cunt.
fontTas 1 year ago
So you´re calling us posers cause we couldnt find out about them? That makes sense. I always thought you were a true fan if you sincerly liked the music, no, you have to find out about them in some retro, unorthodox way.
Oh well as long as i get to listen to the music i dont care if im being called a poser or not.
PullingTeeth1 1 year ago 4
haha i love tony wilson in the crowd..
texaschilibowl19 2 years ago 2
JOY DIVISION FUCKING ALELUYA!
ADESIREEZ 2 years ago 20
still alive
industrialnyleon 2 years ago 3
sam did such a great job acting in this movie
Toofairy 2 years ago 16
JOY DIVISION YOU CUNT
famAAAs 2 years ago 114
It's not better make a playback? from the original voice of Ian Curtis?
escons 2 years ago
i can defo imagine tony wilson in the middle of a boiling hot mosh pit wearin his frilly scarf and bouncing round like that ,,,,
legendary status was reached along time ago
grimkreaper 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i like 24 hour party people better
Gatakumo 2 years ago
are you crazy??? you dont have any idea what you saying!!!!!!
ADESIREEZ 2 years ago
woah woah woah easy, everyones entitled to an opinion i mean yes this documents ian curtis and joy division more because it's souly about them but 24 hour party people was about all the start of revoloutionary music in manchester starting off with post punk/new wave bands like joy division, the buzzcocks, the jam, the stooges etc then on to madchester music with happy mondays and new order, but as far as my opinion goes on a subject that has nothing to do with the point i was saying...
jrbrooks200 2 years ago
24 hour party people is better than this film: funny and entertaining, this films top notch but i like 24 hour party people better, can't deny that it's a shithot film?
jrbrooks200 2 years ago
i feel it closing in too brother....
totospirits 2 years ago 4
(L) (L) (L)
grapjee 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Nothing like the original, nothing.
zoeoz 2 years ago
i reckon he did a good job of it though to be fair, not all of them can sound just like them but that was o.k, tell you what though and here's a point for control over 24 hour party people at least sam riley who was playing Ian Curtis in this sung the songs instead of lip synching them like Sean Harris did when he played ian in 24 hour party people.
jrbrooks200 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the version from 24 hour party people was better.
malleymyster 3 years ago
What, the mimed version?
vaughanography 3 years ago 26
no-the better version
malleymyster 3 years ago
And which version is that?
vaughanography 3 years ago 8
the only one
sieke87 3 years ago
Haha
Polskapan 3 years ago
@malleymyster the better version are you a fucking moron
dbmcfc 7 months ago
@dbmcfc
nah youre a fucking moron, learn that other people have opinions. sean harris did a great job in 24
sam was pretty awsome too
guitar19904 7 months ago
@guitar19904 Haha what are you talking about, Im saying the actual song (which would be played if it was mimed) is undoubtedly better than this
dbmcfc 7 months ago
@dbmcfc
oh ok, but youre still a tool
guitar19904 7 months ago
@guitar19904 Your great gran sucked my tool
dbmcfc 7 months ago
@dbmcfc
wow youre into dead chicks. lol what a fag
guitar19904 6 months ago
TOTALLY RIGHT
TheSweetestBlood 3 years ago
You suck! this one is better!
playmobilbarrett 2 years ago
how do i suck, and why is this one better?
malleymyster 2 years ago
@malleymyster Joy Division you cunt!
TheSellarDoor 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i can do that! (his weird little seizer dances)
BeautifulMiseryandMe 3 years ago
i'm so happy they done this film well. sam riley needs a medal.
kanegills 3 years ago 90
I totally agree, and Anton Corbijn needs a medal too. I think Control was the best movie of 2007.
IrMiMaPi 3 years ago 30
I am a believer in Joy Division. Fockin' Hallelujah!
Ian Curtis, the best lyricist of the 20th century!
IsolationIsolation 3 years ago 27
I thought this was the only song Sam Riley actually sounded like Ian Curtis. He looks very like Ian Curtis as well!
7123526 3 years ago 2
love that bassline
josssmith 3 years ago 3
EPIC!
forcehu 3 years ago 2
Squab1972 3 years ago 11
Great!
BobDylan1201 3 years ago
Sam Riley didn't perform Ian Curtis. HE WAS Ian Curtis! Just a brilliant actor!!!
SoRazzamatazz 3 years ago 13
brilliant song, performed scarily like JD and tony wilson dancing-just great bit of the film
anna315 3 years ago 6
love that little bit of tony wilson in with the crowd, genius
l3inaryl3urnout 3 years ago 17
actually got chills
kcscene0 3 years ago 2
top film
Squab1972 4 years ago 7
best part of the film I thought, amazing track
Wenners 4 years ago 4
I agree
Someday747 4 years ago 3
loved this bit in the film,top tune
temporal76 4 years ago 2