Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (327)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Why does Rock Band even TRY to chart songs? Guitar Hero's charts are boss man!

  • Wat about GHWT or GHWOR

  • GH is more challenging that gay rock band

  • Rock band have more songs in the download list, Rock band is EPIK

    GH6 ist okeeee but GH3 is the best game ever

  • gh6 obscenely overcharted many parts of this song

  • @AdamLawI997 I am glad someone agrees to what I said

  • Rock Band also has: Yngwie Malmsteen, a lot of Jimi Hendrix, Iron Maiden, they have a song by the death metal band Atheist and another one coming soon. RB has Chaotrope, Lich King, Musica Diablo, Bonded by Blood, Infected Nations full album by Evile. The list goes on and on of great bands in RB. I have to say GH has lots of great bands too, but if you try to make it out that "RB only has Pop music" then you'll get called out for it.

  • guitar hero has better guitar and thats cuz they focus on that

    rock band has focused on the full band experience and each instrument challenge... but if you dont play pro guitar/bass the guitar on guitar hero is more realistic with tapping and the notes over sustained note ability gh has

    i prefer rock band since i like the pro drums mode as well as the rest of the band... but i mean i totally prefer playing guitar on gh

  • I have warriors of rock, its better.

  • I think they are both good.

  • The tab on here for guitar hero is more correct. for example in the main riff, the pulloff on RB goes to a green, when the real note is an octave higher than the palm muted green notes that follow, whereas in GH it pulls off to a higher note. just saying.

  • RB has better songs, but GH feels better all around.

  • tbh i find that guitar heros is easier to read and play but rockband does have a really good collection of songs.... but GH FTW :D

  • I think Rock Band is too easily to play... :/ It's better Guitar Hero!

  • rock band drums buttfucks guitar hero drums

  • Guitar Hero FTW way more complex!

  • Ok I'm going to go against my RB fanboyism and say that GH is more fun. But I'll always like Rock Band in general more because they have more great songs. GH has lots of great songs too and maybe more great songs then Rock Band percentage wise. But Rock Band has more songs I like since they have just a whole LOT more songs.

  • @megairondragondeth1 you make no fucking sense!

  • @megairondragondeth1 Well, think. What does GH have? Let's take a look: Nirvana, Metallica, Smashing Pumpkins, DragonForce, Ozzy Osbourne, even The Offspring! Rock Band: Lady Gaga, Britney Spears, Bon Jovi (country, saranade), and other artists it pains me to mention, (cough) (Paramore). Rock Band is a contradiction in itself. It says Rock Band on the cover but what do you get? Pop.

  • @heartshapedlife1 I love you an a non-gay way.

  • @matrex413 Uh, ok.

  • @heartshapedlife1 Uhm Rockband also has Nirvana. Metallica, smashing umpkins, dragonforce, ozzy osbourne and the offspring, so wtf are you talking about?

  • @wolff20o What I'm saying though is, RB copies GH in too many ways for it to be its own game. Guitar Hero had songs in it that Rock Band added as well. And Rock Band's song list sucks except for maybe 2 or 3 songs, that Guitar Hero already had. I'm also just saying Rock Band cancels out its own name FOR the songs it has in it. Lady gaga? Not rock.

  • @heartshapedlife1 So out of over THREE THOUSAND freakin' songs there's only 3 good ones? I want to see how many GH has. Besides, both games were made by Harmonix, so Rock Band is technically not copying. Also, who had other instruments first? As for the Lady Gaga being on, it's just appealing for the RB players that are into current music. At least RB had variety.

    My rant for the day.

  • @heartshapedlife1 Also for Guitar Hero: Slipknot, Rage Against The Machine, Disturbed, Motorhead, and STEVE FUCKIN' OUIMETTIE.

  • @matrex413 Rockband actually also has those bands, Rockband has like 8 songs by slipknot, guitar hero has 1 by them?

  • @heartshapedlife1 Well GH has Paramore, Bon Jovi, (possibly Lady Gaga as DLC, I can't remember and Rock Band has a ridiculously hard charted Operation Ground and Pound that has a harder chart than all of GH's dragonforce songs. Rock Band has Emperor, Rotting Christ, Watain (all great black metal bands). They have Sonata Arctica, Firewind (GH also does, but RB has more), Rock Band has two full albums by Megadeth. Rock Band has a lot of Nirvana, Ozzy Osbourne, and some of The Offspring.

  • @megairondragondeth1 But what do you have to do for most of these GOOD artists? You have to buy, and download them.

  • Everlong drums RB2 vs. GH WT

  • Rock Band 2

  • rock band is quite a bit easier ;)

  • the rock band is on expert??

  • if have GUITAR HERO dead D': and the ROCK BAND i will buy guitar hero its like compare an Lamborghini with an subaru

  • It's kind of funny Rock Band adds random hammer-ons in the beginning. For most people, in Rock Band strumming a hammer-on will most likely make you miss a note. Obviously, Guitar Hero version is better as you have a better chance of strumming a note. RB has off sync music, GH has better syncing. GH FTW. I love RB, but they just don't know how to chart correctly.

  • Rock Band !

  • whoa

    

  • i love that song...MEGADETH...MEGADETH...M­EGADETH...yeah!!!!

  • they´re just games!

    Fuck! learn how to play a real guitar

  • i like rock band better, but i really love Guitar Hero III! after that one it went downhill i think.

  • @Lampshrine95 Warriors of rock is the next best one (the others between 3 and warriors of rock are terrible)

  • @koxsuper5 or well i mostly think about the songs they come with so GHMetallica is ok too, and warriors of rock, you have to go through bad songs to get to the good ones.....

  • @Lampshrine95 Samething with GH3 you had to play bad songs to get the good ones

  • @koxsuper5 the songs in gh3 were good/ok, just a little easy, but you can't blame anyone for that, just the way it's made, but in the other ones the songs are both bad and boring. i don't wanna be a gh hater and stuff just don't wanna be misinterpred :P

  • @Lampshrine95 True very true

  • i can't live with the square notes :/

  • this battle isnt fair because guitar hero actualy had megadeth come in and do a recording session (that is how the song "sudden dead" was born)

  • Does anyone even know the difference between the 2 games?

    Rock Band: Has an actual recording from the bands and is charted to the same difficulty that the actual guitarist plays just on 5 buttons

    GH: Takes a track from their record and puts in the game and tries to do the chartings by ear.

    Which would you rather do?

  • @HNOTails You do know that the megadeth songs on GH:WoR actually had Megadeth come to their studio and do a live recording of the songs exactly the same as with slash, tom morello and buckethead, same goes with dragonforce. Yes they are both great games but rock band has went from to crappy mainstream shit while GH still has some rock left to actually put in their games. That's just my opinion but if you like it better then that's your opinion nd please don't comment me back acting like a moron.

  • @HNOTails Second choice equals more fun and rock band is nothing but covers while GH is all master tracks

    (Correct me if im wrong and show proof)

  • @koxsuper5 Well I really cant show proof cause for one RB doesnt show what they do for their games but I mean if you look at the GH3 TTFAF as a prime example. Yes I do admit it was more fun but yet it was the most impossible song they have today that's not a custom. But they charted the keys into the guitar part. There are many songs where the guitarist doesnt play but yet GH put other parts with it. I am just saying that you guys cant judge a song just by difficulty. You gotta think of accuracy

  • @HNOTails Not difficulty or accuracy........how fun it is, is what it all depends on I would be into rock band if it didnt have that precision (which is an extra in GH) locked in and was more playable like in GH

  • @koxsuper5 Well I do agree with the precision but the music variety is a lot better than GH. (especially now that their store has been closed)

  • @HNOTails well its not like people play guitar hero/rock band to learn to play guitar/learn to play songs,since you cannot(even with rb)learn with these,so i think guitar hero goes better exacly cuz its charted by ear,and its more challenging,and challenging=fun to me...

  • @HNOTails Guitar Hero

  • @HNOTails u c we dont no this

  • @HNOTails Umm, that's not even close to true. Because of how both are set up, BOTH require the original recording. If this weren't the case, then in GH, when you stop playing the guitar track, then you wouldn't be able to hear the song without the guitar in it. It would be impossible to do this without the original recording, otherwise the only two option for missing notes would be either have the song continue to play, guitar and all, or have the entire song muted. What you said makes no sense.

  • @Brockbfball1563 there are actually many programs out there that the average person can get that would stop just the guitar track when you stopped playing or any other part of the music track that they chose.

    Also i agree with @HNOTails cause Rockband has more accurate note patterns and a stricter timing system, you can be like half a second out of time with guitar hero and still hit the note, luls.

    Also, i own both RB and GH

  • @tommyxboy101 So there are programs that, even though all instruments are just on one track that HNOTails claims, they can single out JUST the lead guitar/rhythm guitar/keyboard/whatever instrument they chart at that time and have it stop playing without it sounding weird? I find that hard to believe, but even if there is, it's still not even close to true. And "more accurate not patterns" is almost entirely subjective, and GH1 has a way stricter hitting window, but does that make GH1 better?

  • @Brockbfball1563 "better" is just someones opinion on something, for example i like RB cause i like squares not circles :)

  • @tommyxboy101 I agree. For this particular song, I prefer GH's chart mostly because the HOPOs in RB's chart were all automatically placed and made some places, like the strumming in the main riff and the strumming at 5:26 in the solo, really awkward. In the past I usually preferred RB's charting of things, but recently I've been the other way. It's great that everyone has an opinion, but when people flat out lie to get people to believe them, like HNOTails did, isn't cool.

  • @Brockbfball1563 i like GH's 'noodling' feel with all the hammer ons that Rb misses mainly from it's choice of songs on the disk but you can download some like 'caprici di diablo - yngwie J Malmsteen' or 'satch boogie - Joe Stariani' I'm not advertising but they are some great songs.

  • @HNOTails Guitar Hero cause it looks and feels better? ;P

  • @HNOTails Rock band definitely has more realistic charting, but Guitar hero is more fun to play because of the less precise timing you need so you can play harder stuff

  • @HNOTails what da fuck are you talking about? in case you dont know the music that you are listening now was dave mustaine himself that was in the gh studios working with them to make the song for the game, do your homework kid , and you even know something called guitar hero metallica? .. forget it , you dont make any sense, how da fuck you got to the top comment blews my mind

  • @TheNanoWarriorPH Alright dude its just my opinion of the games to me cause I have played every single GH game so YES I DO KNOW THE FUCKING GAME. But I mean I just pointed shit out that is common in each game cause in my opinion the worst one was GHWOR cause the Expert plus doesnt even make sense. So just leave me alone.

  • @HNOTails  gh

  • @HNOTails awesome reply dude!

  • @HNOTails I don't give a fuck about that. I still prefer Guitar Hero because it's collaboration and sync is perfect. Unlike Rock Band, you lose way too many notes because their sync is off and collaboration is a brick. In this song's intro, RB had random hammer-ons which will make you lose notes as hitting hammer ons decrease your chance of hitting that note. It's not how they get the track, it's how the preformance of the game is.

  • @HNOTails i would play guitar hero because i want a fucking challenge

  • @HNOTails guitar hero because way more songs have double bass :3

  • ghwor

  • Rock Band sucks!!! Guitar Hero is best =)

  • @BoRrEgO99100

    yeah thats why they went broke =)

  • @BoRrEgO99100 yell heah it is

  • @BoRrEgO99100 Nah, Dog.

  • @BoRrEgO99100 Don't be such a kush, Rock Band> Guitar Hero because Guitar hero doesn't make games anymore because RockBand put them out of business. Guitar hero was too unrealistic and had fake recording from albums. Where in rockband they had live performances and used a monephero to chart them into the game.

  • @BoRrEgO99100 agree

  • @BoRrEgO99100 rock band is made by the people who made Guitar hero 1, 2 and 3

  • Tru dat.

  • @BoRrEgO99100 It's TRUE!! GH ROCKS!

  • @BoRrEgO99100 Then why was it discontinued? ;)

  • @BoRrEgO99100 Guitar Hero is not original since the third game because the first 2 ones where made by Harmonix then by another that i dont remeber the name but harmonix continued with rock band that is still with harmonix :D

  • @milin97

    Red Octane/Neversoft/Vicarious Visions

  • @Bowler211

    and rock band

    MTV games/Harmonix (the origins of guitar hero)

  • rock band all parts is sucks!!! i played all parts of guitar hero and all parts for rock band ....rock band is so stupid , so boring , notes do not get the music and sometimes you are played on guitar in rb3 when guitar not used and it is shit!

  • danny is playing ghwor

  • ghwof is WAY better then rock band but thats me so dont hate

  • GH over charts the shit out of every song. For competitive play this is great. However, Rock band is much more accurate with their charts.

  • GH is best ever. i dun kno why activisin cancil it, so much bettr than rock band

  • Rock Band makes it simple and somehow realistic...

    but Guitar Hero fucking breaks the rules and makes the craziest charts!

    GH WoR FTW!

  • To easy in rock band that why this game suck

  • Rock Band sucks!

  • rock band is alot harder then guitar hero but i like guitar hero

  • @demonjay50 you must suck then, cause rockband charts way too lazily. gh is much more difficult

  • lol gh always adds notes gh is based on rhythm rock band on lead guitar

  • Guitar Hero

  • Rock Band is for players with soft fingers ... (piece of shit) Guitar hero is the best interactive game that makes your fingers burn with a monster solo!! REAL GUITAR? HAHAHAH NO THNX! WATCH IT 5:20

  • @AnimeFantasyHD Hmm... That's some good logic... But can I ask you this? What if (Like me) You happen to like and Play both? Do you (I) have Burning/Soft Fingers?

  • GH is obviously better then RB!

  • Guitar Hero is far more challenging then RB ever will be, GH for life baby.

  • thumbs up for real Guitar!!

  • guitar hero warriors of rock

  • Guitar Hero rules!! I just don't like rock band even those notes look shit

  • guitar hero chart is better, but they both have their flaws. especially the rock band one. some sequences are really great though, especially on the guitar hero one, which gives a better feel when it's played. the rock band one is undercharted at times, and the guitar hero one is overcharted sometimes. so neither is perfect, but the gh chart is better. \m/

  • Rock band sucks dick guitar hero rules

  • guitar hero è il più fico

  • rockband sucks!

  • esta mejor guitar hero...

    aunk rock band le kiera dar batalla.

    no la ase... XP

  • Here is the Tricky part GH has way lots of complicated notres than Rock band

    Guityar hero guitar is easy to use Rock band Guitar is really crappy because the strum and the buttons are crappy

    i love guitar hero but rigth now im going with Rock band

  • I tried really hard to overlook the fact that Rock Band had flat notes (more accustomed to round ones O_O') but I still feel that, Rock band makes this song booring and too easy to play since they made the note chart use the orange button a lot less than on the GH version.

    I actually tried moving my fingers as if I was playing this song and looked on the RB side, but I didn't get the same intense feeling as when I played the GH version.

    Sorry RB fans, but my vote goes for Guitar Hero: WoR

  • obviously Guitar is a lil up there on difficulty vs RB, but I like playing songs that are kinda of like the song, rather then playing drum parts on guitar like GH :P. They were still about the same in this clip anyways besides for a few select parts.

  • GH FOREVERRRRRR!!!! crap u rock band (no offence) u suck rock band (no offence) and lastly ur notes look messed up (no offence)

  • compare satch boogie maybe?

  • Rock Band has much better song choice....

  • Fuck you rock band

  • ROCK Band No Sirve Ni Para el Arranque

  • and the notes are fuckin retarded on rock band

  • obviously guitar hero lol rock band sucks.....i fuckin laughed when i seen it like really? rock band

  • I think my issue with this is that is that song in rock band or was it just charted on some program?

  • Gotta say Rock Band just because I can't trust GH, its like they know nothing about guitar and they're making a guitar based game xD I mean "tap strumming"? Wtf is that? Its just tapping

  • 2 n e retard that tryed 2 call me out n say that gh is over ur a fucking dipshit why dnt u go on there website or there facebook they tlk about the new game all the time fuckin stupid kids

  • i think guitar hero wins in everything not just the charts..!!!

  • gutiar hero never loses!>:(

  • RB2 sucks ass!

  • I Like them both but i like RB better because the better song selection.... (DLC Store kicks Guitar Heros *ss) =p

  • jesus christ do people still compare the games in these series? I thought we were done with this comparison shit after Guitar Hero World Tour vs. Rock Band. Shit though, at least Rock Band isn't constantly releasing new games like Guitar Hero. The most Rock Band games ever release on the side is song packs. Well, that and RB: The Beatles and RB: Green Day

  • guitar hero are more hard then rock band and battery sucks in rock band because

    Guitar Hero drum kit:3Toms 2ride cymbal and a bass drum

    Rock Band drum kit:4Toms and a bass drum

    and in guitar hero we have +expert you need 2 bass drums

  • @afahalo Do you still live in the past or what?

    " Rock Band drum kit:4Toms and a bass drum"

    What the hell are you talking about?

    Rock band 3 Drums have 4 pads, 3 cymbals and 1/2 bass drums!

    And you're talking about "+ expert" from guitar hero? That sucks compared to Rock Band 3 PRO MODE! WHERE YOU PLAY LIKE REALITY!

    SEARCH ABOUT PRO MODE OF ROCK BAND 3 AND SEE WHO'S THE BEST!

    SEARCH ABOUT THE REAL GUITAR!

    If you play guitar in pro mode expert and you win, you'll automatically know in reality

  • guitar hero was the 1rst game with guitar and later rock band so if gh copy songs of rock band is good because the copy the game!

  • this song is originally in rb2?

  • For future arguments "Guitar Hero copied Rock Band songs" through out the years they always copied each other. The only difference is which one made the song charted nicely. "Rock Band is more accurate than Guitar Hero" how? They seem to have it down well no matter which notes are different. Over charted, under charted, there almost is no difference most of the time. For me on this chart I would say Guitar Hero did well on it and Rock Band didn't do bad either.

  • If u play guitar, you'll undestand GH is more realistic, yet they're fucking games and RB3 has "pro mode" so I'll say GH and RB are evenly matched

  • I have a feeling that Rock Band is going to go down the drain because they won't be able to look at Guitar Hero for reference for their songs.

  • @SubShadow123 Most of the Warriors of Rock songs were rock band DLC originally -_-

  • and also 2 add on to that rb is more realistic 2

  • all of u r retards 1st of all gh is making more games they r taking a break not stopping and i hate 2 tell all u gh nerds but not only is rb harder its better n thats coming from some1 whos ranked n owns at both games so u can blast me idc if u rlly played rb and looked at the leaderboards u would kno who i am

  • @xSh1T4Bra1nZx We don't give a flying FUCK who you are. Nobody is going to take you seriously when your grammar looks like that. First of all, why don't we look at who created the original Guitar Hero game? Harmonix. Guitar Hero 2? Harmonix. Guitar Hero 3 and beyond, Activision and Neversoft took over making the GH franchise. Harmonix created Rock Band. And we all see how that's doing. And by the way, go to Google and search "Activision pulls plug on Guitar Hero." Try doing your homework.

  • @shanesxe ok big mouth u r just another hater who plays on hard idc about u cause ur prolly 12 n r an online warrior who thinks hes cool trying 2 tlk shit 2 some1 on youtube but yea...no u r the biggest tard in the world dipshit if gh isnt making anymore games then why r they taking ideas from 1 of my friend and putting it in the game why do they always tlk about it on fb huh smart guy mr 12 year old who acts tough why dnt u tell me i would love 2 hear ur shitty answer big shot...ill b waiting

  • @xSh1T4Bra1nZx y d0 u tipe lyk dat? i7 mak3$ u lok fuckin tarded.

  • Guitar hero is not easiest in the slightest, rock band games take longer to beat and have more dlc, 3000, beat guitar hero in sales so much guitar hero is not making anymore games...... Ouch........

  • gh is always harder and cooler..

  • soo wat ur saying is rock band is horrible....i agree gh all dayy

  • What dificulty is warriors of rock?

  • gh is the shit like rock band is for pussy its way to easy

  • Guitar hero is more of a fekkin challenge. Playing this song on expert made me break my guitar strum by accident...

  • Guitar hero is harder and more accurate

  • gh all the way lol

  • I prefer Guitar Hero because the notes are more difficult, I do not like easy

  • how can i do this? GHWoR Vs. GHRB?

  • Guitar Hero has crazier stuff in their charts but the timing gap is much larger than Rock Band. Really I see no difference besides personal preference. I actually find many Rock Band song harder than Guitar Hero because you have to be more precise and I like that more. FCing crazy sections in Guitar Hero just doesn't feel as satisfying because it is too easy to hit but that is my opinion.

  • @13AWESOMEVIDEOGAMER

    But i got to keep it by reading your comment.

  • @13AWESOMEVIDEOGAMER

    THEY WHERE GOING TO TAKE AWAY MY BACON! :C

  • maybe its just me but i feel like the guitar hero chart has more patterns of notes where as on the rock band chart your simply moving up and down the fret buttons

  • A minute and a half before the singing starts...

    No offense i think Megadeth is great but that's one hellofa long intro...

    Also i request "Beast and the Harlot" GH2 vs. RB3

  • @13AWESOMEVIDEOGAMER

    i was forced to read this by the overlords of bacon.

  • rock band is too easy

  • rock band is soooooooooooooo boring when u play in easy but in guitar hero playing in easy is like playing in normal mode at rock band

  • Gotta admit after the solo it felt so real

    Like the lead nd rythm guitar tracks together

    I live both games but GH wins

    Their charting was more precise nd

    Difficult that's what their about challenge

  • guitar hero is way better

  • @thricedice activision said they're searching developers (por asi decirlo, soy español y mas omenos seria que activision esta buscando otra empresa innovadora que los haga)

  • I hate rock band's notes, they look like pills and the hopos are annoyingly difficult to see. I heard Guitar hero went under and won't be making anymore games though =[. I liked both of these games existing because they would use ideas from eachother's games to better their own game.

  • guitar hero charts shit and has shitty songs and dlc's. rock band has good charted songs and way more dlc's to enjoy on.

  • @THEREV468 True shit but Guitar Hero has metal songs.

  • @ZzFearz the only metal songs guitar hero has is pretty much just megadeth they are good but guitar hero needs way more then just them gh has like 6 rush songs in one game 2 black saboth and 4 megadeth instead of putting so many of the same band they should start putting in more. rockband has wway more metal bands then guitar hero and great rock songs old and new. guitar hero just sticks with alot of old stuff and the drum charts for expert is so wrong they can add a few more kick pedals.

  • and for rockband all tho they dont chart double bass everything is more accurate then guitar hero. and when u play almost easy from a7x its completley wrong watch the rev play almost easy on drums then look at the guitar hero drum chart

  • @THEREV468 No You need to look at Expert plus drums for guitar hero. Rock band only has expert.

  • @ZzFearz no i do mean expert not expert plus, they can still add a bit more kick drums for sure and for almost easy from avengedsevenfold was not talking about the bass drum at all i mean how they charted the pads. if u watch the rev playing it on his drum kit u will know what i mean about that

  • guitar hero wins

  • the notes of guitar hero looks cooler than the rock band notes but the 2 games are awesome